Stories & Alibis or Voices

[Mscales67]

personally S&A....

[Bobcat46308]

Voices, give it a chance and it'll grow on you.

although playing for keeps is still one of my favorite songs, whatever it's a really cool song

[Mscales67]

Voices, give it a chance and it'll grow on you.

although playing for keeps is still one of my favorite songs, whatever it's a really cool song

playing for keeps is my favorite MBR song

[takeourcarsnow]

Voices, give it a chance and it'll grow on you.

although playing for keeps is still one of my favorite songs, whatever it's a really cool song
agreed

[xburningcoffin]

i don't really like any of the LP's, West for Wishing is way better and Fourteen Ballons would kill if it was longer

[pinkjinx87]

Voices

[crit]

not a matchbook fan.

[keelan]

S & A but Monsters is such a strong single!!!!

[jahh]

not much of a fan...blegh

[dashboard1190]

I tried to listen to Voices on AOL Music and just wasn't blown away. I really like Stories & Alibis, and "If All Else Fails" is a great 'missing you' song.

[Mike Kraft]

I think Voices is a more solid album than S&A

[josiahh]

Voices, hands down.

Stories has a couple good tracks, but i couldn't listen to it for more than 2 or 3 songs because his voice was just unbearable...

they vastly improved on Voices, even if it does miss slightly more than it hits.

[terrier_punk]

Stories & Alibis...

[Fury15]

stories and alibis is too whiny for me. i chose voices

[Burnout2888]

Every song on Voices to me is awesome. I don't know, I can't explain what it does to me... it's just such a step up from S&A and yes, it is a huge grower. I hated it at first and now I am head over heels about it.

[wasteoftaste]

voices blow.

[A000lex]

They changed way to much on Voices. I voted S & A

[a speedo model]

stories & alibis for me, voices got old after like a week.

[jdawg09]

I have to say when i first heard voices, I wasnt really into it....I was a way bigger fan of S&A ......but then I started really listening to voices and it might be one of my favorite albums this year thus far.....strong songs include monsters, fiction, my mannequin can dance and surrender

[Kyner]

The lead singer's voice is whiny and annoying live. Promise is an awesome song though.

[Klemasser]

Gotta go with Voices. Stories & Alibies got a bit stagnant after a while. It has some great songs, just doesn't have the staying power. Voices is very different and very great, I love the style. It took a few listens to really get into, but it's just a damn good album.

[cahrishurr]

voices

wtf their first LP was mediocre stuff that had been done a million times before
i mean sure it was catchy and all..but its not lasting

voices like made me say wow the second i heard it

[hobbes2809]

S & A

but love them both

[Bury Your Head]

Every song on Voices to me is awesome. I don't know, I can't explain what it does to me... it's just such a step up from S&A and yes, it is a huge grower. I hated it at first and now I am head over heels about it.

dude..
fucking agreed.
every song is great and "lucky like my two left shoes" is probally their best song in my opinion next to you can run,.. but we'll find you

[hobbes2809]

dude..
fucking agreed.
every song is great and "lucky like my two left shoes" is probally their best song in my opinion next to you can run,.. but we'll find you

ummm "goody like two shoes" ?

and yes.

[clandestinerdc]

I chose Voices cause I'm really digging Monsters right now. Though S&A is good too.

[CradlingxHatred]

I'd have to go with Stories and Alibis.
Although it is also true that Voices does grow on you and have shown much maturity.
However, I don't think it is still as solid as S&A.

[NoPenguinsInPA]

Fourteen Ballons would kill if it was longer
truth.

however, if you try to compare fourteen balloons with a track like, say, "goody, like two shoes", you'll realize they're not the same band. they changed so much from s&a to voices, i thought they could probably change their name a third time (since fizzlewink and the getaway didn't last).

[HeartLikeAGun27]

How about the EP? "Hollywood and Vine" is my fav. from them.

[Fury15]

everytime i hear voices i like it better. the best opening track since deja entendu's

[Alba]

Stories and Alibis. I can't get into Voices.

[CantBeStopped]

stories and alibis was more catchy... but i do think voices was an excellent album and a great improvement for the band. voices is so different, in a good way. its hard to choose

[Bobcat46308]

Voices is seriously my favorite album of the year. At first, I just thought it was a good album, a little better than S&A, but now that I've listened to it over and over, it sounds amazing. Surrender and Goody, Like Two Shoes probably my favorite songs right now, I can't stop listening to them.

but S&A is winning? alright

[falling_apart13]

voices because the first one was good but i think voices showed more depth

[Dan1234]

Matchbook blows

[Branevember31]

i gave voices a chance, listening to it almost every day for 2 weeks, and i still hate it. i love s&a tho

[FOBPrettyNPunk]

Stories & Alibis, I never got into Voices.

[mrzippo3]

their ep is really good... anyone else listen to these guys when they were "The Getaway?" I have some songs from back then.. that version of Promise is really good and they had a great song called Ex Marks the Spot.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Stories and Alibis, definitley. I only really like one track on Voices.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

their ep is really good... anyone else listen to these guys when they were "The Getaway?" I have some songs from back then.. that version of Promise is really good and they had a great song called Ex Marks the Spot.

Yeah I love that song

[SorryAboutThat]

Voices is so much more varied than Stories & Alibis which seemed to differ very little from song to song throughout the album... I like the direction Voices headed in rather than sticking to that same emo/screamo formula so many bands have used since Stories & Alibis came out