PDA

View Full Version : Gatsbys American Dream

Piss
05/01/09, 11:04 PM
vote
kazuma_ootaro28
05/02/09, 03:41 AM
Why We Fight is the only GAD album I could enjoy as a whole.
fadedmemories
05/02/09, 06:57 AM
Went with Volcano, their only album that I listen to as a whole.
thehereaway
05/02/09, 07:37 AM
R & S all the way, although Shhhhhh! I'm Listening To Reason and A Mind of Metal and Wheels almost won it alone for Volcano.
cason eat world
05/02/09, 09:02 AM
God I love this band. I went with Volcano.
MADSTA
05/02/09, 09:08 AM
Volcano, then Ribbons and Sugar, then the self titled for me. I've never listened to Why We Fight.
loganmmm
05/02/09, 12:20 PM
Volcano, but their In The Land of the Lost Monsters EP gets the most plays in my library. I absolutely love I Smell an Agenda and You Stole My Story.
dumhed01
05/02/09, 02:09 PM
I went with the self-titled.
Love 'em all though.
Piss
05/03/09, 04:03 PM
R & S all the way, although Shhhhhh! I'm Listening To Reason and A Mind of Metal and Wheels almost won it alone for Volcano.

then shouldn't volcano as a whole win it?
thehereaway
05/03/09, 04:20 PM
then shouldn't volcano as a whole win it?

Yeah what i said didn't really make sense, but never mind i'm sure you got the jist of it.
11:11
05/03/09, 04:56 PM
Volcano is one of my top 5 albums.
Keagan Ilvonen
05/03/09, 05:16 PM
I have to go with Volcano. Really developed my love for the band with that album.
billyboatkid
05/05/09, 09:33 PM
Never heard Volcano. Only one song I think.

Dling now to see what all the fuss is about.
TheZeroKid
05/06/09, 08:18 AM
What avout In The Land Of Lost Monsters? That's a solid album. I went with Volcano though.
overitsi22
05/07/09, 02:26 PM
Why We Fight is the only GAD album I could enjoy as a whole.
this
TotalCollapse
05/07/09, 04:26 PM
Definitely Volcano. I listened to it on the way to school today.
Machu505
05/07/09, 05:02 PM
Ribbons and Sugar barely overtakes Volcano for me.
pleasedontpanic
05/08/09, 01:44 AM
Why We Fight is the only GAD album I could enjoy as a whole.

I can respect you because I'm a huge Gatsby's fan, but it's hard for me to understand that. I loved it, but a lot of it sounded the same. "Why We Fight" is pretty much one of my favorite songs by them though.

Ribbons and Sugar definitely took it for me because I credit that as the album that really got me into them, but Volcano definitely took a close second.
HammersNStrings
05/11/09, 07:32 AM
I also went with Volcano. Amazing album.
CloseToShore
05/12/09, 06:31 AM
Volcano. I love them all though, especially the S/T. But Volcano just does it for me. Just damn near perfect as you can get.
katiebobatie
05/14/09, 06:57 AM
mmm Volcano, lovee that album.
Kevward
05/14/09, 10:16 AM
Volcano! I bought that album in 7th grade and fell in love with it, I even wrote a review for my middle school's newspaper. I still listen to that album very often. I think I'll go listen to it right now...
kittypants
05/14/09, 01:13 PM
Volcano > Why We Fight > Ribbons And Sugar > Gatsbys American Dream
jmg85
05/15/09, 02:56 PM
i can't believe the self-titled album is in 2nd!!! Volcano is obviously first. it's where they really mastered their sound. and then when the self-titled came out they lost their sound. it was INCREDIBLY disappointing being that GAD was my favorite band circa R&S / Volcano.
Machu505
05/15/09, 03:06 PM
i can't believe the self-titled album is in 2nd!!! Volcano is obviously first. it's where they really mastered their sound. and then when the self-titled came out they lost their sound. it was INCREDIBLY disappointing being that GAD was my favorite band circa R&S / Volcano.

Agreed about self-titled. Nice avatar too.
eclipsegts1
05/15/09, 03:15 PM
I really did not like this band, until Volcano grew on me. So VOLCANO!!!