Your Favorite Current Band vs. Your Favorite All-Time Band

[flks511]

Tell your favorite band currently together and your favorite band that has broken up.

Then tell which you think is better.

[glassj4w87]

currently - everytime i die all time - rush hands down rush. Giddy Lee best bass player ever, neal peart, and of course the other guy in rush noone cares about.

[SSLYBY]

Wouldn't it be your all-time favorite band??

[flks511]

Wouldn't it be your all-time favorite band??
Meant to say favorite band not currently together.

[love_american_style]

Orchid and Far.

Far still wins.

[oddwithoutend]

Current Favourite: Mount Eerie
Favourite that no longer exists: The Microphones
Overall, The Microphones have released more great material.
Is that cheating?

[ThisIsNotDan]

current favorite: Set Your Goals
all time favorite: Cave In

Cave In, definetly

[thespearkid]

Current favorite is Dirty Projectors. All time favorite is Neutral Milk Hotel. There is nothing better than Neutral Milk Hotel.

[micahistheballs]

Current Favourite: Bob Dylan
Broken Up Favourite: Neutral Milk Hotel
Bob Dylan takes the cake of course.

[thespearkid]

Current Favourite: Bob Dylan
Broken Up Favourite: Neutral Milk Hotel
Bob Dylan takes the cake of course.
Close but I disagree.

[thesafeword]

Current: Bomb the Music Industry!
All Time: Cap'n Jazz

AND WHO GIVES A FUCK?

[bard]

mewithoutYou vs mewithoutYou

mewithoutYou

[WakeUpBlondie]

Current: Thursday
All Time: Radiohead

[SanePsychotic]

Current: Green Day
Broken up: Jawbreaker

There are better bands than both of these.

[Rodeo]

Current: Sunn 0)))
All-Time: The Beatles



I think the winner is a little clear there...

[_><_]

Current: Portugal. The Man
Broken up: The Blood Brothers

[theguy77]

current: radiohead
all-time: brand new

haha. current, no contest. brand new were my favorite for 5 years, deja entendu changed the way i looked at music, but to be fair kid A changed it again and made me a lot more open minded, and also made it so that i was impacted by components to the music i had never really noticed before. plus radiohead is very easily the better band haha.

TDAG is still a pretty impressive album technically though and brand new remains one of my favorites for more than nostalgic reasons.

[begforthebagel]

current: set your goals
all-time: mad caddies

[IWasaCamera]

No clear cut favorites, either current or all-time. Always been more of an album man.

[boredstiff]

My favourite band probably changes every couple of weeks.

Currently: Alexisonfire
All time: Tool

[xsinkshipsx]

current: anything facedown records
all time: copeland

copeland

[CalRahhh]

Current favourite is Converge. All time is The Smashing Pumpkins.

The Smashing Pumpkins will never be topped for me.

[VampiresRevenge]

Current: Jack's Mannequin
Broken up: Something Corporate

It's a tie between them, for me.

[michelle182]

current/always: Brand New
broken up: Midtown or Neutral Milk Hotel .... or Something Corporate

Brand New > all of them (I can't really talk for NMH though)
But my love for them stands.

[CollectiveConfusion]

current: brand new
all time : lifetime (although they got back together... but i'm still counting them)

tough call

[Colinreturn]

All-time (broken up) - the old hellogoodbye
Current - enter shikari
genre switch?

Choose? Hellogoodbye, by far, has defined my musical taste compared to any other band ive ever listened to.

[chipdip18]

Sorry, but Bob Dylan is better than Neutral Milk Hotel.

[SanePsychotic]

Sorry, but Bob Dylan is better than Neutral Milk Hotel.

I'll agree with you because I have never been a big fan of NMH. Not my thing at the moment.

[chipdip18]

I'll agree with you because I have never been a big fan of NMH. Not my thing at the moment.

Well i mean you just have to face the facts about it, NMH has one stellar album, Bob Dylan has at least three. Bob Dylan's been way more influencial and relevant.

[IWasaCamera]

Sorry, but Bob Dylan is better than Neutral Milk Hotel.
No contest.

[brwnhawaiin]

current:The Warlocks
Broken up: Moccasin
All Time: Brand New

Moccasin is SOOOO good, its such a shame that they only released one cd "last leaf" and then disappeared into Denver somwhere...so sad.
The Warlocks are amazing, have been around for 10 years, and I LOVE their latest two cds
Brand New...I dont need to say anything.

[TakeLotsWithAlcohol]

All Time: Tie between Thursday and Alkaline Trio
Current: Portugal. The Man
Broken Up: The Blood Brothers and At the Drive-In


Thursday and Alkaline Trio> All of those in my opinion.

[Dempsey]

Current: Agraceful
All time : Saetia ( dead )

[Jake Denning]

This is way too hard with one band, so i'm cheating with 2

All Time: Project 86, The Showdown
Current: The Ghost Inside, A Day To Remember
Broken Up: Terminal, Subseven

[maoverbey]

Current: Circle Takes The Square
Broken Up: The Sound of Animals Fighting

[muchoawesomeo]

mewithoutYou vs mewithoutYou

mewithoutYou
agreed

[Kutty]

all time- 36 Crazyfists

Current. A day to remember=Dance gavin dance

Broke up- Still Remains

[Machu505]

Cursive v. Rx Bandits with a Cursive victory.

EDIT: Oops I did this wrong. Cursive v. The Format with a Cursive victory.

[fivergirl]

Current Favourite: Taking Back Sunday
Broken Up Favourite: Grade

[flks511]

Forgot to add in mine.

Current fav.: Silverstein
Broken up: The Movielife