PDA

View Full Version : Clap Your Hands Say Yeah - Clap Your Hands Say Yeah


Greg Dona
01/23/06, 09:08 PM
Clap Your Hands Say Yeah are good. Say what you might about whiny, skill deprived vocals, but these men can play. They are like Modest Mouse. And the Arcade Fire. And Neutral Milk Hotel. And Bloc Party. In all honesty, Clap Your Hands Say Yeah are every indie band you’ve ever heard and then some. Did I mention that Clap Your Hands Say Yeah are good?

The group starts out its debut self-titled album with the outrageously inappropriate “Clap Your Hands!” Neither the lyrics nor the music is offensive, but rather the courage with which the group begins its humble career. Nobody in their right mind would release their first track in such an, as a criminal understatement, odd track. It is intriguing, but all together too experimental for the beginning of a group. But then again, isn’t this what makes us love Clap Your Hands Say Yeah?

A fair portion of songs lull by with few mentionable occurrences. Rather than releasing a CD full of thrashing or uniquely intriguing singles, Clap Your Hands Say Yeah have elected to put out a true collection of tracks with a gorgeous flow. The first, and only, truly eye-opening track is “The Skin of My Yellow Country Teeth.” A fuzzy background with movement inspiring drum lines provokes a relaxed sway from the most immobile of listeners. The rest of the album, much like its beginning stages, simply flows in the most impressive of ways. Much unlike the album you work to forget as it assaults your ears upon first listen, Clap Your Hands Say Yeah massages your ear drums into a beautiful musical oblivion that allows for an elementary lapse in concentration.

Clap Your Hands Say Yeah’s Clap Your Hands Say Yeah sounds like every indie disc you’ve ever bought. But then again, with its incredible collaboration of different indie styles, it sounds like nothing you’ve ever bought as well.

deja andyroo
01/23/06, 10:08 PM
This is a comment on the review, not the disc being reviewed (I haven't listened to it enough to form a cohesive opinion).

Not to be overly negative, but your review doesn't really tell me anything. After reading your review, I've picked this up: they're good, and they sound like every other indie band (but at the same time, don't). Add in a terribly confusing second paragraph, and little is achieved.

Due to the overall vagueness of the piece, it comes off as something written by someone who hasn't listened to the album very much (or very well). I'm not accusing you of this, it's just the first thing I think of after reading something like this. Also, when writing a review (especially of a debut album), assume the audience isn't familiar with the work. If we all knew everything about the band, why would we bother to read your article? While the band has certainly been covered on this site before, assume our minds are blank slates and give us some background information.

I'm not trying to be a prick, just offering some constructive criticism. Journalism is certainly a trial-and-error process, especially when you're young. Keep at it.

JunkBondTrader
01/23/06, 10:30 PM
i enjoy your reviews, they are well-written. they might lack a little depth about the overall sound of the band.....dont go and explain every track, becasue thats when reviews are fucking lame. that is why i enjoy pitchfork reviews, they dont go on and on about each individual track but more about the presentation and feel of the album. they make great comparisoons and inject humor at all the right times. i think you are on the right track honestly.

deja andyroo
01/23/06, 11:08 PM
I think there should be some balance between the two styles. I'm not fond of reviews that mention every single track on the album... I actually wrote a review like that a couple years ago and regretted it as soon as it was published. It becomes a monotonous experience for the reader. Still, I think a solid review should definitely highlight key tracks and elaborate on why they are so important.

Greg Dona
01/24/06, 06:13 AM
Haha. Looks like nobody enjoyed this review. I had to get it out somewhat quickly since I'm just trying to update our review section with a bunch of discs we never got around to covering earlier in the year. That's my lame disclaimer.

mogwaifearsatan
01/24/06, 10:20 AM
Decent review, but this album has been so hyped all over the internet that it's really played to death. Newer stuff!

yanggoh
01/26/06, 04:40 PM
yeah..uh...no offence, but this review didn't tell me anything.

JacksColdSweat
02/04/06, 06:50 PM
Has there ever been a negative review?

mchanning13
10/21/09, 11:53 AM
Have you guys heard Alec Ounsworth's solo project yet?? :)