Silverstein

[flks511]

Favorite Album by Silverstein? I went with DTW, but I love them all to death.

[KidRobot]

They all suck.

[doppelganger]

discovering the waterfront was the album for me when i was in my emo phase.

[Piss]

They all suck.

this

[Indoor Living]

When Broken Is Easily Fixed, is clearly their best release to date, in my opinion, but Discovering the Waterfront is almost as good. After that, I began to lose interest.

[loganmmm]

Have they even released a good album yet?

[Theseventhson]

When Broken Is Easily Fixed. I still think they need a new vocalist, though.

[Helpless]

ASITS by ten billion. So good.

[sweepthenation]

Never even heard of the first 2 on that list haha. Im really digging Shipwreck, it just edged out DTW

[chiefeasy750]

theyre all shitty, but a couple songs on when broken is easily fixed are decent.

[AussieBoy]

DTWF.. but SWITS is pretty fricken cool and rising up my favs

[Untitled09]

DTWF I will admit is a grand album. in fact, it includes my favorite song. But I will admit A Shipwreck in the Sand has to be my overall favorite. All the songs add up and I can't find a low point on it.

[Charles777]

Dtw Ftw

[loganmmm]

Good yes. Great no

I suppose I did judge too quickly. The only albums that I've heard are When Broken is Easily Fixed and Discovering the Waterfront. Neither of which are worth much praise.

[liveloud4life]

I liked DTW but had my reservations. A and D, I think they were moving in the right direction although I don't like it as much. And I haven't heard Shipwreck but I've heard good things which excites me.

[batmannj]

Shipwreck

[Alex DiVincenzo]

While their new one is probably the band's best work, my favorite is When Broken is Easily Fixed for nostalgia.

[voncorn]

They all suck.

This should have been a poll option.

[Indoor Living]

While their new one is probably the band's best work, my favorite is When Broken is Easily Fixed for nostalgia.
How much better is it than Arrivals and Departures?

[Alex DiVincenzo]

How much better is it than Arrivals and Departures?
I'd say it's significantly better than Arrivals, which I thought was a step down from Waterfront -- maybe not a step down, but it just seemed like more of the same. I guess the band has never been one to write out of their norm, but by the third full-length it just seemed like a B-sides record, whereas the new one is almost like a breath of fresh air without actually changing much... if that makes any sense. In any event, it has more stand-out tracks so give it a try.

[Indoor Living]

I'd say it's significantly better than Arrivals, which I thought was a step down from Waterfront -- maybe not a step down, but it just seemed like more of the same. I guess the band has never been one to write out of their norm, but by the third full-length it just seemed like a B-sides record, whereas the new one is almost like a breath of fresh air without actually changing much... if that makes any sense. In any event, it has more stand-out tracks so give it a try.
Just listened to the stream on Myspace. Thought it was really good, but definitely in the same vein as the rest of their stuff. I agree with you on the "not writing out of their comfort zone" thing.

[Bruised26]

I bet most of these people bashing them secretly listen to them and like them, but dont want to look 'scene'