View Full Version : Sweet 16: Midtown vs. Brand New
Anton Djamoos
05/03/09, 09:08 PM
Which band is your favorite?
thesafeword
05/03/09, 09:09 PM
Brand New.
Chromefox
05/03/09, 09:09 PM
Sorry Anton. Brand New.
Looks like anton already voted in this one.
TheOtherAndrew
05/03/09, 09:10 PM
oh peace Midtown
fightoffyrdmns
05/03/09, 09:11 PM
Brand New.
Anton Djamoos
05/03/09, 09:11 PM
Midtown's so gone in this one :-(
TSLROCKS
05/03/09, 09:12 PM
Brand New
DejaNew
05/03/09, 09:12 PM
I wanna see who votes Midtown.
Burn That Shit
05/03/09, 09:13 PM
Brand New.
AndrewIcex
05/03/09, 09:13 PM
Went with Brand New, though I was slightly tempted to let Midtown have my vote.
princesschad
05/03/09, 09:15 PM
Brand New!
xtheaudition
05/03/09, 09:15 PM
im not gonna vote, cause i love both bands equally.
Anton Djamoos
05/03/09, 09:15 PM
Looks like anton already voted in this one.
There was a time when Midtown was beating Brand New (see: as soon as I posted the poll and voted for them).
sweepthenation
05/03/09, 09:16 PM
BN, I think Limousine is my new favorite song
phoenixinflames
05/03/09, 09:17 PM
Midtown's so gone in this one :-(
Haha, unfortunately...yes.
Alex DiVincenzo
05/03/09, 09:17 PM
Brand New
k8omiller
05/03/09, 09:20 PM
Brand New just blows my mind
googirl8907
05/03/09, 09:20 PM
Midtown. I've never liked Brand New.
I love both, but enjoy Midtown way more.
ashiex3
05/03/09, 09:27 PM
I went with Brand New, but still love Midtown.
Jamos4184
05/03/09, 09:27 PM
I need to get into Midtown. Obviously, my lack of familiarity with their stuff (beyond the song "Give It Up") did not make this a difficult decision for me.
I wanna see who votes Midtown.
you say that like it's impossible? Midtown was a great band.
Oh, I voted Brand New.
emptyvictory
05/03/09, 09:28 PM
I love both, but enjoy Midtown way more.
I like both but went with Midtown, Gabes the man!
bouttogetfancy
05/03/09, 09:30 PM
brand new
seraph1214
05/03/09, 09:32 PM
Starting to like Brand New more and more, but Midtown's an all time favorite so I went with them.
i like midtown, but i like brand new more
Ryzenfall
05/03/09, 09:36 PM
Midtown. The senseless rampage continues...
kianacarly
05/03/09, 09:36 PM
I love both bands, but I find myself listening to Brand New more often
Illuminate
05/03/09, 09:36 PM
Easily Brand New. I love Midtown and all but they just don't compare.
theguy77
05/03/09, 09:36 PM
total no brainer
walshknilb281
05/03/09, 09:37 PM
the nizzle
I feel both are overrated on this site, but brand new is underratted in the scheme of the music scene
batmannj
05/03/09, 09:38 PM
Brand New but I really enjoy Midtown
irthesteve
05/03/09, 09:39 PM
sorry tonton, the run is over
hailthewarrior
05/03/09, 09:39 PM
Brand New
theguy77
05/03/09, 09:39 PM
the nizzle
I feel both are overrated on this site, but brand new is underratted in the scheme of the music scene
overrated or underrated, TDAG is an awesome and dynamic album, and midtown repeats their lackluster hooks wayyy too many times.
rickbarrera
05/03/09, 09:41 PM
just when i was starting to like midtown they got vs one of the greatest bands in history sorry i was sure i'll vote for them on these week but no contest against YFW, DE and DaG sorry
BRAND NEW!!!!
heyzombiehitler
05/03/09, 09:43 PM
Alkaline Trio.
jimjam32
05/03/09, 09:44 PM
yep. expected.
altemose09
05/03/09, 09:44 PM
brand new
mmmmmpoetry
05/03/09, 09:44 PM
Eh I don't like Midtown and I like brandnew.
Adios.
singyoutocoma
05/03/09, 09:46 PM
I'm listening to Living Well is the Best Revenge right now, and I was just thinking about how I love it to death, and I was curious about who they were hitting...well.
I probably love Brand New's later two CDs more than any of Midtown's work, but Midtown get my sympathy vote.
leftapart
05/03/09, 09:48 PM
Midtown! I do not like Brand New; AT ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
dpetty21
05/03/09, 09:52 PM
Midtown fo sho! I mean BN is sweet and everything but to me Midtown is much better.
kazuma_ootaro28
05/03/09, 09:52 PM
Midtown: Forget What You Know
Brand New: Deja Entendu, most of TD&GaRIM, some of Your Favorite Weapon
Anton's a good guy and all, but I gotta go with Brand New for this one.
Keagan Ilvonen
05/03/09, 09:52 PM
Brand New easily even though Midtown are great.
TSTLSOOM
05/03/09, 09:54 PM
Midtown's so gone in this one :-(
nah expect alot of one posters for this one ;)
cOnfidence_Man
05/03/09, 09:56 PM
I would have said Midtown if Gabe didn't start Cobra Suckship
Dirge07
05/03/09, 09:58 PM
I actually didn't even hear of/about Midtown til this pool started haha. Good, but BN still owns.
CarryOn09
05/03/09, 09:59 PM
brand new. yes.
boxingwithstars
05/03/09, 10:00 PM
BN, although i love Midtown. these polls are getting tough now...
theguy77
05/03/09, 10:01 PM
Midtown! I do not like Brand New; AT ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OMGZZZZZZZZZZZZ LOLLLLLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! UR LIEK, A REBEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!
Imperfektion
05/03/09, 10:02 PM
Brand New.
zeropunk16
05/03/09, 10:02 PM
Never even listened to Midtown.
westendriot
05/03/09, 10:10 PM
Midtown.
voted midtown even though i knew it wouldnt matter
Chris Fallon
05/03/09, 10:12 PM
I defied APdotnet logic and voted Midtown.
Not because I love Anton, or because I have a Midtown shirt in my profile picture, or even because I hate a real problem with a majority of Brand New fans... but because they released three classic, stellar pop-punk albums that were amazing before all the late bloomers came in. It's just a shame people caught on so late...
Anton Djamoos
05/03/09, 10:15 PM
If Brand New wins this poll, I'm totally losing faith in AP.net.
/typical response from disappointed fan. I'm just teasing.
gemini089
05/03/09, 10:18 PM
this seems mean...brand new is literally one of the few bands i would vote for over midtown. I got into brand new before midtown and they're just a sort of band thats always stuck with me. Im not gonna lie tho i was tempted, my mouse definitly hovered over midtown for a second there
Broden Terry
05/03/09, 10:18 PM
I voted for the wrong band. :-( I suppose it won't matter?
fadedmemories
05/03/09, 10:19 PM
Poor Midtown.
lenard27
05/03/09, 10:20 PM
Tough one. I went with Brand New.
nerdvglc
05/03/09, 10:26 PM
br& new will win the whole thing. i just know it. i love them so...
HometownHero
05/03/09, 10:26 PM
Brand New = A million times better
Daniel Thompson
05/03/09, 10:28 PM
landslide.
theguy77
05/03/09, 10:28 PM
Poor Midtown.
nah this isnt unfair to them at all. they got as far as they deserved to get by their music. unlike all time blow. oops did i pun that name?
what_ever
05/03/09, 10:28 PM
too easy. brand new.
katieissweet
05/03/09, 10:32 PM
Sorry Midtown. :-(
starjamgirl
05/03/09, 10:32 PM
Brand New<3
ericsounds41
05/03/09, 10:32 PM
Wonder who's going to win this one.
IamTheINDUSTRY
05/03/09, 10:33 PM
bn
fadedmemories
05/03/09, 10:36 PM
nah this isnt unfair to them at all. they got as far as they deserved to get by their music. unlike all time blow. oops did i pun that name?
Don't get me wrong, I admit that BN is the better band, just wish that Midtown we're up against a band that they have a chance of beating.
acowsert
05/03/09, 10:41 PM
Fuck me. Brand New and Midtown are equal in my book. I have to go with Brand Nizzle though
travis113p
05/03/09, 10:43 PM
love midtown, but BN is epic.
anthonydarko
05/03/09, 10:47 PM
I never saw the appeal of Brand New :shrug:
bailmeout13
05/03/09, 10:48 PM
Midtown. Really have struggled to get into Brand New.
thespearkid
05/03/09, 10:56 PM
I don't see anyone beating Brand New but Blink or Fall Out Boy.
Anton Djamoos
05/03/09, 10:57 PM
I don't see anyone beating Brand New but Blink or Fall Out Boy.
Jimmy.
theguy77
05/03/09, 10:58 PM
Jimmy.
ohh hell naw!
haha JEW rules but come on, better than brand new?
cscwell107
05/03/09, 11:01 PM
I love me some Midtown but I don't like them as much as I like Brand New
radxbandit
05/03/09, 11:06 PM
midtown all the fucking way, though i really like brand new.
Broclee
05/03/09, 11:09 PM
http://www.leftoffthedial.com/midtown.jpg
Goodnight, sweet prince.
Bloodsucker II
05/03/09, 11:10 PM
lol
jawstheme
05/03/09, 11:21 PM
Midtown used to be cool, but they haven't put out anything to match TDAG.
Undue Noise
05/03/09, 11:22 PM
As much as I love Midtown, it's got to be Brand New this time.
TalkShowsOnMute
05/03/09, 11:24 PM
I went with Brand New, but this was probably my toughest choice so far. Sorry Midtown :(
XEmoBoyShandorX
05/03/09, 11:26 PM
Midtown.
ZachMadeMeOdd
05/03/09, 11:32 PM
brand new poll, decided a long time ago.
robat19
05/03/09, 11:38 PM
I actually didn't even hear of/about Midtown til this pool started haha. Good, but BN still owns.
X-)
littlebeav
05/03/09, 11:39 PM
I like Brand New, but Midtown never closed after Thrice and put on the world's most terrible headlining show ever at Stubb's in Austin, no, that award goes to Brand New.
dannixx
05/03/09, 11:44 PM
I love both these bands and I voted for one but I'm not saying which.
drudo182
05/03/09, 11:58 PM
Brand New.
iheartTHS
05/04/09, 12:11 AM
Brand New.
amysaurus
05/04/09, 12:19 AM
Brand New is my favorite band, so Brand New. I hate that I had to vote against Midtown, though.
mariaaaa_x
05/04/09, 12:19 AM
i like both bands,
but midtown has had my heart since i've had a myspace,
sucks to see them gone, but,
voted for midtown.
Nick_K99
05/04/09, 12:26 AM
Do not understand the love for brand new, they are not that good.
MyWorldEntire
05/04/09, 12:40 AM
It's going to be Blink vs Brand New, with Blink winning.
DonnerParty666
05/04/09, 12:41 AM
I like both but went with Midtown, Gabes the man!
Gabe WAS the man.
DonnerParty666
05/04/09, 12:42 AM
Do not understand the love for brand new, they are not that good.
and they let you register for an account on ap.net with that crazy thinking?
walking_by91
05/04/09, 12:48 AM
Brand New, but it was close for me.
stereokiller
05/04/09, 12:56 AM
Forget What You Know! MIDTOWN. easiest vote so far.
Voted for Midtown even though I like Brand New more. They're not good enough in my book to just get everything handed to them though.
mariaaaa_x
05/04/09, 01:26 AM
Gabe WAS the man.
YES. haha.
i do admit cobra starship grew on me though.
Ghostpsalm
05/04/09, 01:27 AM
sorry midtown. we'll miss you.
denissuxx
05/04/09, 01:31 AM
Midtown all the way.
FormerClarity
05/04/09, 01:32 AM
I so wanna vote Midtown but I know better lol.
fadedmemories
05/04/09, 01:34 AM
http://www.leftoffthedial.com/midtown.jpg
Goodnight, sweet prince.
Sweet
loveisdead
05/04/09, 01:35 AM
I knew Brand New would win this pretty handily, but not by this much.
Metal Now
05/04/09, 01:37 AM
Bad luck for Midtown.
yepitsme
05/04/09, 01:42 AM
Brand New
Pawan1993
05/04/09, 02:13 AM
Even if they are against Midtown, Brand New are still garnering the most votes from all the polls. These guys should win this whole thing. On another note, it's so sad to see Thrice losing to Taking Back Sunday.
Pawan1993
05/04/09, 02:16 AM
Sorry meant the highest percentage over the opposition in the entire thing so far. Not the highest amount of votes. That would be Jimmy Eat World's.
loveisdead
05/04/09, 02:17 AM
At this point Brand New could get a bye to the finals.
Pawan1993
05/04/09, 02:19 AM
Haha I know. It would be pointless to put anything against them in then entire competition. We'd all know who'll know who'd win.
loveisdead
05/04/09, 02:20 AM
Haha I know. It would be pointless to put anything against them in then entire competition. We'd all know who'll know who'd win.
I'm pretty sure in one poll thread they were put against God and won. And I'm being serious.
Dagless
05/04/09, 02:31 AM
Brand New
fadedmemories
05/04/09, 02:35 AM
At this point Brand New could get a bye to the finals.
They should. It's not even close.
loveisdead
05/04/09, 02:40 AM
They should. It's not even close.
They're gonna win this whole thing. I'm just curious to see who they're gonna go up against. I tend to think JEW.
fadedmemories
05/04/09, 02:44 AM
They're gonna win this whole thing. I'm just curious to see who they're gonna go up against. I tend to think JEW.
My money is one a Brand New/Say Anything finals.
loveisdead
05/04/09, 02:47 AM
My money is one a Brand New/Say Anything finals.
That's my second guess. I think Brand New would demolish them though.
fadedmemories
05/04/09, 02:51 AM
That's my second guess. I think Brand New would demolish them though.
Might as well crown them as the winners.
anamericangod
05/04/09, 02:53 AM
Oh.
loveisdead
05/04/09, 02:55 AM
Oh.
I don't follow.
anamericangod
05/04/09, 03:12 AM
I don't follow.
Was just saying it because Brand New is obviously dominating. No surprises here.
XchrisX
05/04/09, 03:12 AM
Brand New
loveisdead
05/04/09, 03:13 AM
Was just saying it because Brand New is obviously dominating. No surprises here.
I want to hear your opinion on the Soco Jacks one.
fadedmemories
05/04/09, 03:15 AM
Dominating is an understatement.
Brand New would win against almost any other band here.;-)
handlikesecret
05/04/09, 04:02 AM
a wild Brand New appears!
anamericangod
05/04/09, 04:03 AM
I want to hear your opinion on the Soco Jacks one.
Something Corporate over Jack's. I love Jack's Mannequin, some of those songs mean the world to me, but Something Corporate was basically the soundtrack (along with a few other albums) for my life awhile back. The albums were a bit more consistent, and honestly I would have to say that Konstantine is arguably the most scene defining song for people who were around in those days. So many people have memories attached to that song, and I can't think of anything else that really comes close to doing what that song does.
Both great bands with lots of great songs, but the nostalgia wins me over.
loveisdead
05/04/09, 04:04 AM
Something Corporate over Jack's. I love Jack's Mannequin, some of those songs mean the world to me, but Something Corporate was basically a soundtrack (along with a few other albums) for my life awhile back. The albums were a bit more consistent, and honestly I would have to say that Konstantine is arguably the most scene defining song for people who were around back then.
Both great bands with lots of great songs, but the nostalgia wins me over.
Bout time haha. Not gonna talk about it in this thread cause then it'll get way off topic.
just-in.
05/04/09, 04:13 AM
Well, I tried helping Midtown out, but it's not looking good.
Not a big Brand New Fan <- plz dont kick me ;)
Midtown is a great band, like them a lot!
DaveZeroZero
05/04/09, 04:30 AM
Anton put his loves against the wrong band, assuming that he wanted them to survive this round. Brand New for me.
Shin Akuma
05/04/09, 04:31 AM
Midtown yeeeeeh!
atticusfinch
05/04/09, 04:43 AM
aw, poor Midtown.
Brand New wins.
Anton Djamoos
05/04/09, 04:53 AM
Anton put his loves against the wrong band, assuming that he wanted them to survive this round. Brand New for me.
I knew they weren't making it past this round.
Until The Bombs
05/04/09, 04:54 AM
BN. Buh bye Midtown.
DaveZeroZero
05/04/09, 04:57 AM
I knew they weren't making it past this round.
If you had put them up against JM or SoCo they could've been in with a chance.
showyourteeth
05/04/09, 05:02 AM
brand new
illusionfailure
05/04/09, 05:04 AM
MIDTOWN.
I fucking love that band.
Anton Djamoos
05/04/09, 05:06 AM
If you had put them up against JM or SoCo they could've been in with a chance.
I know, but I thought it would be unfair to give Midtown the easy match ups because they're my favorite band.
SteffRyanFail
05/04/09, 05:24 AM
Brand New.
Though I enjoy Midtown sometimes.
CloseToShore
05/04/09, 05:30 AM
Brand New.
George-Michael
05/04/09, 05:37 AM
I can't believe Brand New is winning by that much. I figured most people who love Midtown would vote for them, even if they do prefer Brand New, just because they knew Brand New would win anyway.
That's what I did at least.
Hagysaurus Rex
05/04/09, 05:49 AM
80/20 Brand New. That seems about right.
blimpcityhero11
05/04/09, 05:53 AM
No disrespect to Midtown, but Brand New is far better...
albertad
05/04/09, 05:53 AM
Bn. Ftw!
fly_guy
05/04/09, 06:06 AM
Oh this is just wrong.
raychull
05/04/09, 06:22 AM
yes.
YouMeHimAndHer
05/04/09, 06:42 AM
Midtown are awesome but had to go for Brand New.
Schreiforme417
05/04/09, 06:52 AM
haha poor midtown, they didnt have a chance.
just.Starla.
05/04/09, 07:06 AM
Midtown
RonStoppable
05/04/09, 07:13 AM
Midtown.
DaveZeroZero
05/04/09, 07:17 AM
I know, but I thought it would be unfair to give Midtown the easy match ups because they're my favorite band.
I know, but it would've been nice to have someone I actually like to vote for when voting against Andrew Macmahon. Because of what you've done I had to vote for him to vote against him!
nickthehick2
05/04/09, 07:17 AM
Brand New. I've never even heard of Midtown.
Bruised26
05/04/09, 07:41 AM
People on this website go crazy over brand new...its kind of scary, actually.
WFUJerseyJon
05/04/09, 07:51 AM
Battle of the AP Cult Status bands! Midtown.
jbaseball44
05/04/09, 08:00 AM
Tdag
underthetalking
05/04/09, 08:10 AM
So an Elite 8 with Brand New, Blink 182, Say Anything, Taking Back Sunday, Fall Out Boy, New Found Glory, Something Corporate, and Jimmy Eat World.
The first few rounds really weren't necessary.
meghanlail
05/04/09, 08:25 AM
Midtown's so gone in this one :-(
I'm with you on this one. I like Brand New, but nothing they have done beats Living Well for me.
I know, but it would've been nice to have someone I actually like to vote for when voting against Andrew Macmahon. Because of what you've done I had to vote for him to vote against him!
Why don't you like McMahon?
By the way, I love your avatar. Grammatics is soooo good.
lovekillsgirl
05/04/09, 08:44 AM
Midtown because they're losing and I honestly couldn't pick
CellarGhosts
05/04/09, 08:47 AM
I can't stand Brand New so Midtown.
jtyexists9
05/04/09, 08:49 AM
Brand New.
WordzandDreamz
05/04/09, 08:52 AM
Br& New.
DaveZeroZero
05/04/09, 08:58 AM
I'm with you on this one. I like Brand New, but nothing they have done beats Living Well for me.
Why don't you like McMahon?
By the way, I love your avatar. Grammatics is soooo good.
Nothing he does has been particularly interesting to me and everyone's like "Oh, he's so great! He survived cancer."
Newflash: I don't care
In other news: Yes, Grammatics rule.
Galedeep
05/04/09, 09:04 AM
Gotta be Brand New.
HelpMeSleep
05/04/09, 09:06 AM
Midtown.
Mibabalou
05/04/09, 09:18 AM
midtown
Charles777
05/04/09, 09:18 AM
Midtown, because they're actually good
zubinmoosa
05/04/09, 09:21 AM
Midtown had a good run, but c'ya Gabe!
BN FTW!
meghanlail
05/04/09, 09:40 AM
Nothing he does has been particularly interesting to me and everyone's like "Oh, he's so great! He survived cancer."
Newflash: I don't care
In other news: Yes, Grammatics rule.
While I do admire his fight and recovery, I agree that it is ridiculous that so much of the attention he receives is a result of his leukemia, rather than his music. As far as his songwriting goes, I suppose it's all a matter of taste.
Brand New is going to slaughter this one...
Thomas Balkcom
05/04/09, 09:50 AM
Brand New
c_rob2700
05/04/09, 09:53 AM
Brand New.
But in other news:
http://gormsey.files.wordpress.com/2008/11/cobra_starship.jpg
Really Gabe, really?
tonighttonight0
05/04/09, 10:06 AM
Midtown
Schmidty Says
05/04/09, 10:11 AM
Midtown's so gone in this one :-(
Poor Midtown...
Given the choice, I'm listening to Living Well... over anything Brand New has put out.
I am Mick
05/04/09, 10:16 AM
I cannot understand AP's fascination with Brand New. The most overrated band EVER.
TheSkunk
05/04/09, 10:23 AM
i can see brand new taking the whole thing
glasscase501
05/04/09, 10:38 AM
no band has a chance against brand new :( sucks because they could have possibly beaten some of the other bands in the top 16. i still think they're in the top 10 fave ap bands though, just not when they're up against bn
KyleMcr
05/04/09, 10:39 AM
Brand New!
Yep
So an Elite 8 with Brand New, Blink 182, Say Anything, Taking Back Sunday, Fall Out Boy, New Found Glory, Something Corporate, and Jimmy Eat World.
The first few rounds really weren't necessary.
This has been obvious the whole time. Oh well, can't help the overwhelming support that a couple of bands get. I don't listen to Brand New so Midtown was an obvious choice here. Also Save the World >>> Your Favorite Weapon.
xSpillFiction
05/04/09, 11:47 AM
Midtown, by far. I'll never understand all the hype around Brand New. I just can't get into them at all.
Chromefox
05/04/09, 11:49 AM
So an Elite 8 with Brand New, Blink 182, Say Anything, Taking Back Sunday, Fall Out Boy, New Found Glory, Something Corporate, and Jimmy Eat World.
The first few rounds really weren't necessary. Blink182.
This entire thing is unnecessary. :-d
givemegravity
05/04/09, 12:04 PM
Midtown's so gone in this one :-(
So sad. :( Midtown, plz. Brand New is garbage.
WhoSaidThat?
05/04/09, 12:06 PM
Sorry Anton. Brand New.
What I was gonna say.
baron162
05/04/09, 12:19 PM
this one was tough. i chose BN, but i'm surprised at the disparity between the two. more of a testament to brand new's domination or midtown's unpopularity? i say the former.
underthetalking
05/04/09, 12:21 PM
Blink182.
This entire thing is unnecessary. :-d
Haha, you win.
DaveZeroZero
05/04/09, 12:31 PM
While I do admire his fight and recovery, I agree that it is ridiculous that so much of the attention he receives is a result of his leukemia, rather than his music. As far as his songwriting goes, I suppose it's all a matter of taste.
I guess music's in his blood ;-)
Formatfun
05/04/09, 12:47 PM
I voted Brand New, but I felt bad having to choose between two very good bands.
TheHoldSteady
05/04/09, 12:49 PM
I think we know who won this one.
Brand New.
ThisIsNotDan
05/04/09, 12:51 PM
I love both bands alot, and as cliche as it is, Brand New. Your Favorite Weapon doesn't touch any Midtown album, but based on Deja and TDAG I gotta choose BN
TheClockSounds
05/04/09, 01:00 PM
Brand New but I love Midtown too
Machu505
05/04/09, 01:09 PM
Brand New.
ryheeles
05/04/09, 01:18 PM
I love Midtown, but BN gets a lot more plays with me
TSLataris
05/04/09, 01:21 PM
I wanna see who votes Midtown.
I voted Midtown.
I've tried and tried to get into BN; no dice, though.
Poe-tryGirl
05/04/09, 01:22 PM
Brand New
Indoor Living
05/04/09, 01:36 PM
Midtown! I do not like Brand New; AT ALL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wow. Unnecessary. Brand New. Toughest poll ever on this site. I've never liked both of the candidates so much.
sweetforever
05/04/09, 01:38 PM
Brand New
ATL182fan
05/04/09, 02:01 PM
Midtown
ijbet59
05/04/09, 02:11 PM
Brand New.
I Love Midtown, but BrandNew are just too amazing.
deathcar
05/04/09, 02:31 PM
this was the hardest choice for me this week.
PenThrive
05/04/09, 02:33 PM
Brand Nizzle. Nuff said.
ASaveSituation
05/04/09, 02:53 PM
I'm sorry Midtown :-(
This one will go to Brand New by a long shot.
Forever.Zero
05/04/09, 03:21 PM
Brand New!
ktbear257
05/04/09, 03:25 PM
wow i miss midtown. but I voted Brand new.
inyoursea
05/04/09, 03:34 PM
Brand New. I feel sorry for every band that's come against BN in this haha..unfair really.
poor midtown, they never had a chance...not that they should against brand new
fueledbykate
05/04/09, 03:46 PM
ugggk, I cannot stand Brand New.. Midtown SHOULD take this but that's apparently not gonna happen.
MickShamrock
05/04/09, 03:49 PM
Brand New.
fiercetown
05/04/09, 04:03 PM
Brand New's probably gonna win it all, and it would be very deserved.
&IllBeTheReason
05/04/09, 04:35 PM
It really hurts me to vote against Midtown. So bad. But I could never vote against Your Favorite Weapon.
Jessamachine.
05/04/09, 04:54 PM
Brand New, hands down
TheSkyline
05/04/09, 04:58 PM
I totally respect Midtown, they are awesome, but I just have to go with Brand New.
TheSkyline
05/04/09, 04:59 PM
It really hurts me to vote against Midtown. So bad. But I could never vote against Your Favorite Weapon.
lolwut?
You decided to vote for Midtown because of Your Favorite Weapon? You should have just voted for Midtown, everything they have done kills that album. However, Deja and TDAG > Midtown.
&IllBeTheReason
05/04/09, 05:02 PM
lolwut?
You decided to vote for Midtown because of Your Favorite Weapon? You should have just voted for Midtown, everything they have done kills that album. However, Deja and TDAG > Midtown.
I disagree. Which is also coincidentally the entire point of the poll.
lostxmyxmind
05/04/09, 05:02 PM
but...but...:-( midtown
TheSkyline
05/04/09, 05:11 PM
I disagree. Which is also coincidentally the entire point of the poll.
Yeah, I know. But you voted for Brand New too. It just seems weird someone would vote against the awesomeness that is Midtown because of YFW, it really is just a very mediocre pop punk album. At least Midtown was good at pop punk.
&IllBeTheReason
05/04/09, 05:19 PM
Yeah, I know. But you voted for Brand New too. It just seems weird someone would vote against the awesomeness that is Midtown because of YFW, it really is just a very mediocre pop punk album. At least Midtown was good at pop punk.
I love Midtown probably as much as you do, but I started listening to Brand New in 8th grade and would have never even heard of Midtown if it hadn't been for YFW, so it only seems fair.
brokenhats
05/04/09, 05:36 PM
wow we got crushed
more heart
05/04/09, 05:58 PM
Hate to be that guy but, fuck Brand New. Midtown all the way.
simplybriannax3
05/04/09, 07:01 PM
eh. whatever, I still love Midtown infinitely more than Brand New.
SeanEBoy2686
05/04/09, 07:01 PM
shellacked!
Tristan Needler
05/04/09, 07:11 PM
Surprised you put Midtown against Brand New, Anton. You must have know how that would turn out, must have been painful to post.
GuitarR0cker1
05/04/09, 07:16 PM
This was a no-brainer. Sorry Midtown but Brand New hits me too hard.
Co and Ca
05/04/09, 07:17 PM
Brand New. the end.
DejaGuy89
05/04/09, 07:43 PM
http://i485.photobucket.com/albums/rr218/LftyRocker56/Photo36.jpg
guess who i voted for
Tristan Needler
05/04/09, 07:50 PM
http://i485.photobucket.com/albums/rr218/LftyRocker56/Photo36.jpg
guess who i voted for
Man or Astro-man?
DejaGuy89
05/04/09, 07:54 PM
Man or Astro-man?
hahaha
permanentdan
05/04/09, 07:55 PM
damn, i knew that ap.net users loved their brand new, but...damn.
apsterling
05/04/09, 07:57 PM
Midtown.
hubbabubbal3ts
05/04/09, 07:58 PM
midtown put out a terrible record in forget what you know. if they only would have ever put out living well, then i'd vote for them. bn has been solid everytime. i wish i didn't jump on the bandwagon, but i had to on this one.
lostxmyxmind
05/04/09, 08:04 PM
midtown put out a terrible record in forget what you know. if they only would have ever put out living well, then i'd vote for them. bn has been solid everytime. i wish i didn't jump on the bandwagon, but i had to on this one.
I actually really like Forget What You Know. It was the album that got me into Midtown.
ianxcurtis
05/04/09, 08:09 PM
Brand New, although I'm sad to see Midtown go. I thought it would be much closer than this.
guinness
05/04/09, 08:22 PM
I love Brand New but I listen to Midtown so much more, so the latter got my vote.
Talib Scottie
05/04/09, 08:36 PM
Brand New with some consideration for Midtown.
PatVaughn
05/04/09, 09:03 PM
it sucks that Brand New is going to beat Midtown...
fadedmemories
05/04/09, 09:07 PM
79/21 BN right now.
TheMisanthrope
05/04/09, 09:21 PM
brand new....midtown got an unfortunate match up here though
CarouselBoy
05/04/09, 09:38 PM
wow I didn't expect midtown to be losing this bad. Guess I overestimated the midtown fans on this site
TSTLSOOM
05/04/09, 10:07 PM
wow I didn't expect midtown to be losing this bad. Guess I overestimated the midtown fans on this site
no worries the CS fangirls will be arriving soon! MUHAHAHA
theguy77
05/04/09, 10:11 PM
http://i485.photobucket.com/albums/rr218/LftyRocker56/Photo36.jpg
guess who i voted for
im not the tattoo type, and if i got one it wouldnt be a reference to a band cause i would feel too fanboyish, but even so that is a sick tattoo haha.
glasscase501
05/05/09, 07:39 AM
wow I didn't expect midtown to be losing this bad. Guess I overestimated the midtown fans on this site
it's brand new i think any band would be losing this badly to them save for a few
Bruised26
05/05/09, 07:44 AM
I love the song It's my Life by No Doubt
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.