More likely hall of fame brothers

[mat1419]

Which of the two sets is more likely to have both in the Hall of Fame at the end of their careers?

[Fullcollapse3k]

Peyton and Eli.

[justinevans]

how about Reggie Bush and his ginormous brother?

[Vincewithouthee]

Yeah, the Mannings.

[justinevans]

i think it'll be neither, but the mannings have the best chance...ronde will not make the hall of fame.

[itsjdiggity]

Michael and Marcus. :laugh:

[somethingyellow]

i think it'll be neither, but the mannings have the best chance.
thats what i think too

[mikeford]

ronde and peyton will make it.

[still_life]

Peyton's a lock, but way too early to know what Eli will do. I doubt either Barber gets in. Very good players, but not HOF material.

[mat1419]

Peyton's a lock, but way too early to know what Eli will do. I doubt either Barber gets in. Very good players, but not HOF material.
both have a decent half decade left before age should start to slow them down. If Ronde keeps his productivity up he'll be very close to HOF numbers, and Tiki is seemingly just hitting his stride and getting his touches. I think he's just hitting the prime of his career.

This was the debate I had at happy hour. Two very good football players with a few years left vs one lock and one raw potential.

[still_life]

I'm really not sure what HOF numbers are for a CB.

Tiki probably has 2-3 years left as a legit starter. He might get into the hall the Curtis Martin way, but he's going to have to produce a lot right now. Should get another Pro Bowl bid this year, and he might lead the league in yards from scrimmage again. That helps.

[mat1419]

I'm really not sure what HOF numbers are for a CB.

Tiki probably has 2-3 years left as a legit starter. He might get into the hall the Curtis Martin way, but he's going to have to produce a lot right now. Should get another Pro Bowl bid this year, and he might lead the league in yards from scrimmage again. That helps.
For Ronde I think the 20/20 stat was big...he'll probably get close to 50 int's by time he's done with around 30 sacks. On top of that he's up there as one of the all time leaders in tackles and has 7 defensive TD's. He's probably one of the best all around corners to ever play when you factor in everything a corner is asked to do nowadays.

[mikeford]

i think ronde will be able to play long enough to get in.. he hasnt lost a step... hes probably got 5 more seasons barring any serious injury trouble.

[LeftWideOpen]

eli manning has to cut way back on the INT's if he's going to remain an NFL starter for the next 10 years, nevermind be in the HOF. I say neither because I don't see Ronde getting enough love from HOF voters, and I don't see Eli even playing in more than a Pro Bowl or two.