who do you like better, musically?

[meh]

cue a war

[tonyC4L]

Or a landslide BN win...

[11:11]

I only like 2 songs by Taking Back Sunday, really.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

this has been done. tell all your friends TBS> brand new>>>> the rest of TBS catalogue.


so I go BN.

[phaserstostun]

In my opinion... I know everyone will disagree with me but I'll face persecution anyways...

Where You Want To Be=Deja Entendu>The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me>Tell All Your Friends>Your Favorite Weapon>Louder Now

I like all of those cds but I personally just really enjoy these bands' second albums the most.

[showyourteeth]

this has been done. tell all your friends TBS> brand new>>>> the rest of TBS catalogue.


so I go BN.

completely agree

[KevinForReal]

They are both pretty decent, but I prefer Brand New.

[Piss]

the only album i like by both of these guys are TAYF, so vote for TBS

[liveloud4life]

When you say musically do you mean instrumentally?

[phil19]

brand new. i listen to all their albums way more than i listen to tbs

[Indoor Living]

Why is this needed? Taking Back Sunday, clearly. New Again is going to be the next White Album. :-d

[Troggy]

Never liked either of these bands, but I think the winning choice is obvious.

[George-Michael]

Why do this?

[Neo Cassady]

Which do you prefer?

*Well, whiiiiich wooooould youuuu preeeefer?!


Early TBS, later BN. BN overall.

[KevinForReal]

Why is this needed? Taking Back Sunday, clearly. New Again is going to be the next White Album. :-d


I'm embarassed for you, TBS is garbage compared to Brand New, clearly

[Indoor Living]

I'm embarassed for you, TBS is garbage compared to Brand New, clearly


I'm embarrassed for you, who thought I was serious.

[Machu505]

Brand New is much more consistent.

[Burn That Shit]

Tell All Your Friends is just a really whiny and lame album, same with Your Favorite Weapon. The only difference is that Brand New actually got better and Taking Back Sunday didn't.

[MyNameIsRoss]

b ra n d n ew

[CarouselBoy]

I voted for TBS only because I've never really listened to Brand New and I like TBS pretty good. I've been listening to more BN lately and I really like it and from what I heard they seem like the better band but I'm going with TBS for now.

[SeanEBoy2686]

Brand New albums have gotten better and better. TBS has plateaued... and sadly may fall with this next album, but I haven't heard it yet.

I feel like I've voted on a poll like this at least 10 times since I joined the site.

[GamEin]

I'll say Brand New. But Tell All Your Friends is an amazing cd.

Brand New keeps evolving and their CDs are still gold, while TBS has steadily been getting worse album by album in my opinion.

[Theseventhson]

The Devil & God>Deja Entendu>Your Favorite Weapon>Tell All Your Friends>Where You Want To Be>>>>>>>>>>>Louder Now.

Although I doi enjoy both bands quite a bit.

[KevinForReal]

Tell All Your Friends is just a really whiny and lame album, same with Your Favorite Weapon. The only difference is that Brand New actually got better and Taking Back Sunday didn't.


I do enjoy both, but this is by far the most accurate. IMO i thought Brand New got better with every release, and TBS just sort of levelled off.... WHere you want to be and God and Devil are some of my most favorite shit.

[KevinForReal]

I'm embarrassed for you, who thought I was serious.


Dude where is new richland?

[Indoor Living]

Dude where is new richland?


I'm going to college in the cities next year. New Richland is about an hour south of you.

[spunkmastaflex]

TAYF and WYWTB were really good imo, so i went with them, and i couldnt really get into BN

[jjjkman]

this has been done. tell all your friends TBS> brand new>>>> the rest of TBS catalogue.


so I go BN.

This is true. I agree with you.

[xBrandNew]

both are amazing. tell all of your friends, and deja entendu are my two top played albums ever. i say brand new wins it cumulatively however, but tbs' new stuff sounds pretty good.

[x1onexwo1fx]

Tell All Your Friends and Your Favorite Weapon are equally amazing albums. The only difference is that Brand New actually got better and Taking Back Sunday didn't.

fixed.

[MickShamrock]

Brand New.

[fueledbyvictory]

*Well, whiiiiich wooooould youuuu preeeefer?!



I was going to say that.

Taking Back Sunday.

[handlikesecret]

Brand New.

[just.Starla.]

TBS, but of course BN is going to win.

[unwritten]

This poll is about 6 years too late.

[PenThrive]

Bn (3 solid albums) **winner**

TBS (1 solid album)

[jawstheme]

Tell All Your Friends is just a really whiny and lame album, same with Your Favorite Weapon. The only difference is that Brand New actually got better and Taking Back Sunday didn't.

Yep

[Takk...Ros]

went with Brand New because 1) I love them and 2) I've honestly never really listened to TBS. I've heard some of louder now and that's it. On second thought maybe I shouldn't have voted since I know practically nothing about TBS.

[THE_SICKEST]

this has been done. tell all your friends TBS> brand new>>>> the rest of TBS catalogue.


so I go BN.

this.

fa sho.

[augustana]

the devil and god > deja entendu > tell all your friends > yfw > everything else tbs has done that's shitty

[futilespider]

taking back sunday is more consistent for me. so i went with them.

yes brand new is good.

not the level this site thinks or w/e. but they are good.

gotta go tbs on this one though.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Brand New will dominate, but I've always been more into TBS.

[JustAGirl01]

i went with taking back sunday only because i was into them longer than BN

[RAMROD85]

I went with TBS because their live performance is so much better. But I'll rock both band's albums.

[TangledUp]

Brand New. Always.

[Zulufu]

Brand New catalogue and TAYF are Amazing. Because of the TAYF i keep hoping for a glimmer of that album again so keep buying TBS cd's. Each album is decent and has songs I really rock out to, but in the end Brand New takes me to another level everytime. For the people that are old enough to really appreciate TAYF...late high school or college when it came out, know what i mean. So that album is standard.

[blinkme]

Tell All Your Friends is just a really whiny and lame album, same with Your Favorite Weapon. The only difference is that Brand New actually got better and Taking Back Sunday didn't.

this is about right. deja entendu decides this for me. a very nearly flawless album.

[emptyvictory]

Have never been and will never be a Lacey fan

[abbysmith]

I don't dislike TBS, but I've never been a huge fan. BN for me.

[DejaNew]

This is so unnecessary.