April Mayhem Round 2: Jimmy Eat World vs. Lydia vs. Gatsbys American Dream

[Anton Djamoos]

Which band is your favorite?

[Armor42]

Lydia by far

[kianacarly]

Jimmy Eat World is my favorite band, so vote went there.

[RAMROD85]

GAD is great, but JEW is better. Lydia isn't even in it for me.

[The Summer Ends]

Jimmy Eat World :-)

[chipdip18]

Hahaha JEW will throttle this poll

[Say Hello 87]

gotta love lydia

[Bobby Tucker]

Is there something that means a cakewalk and a landslide simultaneously. Because that is JEW in this one...

[TheOtherAndrew]

JEW by a lot.

[theguy77]

JEW by a lot.

this. futures is by a mile my favorite mainstream pop-rock record, and on my top 5 for pop-rock records in general.

GAD are alright but their music is way too scatterbrained.

[TSLROCKS]

Jimmy Eat World! Easily one of my favorite bands

[drudo182]

Gatsbys American Dream.

[xtheaudition]

JEW ! , DUH! haha

[boysandbulletsx]

I will be very surprised if JEW doesn't win this.

[chipdip18]

Gatsbys American Dream.

:highfive:

[DejaNew]

Easily JEW

[PatVaughn]

eh...i always seem to pick the bands that don't win. i went for GAD.

[chipdip18]

Pikajew!

[mrnegativezero]

Jimmy Eat World. Seeing as they have been guiding me through life this past year or so, they definitely get my vote.

[Keagan Ilvonen]

Toughest poll I have had yet. I love Lydia, but they can't compare to the effect the other two have had on my life. Jeez, I can't pick yet.

[Nick Le]

Jimmy Eat World, easily.

[ericsounds41]

Jimmy Eat World for me.

[XEmoBoyShandorX]

JEW>Lydia>GAD But is close between JEW and Lydia.

[chipdip18]

I love each and every one of you who voted Gatsbys.

[makeshiftmind]

Lydia...although it will probably be JEW in a landslide

[WhoSaidThat?]

Good Charlotte. :-d

[themadsilentist]

Voting for Lydia because I know JEW's going to win. Tough choice though.

[ashiex3]

Jimmy Eat World, easily. Still enjoy Lydia though.

[Ryzenfall]

JEW.

Lydia made a good run, I'm glad. I still don't understand the hype around Gatsby's American dream.

[Chris Fallon]

Jimmy by a landslide. Top 5 favorite, fo sho.

[Keagan Ilvonen]

I'm going to have to go GAD because of my man crush on <3 Nic <3

[relaxrelapse830]

Lydia, but JEW will win.

[chipdip18]

Gatsbys fans! Let's beat Lydia!

[Romancebled]

Gatsbys!

[bouttogetfancy]

Lydia

[kdefrisc]

shit.

[katieissweet]

Jimmy Eat World. I love the other two though.

[icarolina]

eh...i always seem to pick the bands that don't win. i went for GAD.

same here. sucks that they are so underrated.
=/

[TheGoodnightMoon]

I fucking LOVE Lydia, but had to give it to JEW due to their perfection of a catalogue.

[Hamlet]

If you're listening, whaaaaaooooaaaoooaaaoooooh

[Shatter_Glass]

JEW for sho'

http://www.morethings.com/fan/south_park/photo_gallery/eric-cartman-100.jpg

[CiaraX]

Definitely Jimmy Eat World.
There The Best =]

[zeropunk16]

Damn. Lydia's not even gonna come close.

[theguy77]

lydia are even more overrated by this site's "indie" fans (note the quotatoin marks) than manchester orchestra.

[AndrewIcex]

Jimmy is going to kill it. Gotta love me some JEW.

[CarryOn09]

jimmy eat world.

duh.

[patpratt]

honestly, this is the hardest thing ever.

[Broden Terry]

Lydia needed the votes but I love Jimmy Eat World too.

[burrito]

jew

[bobby runs]

Gatsbys even though JEW is pretty sick.

[lucygray]

Well dang, I seriously love all three bands.

[rickbarrera]

Clarity
Bleed American
Futures
Chase this light
Clarity Live

[Imperfektion]

Definitely JEW.

[Kbm600]

Lydia by far

This.

[jcoop05]

Went with JEW. I haven't listened to the other two that much :-|

[blender]

This isn't even close to fair.

JEW will trump Lydia any day. I do love me some Lydia though.

[nfmbf]

i love jimmy eat world..
:D

[famous_burro]

jew, no contest

[mycuban]

GAD, easily, their music is so genius.

[emkvetwin]

easiest choice so far... Futures is probably my favorite album. ever.

this band shall be my horse for the rest of the competition.

[3eb23]

JEW all the way

[notoaststereo]

jimmy eat world

[CarouselBoy]

This was easy for me, JEW

[VIVALAMATT]

JEW by a lot.

fo sho. easy win.

[irthesteve]

Even though I think Jimmy are more enjoyable, I voted GAD in this one. Fuck Lydia though

[MILFCORE]

JEW just blows the other two bands out of the water. They're a huge influence on many modern-day bands... Other two, not so much.

[b4_dRun]

Jimmy Eat World

[kazuma_ootaro28]

Jimmy Eat World for me, seeing as how I did not get the Lydia hype at all last year. I don't even like Gatsbys American Dream that much.

[matt_garland]

Gatsby's American Dream's Volcano is one of the best records I've ever heard. Mind you so is Clarity...

[EliteCombine]

Gatsby's American Dream all the way. Volcano and their self-titled album are both examples of sheer awesomeness!

[Jeannieanline]

there's no chance GAD and Lydia will beat JEW. JEW is way more popular.
I definitely voted Gatsby. I think they have more variety in their music, but I love the other two too.

[ringlord]

Lydia, based on the fact that GAD and JEW are good but have never done anything really outstanding in my opinion. I love Clarity and Futures, but I could easily listen to any other pseudo-pop band in their place.

[Dagless]

It has to be JEW.

[pblest]

gotta love the jew.

[walking_by91]

JEW but I do love me some Lydia.

[Iron Aeroplane]

Jimmy Eat World, but Gatsby's American Dream is very close.

[DogSizedBird]

Jew.

[fearthesloths]

As much as the other two bands rule this one has to go to JEW because they're JEW no other explaination required.

[stereokiller]

GAD. =)

though i know JEW deserves this and will win this.

[xjustinz]

jimmy eat world is god awful.
lydia by far!

[just.Starla.]

I love Lydia, but JEW was one of my first favorite bands, so I went with them.

[mmmmmpoetry]

Gatsby's, because I hate both of my hometown bands.

[color_coded]

I love Lydia, but JEW was one of my first favorite bands, so I went with them.
This.

[meeshdarling]

lydia is my favorite band ever :) cheers <3

[trappedintime]

Jew

[googirl8907]

Jimmy Eat World.

[fiercetown]

Jew!

[Indoor Living]

Oh, Lydia. You were so young.

[DaveZeroZero]

Gatsby's are my boyssss, but JEW should take it. I still voted for GAD.

[jtyexists9]

Jew = love.

[roju]

gotta go with jew

[live.]

Jeeeeeeeeeeeeeew

[ACA]

I voted for GAD just because JEW doesn't need the support.

[MADSTA]

JEW will destroy this one for sure. Good thing too.

[fadedmemories]

Stay Awake by Lydia

/thread

[RonStoppable]

Gotta go with Lydia

[owiseone35]

Gatsbys American Dream. Though i know they will lose.

[nickthehick2]

Lydia, I've never been a fan of the others.

[Kevtron650]

JEW is dominating

[batmannj]

Three great bands....I went with Lydia.

[Everiggs]

Jimmy.

[foisol]

Jimmy Eat World :)

[COTA]

Jimmy Eat World

[RelientAudio]

My goal here is just to see Lydia beat GAD. I've tried really hard but I just don't care for GAD.

JEW deserves the win though.

[Krupt]

I never get tired of GAD

[erinfxs]

JEW alles the way.

[Galedeep]

Jimmay!

[fadedmemories]

JEW has more posts than Lydia and GAD combined haha

[zubinmoosa]

I gotta go with Gatsby

[AEast317]

gotta be JEW, sorry gatsbys

[Melkor]

Jimmy Eat World.

[ninthandash]

jew, ftw.

as if the username didn't give it away.

[WFUJerseyJon]

Jimmy not even close.

[YouMeHimAndHer]

I do love Lydia but c'mon up against Jimmy Eat World? No contest.

[HelpMeSleep]

Gatsbys for me.

[CloseToShore]

Gatsbys, hands down. Sucks they'll probably lose though.

[I am Mick]

Lydia

[youngmountain]

It was pretty close between JEW and lydia although i suprised myself in the end and decided I prefer Lydia, though I can't say I'm that crazy about either.

[sheslostcontrol]

Jimmy Eat World

[cscwell107]

Voted for JEW but the other two are awesome

[Protested Hero]

Gatsbys definitely. I love the other two also, but GAD is too good. Also, I think that next year the obvious huge winning bands should not even be in the running. I already knew it was going to be JEW vs Blink vs Brand New.

[atticusfinch]

Jimmy Eat World for sure.

[rollerpiggy]

obviously JIMMY :)

[reckoner]

jimmy eat world.

[chokeychicken]

Lydia by far

lol, lydia wouldn't even be a band without jimmy eat world

[its all good 03]

i wish gatsbys and lydia were getting more love, both are incredible bands

[tonighttonight0]

Jew

[Troggy]

I'm fine with Jimmy Eat World running away with this. They are definitely the most successful and popular of the three. How Gatsbys is losing to Lydia is beyond me.

[WasteofPaint31]

All good bands
Jimmy Eat World is my favorite though

[blimpcityhero11]

No disrespect to Gatsbys or Lydia, but JEW is simply too good...

[teenagetwilight]

JEW are raping this poll, as expected and deserved

[Bruised26]

Jew.

[SomedayTheFire]

Why is GAD losing to Lydia? JEW I can expect but come on, I love Lydia but they pale in comparison to GAD

[kelsabelse]

jimmy eat world is amazing!

[Brandao]

this was tough!

Between Gatsby's and JEW i'll choose JEW

[spunkmastaflex]

of course jimmy eat world

[Vaporchoke]

I love me some Jimmy, but I had to vote Lydia. Illuminate is just too damn good for me to vote against.

[bdil]

I never really got into Jimmy Eat World so my vote went to Lydia. Illuminate was a solid album.

[circatbs]

Lydiaaaaaa

[drivethruaz]

fuck. that was hard. lydia is one of my favorite bands. but its JEW! damn it! I hate life's hard decisions.

[chipdip18]

I just hope that Gatsbys pulls ahead of Lydia.

[TalkShowsOnMute]

Damn I hate to see Lydia get eliminated. I voted for them without a second of hesitation.

[druck]

gatsbys for SURE.

[MickShamrock]

Jimmy Eat World.

[ppt4895]

jimmy eat world

[denissuxx]

Lydia. Sorry JEW.

[taylerx0]

Awww I wish Lydia could have won this... but clearly it's not even a competition here. I like JEW, but, I mean... it's Lydia. There's no way I could have voted for any other band.

[justletgo]

Lydia.

[Mibabalou]

JEW over lydia over GAD

[littlebeav]

I love JEW, but Lydia is quickly becoming one of my favorite bands. Had to give them the sympathy vote knowing it would be a landslide.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Jew

[Machu505]

Gatsby's American Dream. I never saw much good in Lydia.

[Formatfun]

I think GAD should win this.

[TheClockSounds]

Jew

[blankets]

Jimmmmmyyyyyyyy.

[diehtc0ke]

Gatsbys by far for me.

[Undue Noise]

Jew.

[emilytimesseven]

JEW by far.

[just-in.]

Jimmy Eat World. Who did Gatsby beat to make it to Round Two?

[Daniel Thompson]

i love all bands, but im more into lydia right now.

[Christian Otte]

Gatsbys American Dream. It's a close one between them and Jimmy Eat World.

[Theseventhson]

JEW for sure.

[Dan!]

the fact that lydia is beating GAD is disgusting

[new_arbiter]

JEW, though I'll admit to not having heard much Gatsbys(not a slight against them).

[chipdip18]

Jimmy Eat World. Who did Gatsby beat to make it to Round Two?

Cobra Starship haha. It was like a 400 vote difference if i remember right.

[just-in.]

Cobra Starship haha. It was like a 400 vote difference if i remember right.

haha of course, even though I'd personally pick Cobra. I just could never get in to Gatsby.

[chipdip18]

haha of course, even though I'd personally pick Cobra. I just could never get in to Gatsby.

Gatsbys does seem a bit hit or miss. What turned you off? Nic Newsham's vocals? Acquired taste for sure.

[xSpillFiction]

I couldn't choose between Gatsby's and JEW. Went with JEW but it killed me to not vote for Gatsby's. I don't like Lydia at all, though.

[xfantabulousx]

Had to be Jimmy Eat World. Nothing against Gatsby's or Lydia, but JEW is well, JEW.

[Talib Scottie]

JEW by a mile. I really enjoy(ed) GAD though.

[Co and Ca]

I voted for Lydia. mmmmmmindywhitemmmmm.

[ericag1]

JEW is killing it.

[watchitfall]

GAD has an amazing performance, but JEW has won the test of time, But LYDIA is just pure amazing! i don't know...i don't know.. I would say GAD just because i drank with them and they are awesome!

[shimmyshakes]

Lydia, hands down.

[Alison1488]

Jimmy Eat World. No competition!

[drewk16]

jimmy easily on this one

[TotalCollapse]

Lydia

[SeanEBoy2686]

jew

[PenThrive]

Jew

[Until The Bombs]

Jew!

[musicloverliver]

Jimmy Eat World, by far!

Michelle<3

[SingleDoubt]

this sucks. i adore Gatsbys but JEW means so much to me.... gahhhh. difficult decisions.

EDIT: flipped a coin. GAD.

[lesto17]

JEW. Although I do love GAD, and Lydia are pretty sweet as well.

[PopPunkKid]

JEW... no contest.

[fromoc2dc]

JEW, but I love all 3.

[ThisIsNotDan]

Gatsbys by faaaaaaaar although they aren't going to win. could be worse

[xheartdenterx]

I'm starting to like Lydia, but JEW wins this one.

[KyleMcr]

JEW easily

[c_rob2700]

Pack it up and go home kids, Jimmy Eat World are kings

[nlcentralchamps]

I like all 3.

But I listened to Lydia a lot the past few months, so I went with them.

[Forever.Zero]

Jimmy Eat World.
No let down

[amber3]

I love both JEW and Lydia, but I like Jimmy Eat World quite more.

[Merkin]

picked lydia, but jew is too old for them

[Sarah92]

JEW. Just recently bought Clarity. Amazing album.

[wahwah16]

JEW, I haven't been able to get into Lydia and Gatsby's American Dream

[hailthewarrior]

Jimmy Eat World, no contest.

[altemose09]

jew

[ATL182fan]

Jimmy Eat World

[11:11]

I love each and every one of you who voted Gatsbys.
I love JEW, but Nic Newsham is a genius. Way too unfair that GAD is put against JEW.

[atainder]

Gatsbys.

[nickstetina]

Dammit.

[TheHoldSteady]

Love all three.
Went with Lydia.

[Matthew Tsai]

JEW not even close. Lydia? lol.

[VampiresRevenge]

Jimmy Eat World.

[benlong]

no contest, For Me This is Heaven was the first dance at my wedding

[Do I Divide?]

I feel bad for lydia here.

[phil19]

JEW. cant really go past them

[meghanlail]

Definitely JEW for me.

[nathlance]

lyida for sure
jew very close second
GAD a stylish 3rd

[annalee_xx]

Lydia's my all time favorite band so... not even close in my mind. Lydia all the way.

[Dr. Acula]

:hitself:

[andrewa5]

JEW is raping it! as they should be!

[kaylaalovee]

I knew Jimmy Eat World would take this one, it was obvious!
:]