PDA

View Full Version : Rocky Votolato - Makers


Garett Press
02/02/06, 12:02 PM
Rocky Votolato – Makers
{SCORE: 8.8/10}

1. What Daisy Passing
2. Portland is Leaving
3. The Night's Disguise
4. She Was Only in it For the Rain
5. Uppers Aren't Neccessary
6. Wait Out the Days
7. Streetlights
8. Tennessee Train Tracks
9. Goldfield
10. Tinfoil Hats
11. Where We Left Off
12. Makers

Rocky Votolato is the type of musician who makes my job easy. His voice and his sound are as one so picturesque and evocative, the descriptive adjectives and sonic metaphors could practically write themselves. A throat warming whiskey, the crackle of a dim hearth flame, a creaky wooden rocking chair, and the homely twang of a handmade acoustic guitar… if there was ever an image projected by musical composition, this is that of Rocky Votolato’s Makers.

In many senses, Makers is an album you’d expect from someone much older than Rocky V. Whereas Suicide Medicine seemed made to accompany a road trip slideshow (and Makers does as well to an extent), Makers gives a stronger vibe of a more stationary, road-weary Rocky; riper with a few years of age, pensive in reflection, contemplative of his rung on the ladder of success and love, and confidently deliberating the slow road to the grave. It’s a meditative pleasure to hear these ruminations in audio format and worth listening to if only for the invigorating refreshment of hearing acoustic rock with maroccas, slide guitar, tambourines, and harmonicas done right, ohhhh so right. All too rarely are we afforded the opportunity to enjoy this winning combination in such pure form.

Again as always, Votolato exercises his knack for tearing – and I mean tearing! – into the human core with soulful chords and worn melodic vocals. There are times where the laceration in your heartstrings is almost tangible, and this is by no means a relationship record. The romantic words penned for “The Night’s Disguise” (“the clouds are holding up the dawn / they're stilts or crutches I can't tell which one / to keep the short days looking longer / or to keep the sunlight from falling on broken legs / but the night's disguise is wearing thin”) work in beautiful contradiction with the convictive chorus; it’s a juxtaposition that stirs me every time. In other highlights, the piano accompanied outro of “Goldfield”, the rat-tat verses of “She Was Only in it for the Rain”, the dreamy finger picked conclusion of “Streetlights”, and the blossoming harmonies in “White Daisy Passing” all make for a thoroughly satisfying listen. I imagine that if we lived in an era that idolized brilliant singer/songwriters, Rocky would be a fan favorite.

As a record, it shares a similar flaw with Suicide Medicine. Until you’ve had repeated sittings, several tracks may fail to grip you, especially towards the tail end. It is also not as instantly attractive as Rocky’s past efforts, but picture it in this manner: you’ve encountered the attractive young adult, and now allow me to introduce you to the slightly wrinkled elder man. Don’t necessarily favor immediate appeal, but instead, seek out the wisdom within… then make your judgments.

Mine? Makers is as intoxicating as the whiskey after which it’s named.

badnewsherald
02/02/06, 12:12 PM
nice.

GoWaitInTheCar
02/02/06, 12:17 PM
Wait Out The Days is my favorite, it may change though.

Gabe Gross
02/02/06, 12:20 PM
wow....well said garett

love that last line...I'm gonna make an album called Jack

Scott Weber
02/02/06, 12:27 PM
this album is soooo good. Personally, it's actually my favorite Rocky album to date. I feel like it's the most well-rounded. It doesn't have any super amazing tracks on it, like the last one did ("Montana"...sigh) but there's less weak tracks.

Garett Press
02/02/06, 12:28 PM
this album is soooo good. Personally, it's actually my favorite Rocky album to date. I feel like it's the most well-rounded. It doesn't have any super amazing tracks on it, like the last one did ("Montana"...sigh) but there's less weak tracks.
yeah I'd agree with that, I was actually going to say that exact point about there being no "Montana" lol, ironic, but true

SLADE775
02/02/06, 12:50 PM
Great review Garett.

Gabe Gross
02/02/06, 01:02 PM
this album is like eating a bowl full of sugar chased with a bottle of aunt jemima

Dudebroham
02/02/06, 01:22 PM
This cd isnt that good, mediocre at best. Songwriting is rather dull, i've heard this sound from a thousand different artists, but better. yawn.

Garett Press
02/02/06, 01:24 PM
This cd isnt that good, mediocre at best. Songwriting is rather dull, i've heard this sound from a thousand different artists, but better. yawn.
One in particular?

bigmike
02/02/06, 02:50 PM
nice review. and i think this is a tremendous record.

unwritten
02/02/06, 02:50 PM
Makers and coke.....good drink

SC0926
02/02/06, 03:10 PM
One in particular?
yes examples please.. cuse this album is fantastic

onefallenhero
02/02/06, 03:47 PM
I picked this CD up with the intentions of a next Suicide Medicine. I gave it a listen once. It was nothing like Suicide Medicine. After looking at it on my desk I sat down with the lyrics and just listened. Rocky Votalato somehow can reinvent himself. After his days in Waxwings and old hardcore movies this album has his age written on it. I do not mean this to be insulting, however much of the folk music I usually consume it has great similarities. I love this album, and don't make the mistake I did. If your into more upbeat songs try "Tenneesee Train Tracks," or "White Daisy Passing." One of the best albums out this year! You should all check out Grizzley Bear. Garrett good job.

mewithoutyou
02/02/06, 04:27 PM
This album is very good but a couple of tracks (In It for The Rain and the last 2 tracks) hurt the album a lot. They are way below the level of tracks like White Daisy Passing, Tenessee is Leaving and Streetlights. Overall, there is no doubt these are his best songs but I'm leaning towards keeping Suicide Medicine as his most entertaining album in my mind.

TyroneShoolaces
02/02/06, 06:56 PM
good review.
i love this album so much.

Dudebroham
02/02/06, 07:45 PM
iron & wine, sufjan stevens... enough said. you cant expect everybody to like an album. It just didnt move me what so ever.

Garett Press
02/02/06, 07:52 PM
iron & wine, sufjan stevens... enough said. you cant expect everybody to like an album. It just didnt move me what so ever.
No, I'm not expecting you to like it, but you said 1,000 other artists with the same sound, and I don't think either of those artists sound like Rocky Votolato. I understand where you're coming from though. I do appreciate the dissenting opinion, I didn't mean to sound condescending.

Scott Weber
02/02/06, 08:15 PM
No, I'm not expecting you to like it, but you said 1,000 other artists with the same sound, and I don't think either of those artists sound like Rocky Votolato. I understand where you're coming from though. I do appreciate the dissenting opinion, I didn't mean to sound condescending.
Yeah, those artists aren't comprable to Rocky, especially Sufjan - totally different. I think he was just exaggerating because he didn't feel the record.

Jamison Kane
02/02/06, 08:15 PM
The demos that were circulating about a year ago were better than the proper release, imho. He cut some of the tail-end songs ("End Like This" being the strongest of them all) and pasted on the last few and the result is lackluster. I'd give the demos the rating you gave the retail record and probably bust the proper release down a few notches. That said, it's still a great record from an incredibly underrated artist. Good review.

Dudebroham
02/02/06, 08:40 PM
Maybe it's just me. I mean i think you can agree the comparison in sound, its a folky sound, I suppose I Just feel the artists I Just mentioned have made more of a movement on this type of sound, than Rocky has, But you did only ask for one example. I guess there always needs to be a mixed review.

Scott Weber
02/02/06, 08:43 PM
Maybe it's just me. I mean i think you can agree the comparison in sound, its a folky sound, I suppose I Just feel the artists I Just mentioned have made more of a movement on this type of sound, than Rocky has, But you did only ask for one example. I guess there always needs to be a mixed review.
I wouldn't even mention Sufjan and Rocky in the same sentance, personally.

Garett Press
02/02/06, 08:59 PM
Maybe it's just me. I mean i think you can agree the comparison in sound, its a folky sound, I suppose I Just feel the artists I Just mentioned have made more of a movement on this type of sound, than Rocky has, But you did only ask for one example. I guess there always needs to be a mixed review.
I feel that, and their movements were certainly greater. Rocky's cool though.. not many like him, and that's part of the score.

Garett Press
02/02/06, 09:01 PM
The demos that were circulating about a year ago were better than the proper release, imho. He cut some of the tail-end songs ("End Like This" being the strongest of them all) and pasted on the last few and the result is lackluster. I'd give the demos the rating you gave the retail record and probably bust the proper release down a few notches. That said, it's still a great record from an incredibly underrated artist. Good review.
Well said... I haven't heard the demos :'(

P.S. I read rockingthescene.com

Talib Scottie
02/03/06, 02:21 AM
this album is soooo good. Personally, it's actually my favorite Rocky album to date. I feel like it's the most well-rounded. It doesn't have any super amazing tracks on it, like the last one did ("Montana"...sigh) but there's less weak tracks.
Agreed 100%

mewithoutyou
02/03/06, 10:51 AM
The reason Iron & Wine and Sufjan made "greater moves" is because they both had a gimmick. The folk dude with a big beard and the guy with the funny name who has long sing titles about the state of Illionois.

Rocky Votolato doesn't have any wacky physical traits or outstanding album concepts. He just plays accoustic Americana & rock songs and lets the music speak for itself.

Garett Press
02/03/06, 10:52 AM
The reason Iron & Wine and Sufjan made "greater moves" is because they both had a gimmick. The folk dude with a big beard and the guy with the funny name who has long sing titles about the state of Illionois.

Rocky Votolato doesn't have any wacky physical traits or outstanding album concepts. He just plays accoustic Americana & rock songs and lets the music speak for itself.
I hear that man

hoad0404
02/05/06, 06:18 PM
This is a great album, takes a couple listens to fully appreciate, but once it sinks in you can just sit back and enjoy.

Someone here said to check out the Grizzly Bear cd, so I did... and... yeah... not so good.

Decemberist
02/09/06, 11:23 AM
i love this album.
i would agree there are a few weak tracks. but i think makers is one of the most beautiful song ive heard in such a long time.
'heaven or heavenless, we're all headed for the same sweet darkness'

i love that so much.

Jamison Kane
02/21/06, 08:53 PM
P.S. I read rockingthescene.com
Oh, so you're the one ;)

Read jamisonlikewhat.com, instead. All jlw, all the time.

Jamison Kane
02/21/06, 08:56 PM
P.S. I read rockingthescene.com
Oh, so you're the one ;)

Check out my signature site, sometime. Basically what I do for RTS, but on a daily basis.

Garett Press
02/21/06, 08:58 PM
Oh, so you're the one ;)

Check out my signature site, sometime. Basically what I do for RTS, but on a daily basis.
hahaha, sweet I definitely will (the link in your sig is messed up btw)

i really enjoy the stuff you write about and how you say the things you say

Sureshot182
03/30/06, 11:08 AM
GREAT review. the last paragraph sums up the cd pefectly.

Boring Pop Song
03/31/06, 03:12 PM
great review. this is already one of my favorite albums of all time