Brand New vs mewithoutYou

[bard]

remember to choose on an overall aspect, not just their latest album.

my choice is mewithoutYou

[evvandflow]

to quote charlie murphy: "it ws a landslide victory"

BN.

[Tim Lincecum]

this wont be close, not only because of this sites BN bias but also just because mewithoutyou just simply is not as good and has a much smaller fan base in general... brand new packs venues and festival stages, mewithoutyou opens for the headliners of those venues

[Bloodsucker II]

mewithoutYou

[jbaseball44]

Tdag

[Forever.Zero]

and again when your head goes through the windshield

[Machu505]

Brand New easily.

[11:11]

If you want to see Brand New lose a poll, you're going to have to pit them against a band that has a wider fanbase. MWY is a great band, but there's just no way they can win this.

[bradnewman]

lol after brand new was in the finals on all of AP what is the point of this matchup lol

[bard]

frustration at the weezer vs mwY topic

lol

[Urglegrew]

k.

[jbertclassic]

mewithoutYou. i get to see these two back to back nights in July though.

[Theseventhson]

I accidently chose mwY. Oh well, I love both but Brand New may be my favorite band.

[sammyboy516]

its AP. brand new can't not win. if it weren't for the blink reunion they would have lost the march madness thing too, haha.

[doppelganger]

i picked mwY because they were losing. love both bands though. there are different reasons why i love both bands.

[Cheesus]

What a retarded thread

[Trauma Caspian]

Both bands are fantastic, but I would choose MWY

[DejaNew]

I love both, but I LOVE BN.

[TotalCollapse]

Brand New

[xBrandNew]

bn by far.

[timb89]

If you want to see Brand New lose a poll, you're going to have to pit them against a band that has a wider fanbase. MWY is a great band, but there's just no way they can win this.

true

[Heart-A-Tact]

mewithoutYou.

[fadedmemories]

BN cannot and will not lose.

[abbysmith]

I chose mewithoutYou because they were loosing by a lot and it is obvious Brand New are going to win. That being said, I do love Brand New.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

i'm surprised it's so close.

[Johnnydcp]

I never could get into MeWithoutYou.

[xJesusFreakx]

TDAG > Brother, Sister > Foxes = Deja > A-->B > it's all crazy! > YFW

Brand New.

[SeanEBoy2686]

this poll is a failure by design

[tonighttonight0]

mwY

[jawstheme]

this poll is a failure by design

I see what you did there.

[SeanEBoy2686]

I see what you did there.

this response made me laugh... so the dumb joke was worth it after all

[yayitsjoe]

well, brand new won in a landslide. but i still think Aaron Weiss is better than Jesse.

[PenThrive]

Two totally different bands, but I have been a fan of BN longer than I have with mwY

[Kill_the_radio]

when you put brand new or blink on a poll, you know that they're gonna kick ass.

[MyHereAfter]

Honestly I would like Brand New better if everyone would stop swinging on their nuts. mewithoutyou is awesome and so is brand new. mewithoutyou are more my thing though.

[just.Starla.]

Brand New

[oncedarkness]

mewithoutYou

[boysandbulletsx]

I can't vote because these are my two favorite bands and I don't want to choose which is better. Wow. This is probably the first time I'm not voting for Brand New.

[MarkAndros]

Easily Brand New, I just do not like live mewithoutYou and 80% of their songs. Left during their set when MO/The Snake The Cross The Crown opened for them and left early tonight when The Dear Hunter opened for them.

[showyourteeth]

mewithoutyou easily
even if i didnt really think much of their last album, i still prefer them over brand new

[princesschad]

Brand New, no contest. mwY opened for Brand New at my college a few months ago. I just can't get into them.

[billyboatkid]

Brand new. Easily

[Indoor Living]

Brand New. I've never really listened to mwY, but I've only heard good things.