Bigger Hack

[flks511]

Which of the two, in your opinion is a worse comedian?

[Silzildrummer]

Mencia easily. I'm not a fan of dane cook either, but there's no comparison in my opinion.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

I can admit to laughing at some old Dane cook jokes. What makes him unfunny is his attitude and delivery. Mencia is just generally unfunny on top of coming across as a dbag.

[briewer]

Mencia, definitely. I hate him because he spouts racist, sexist, xenophobic bullshit, and then tries to convince me that those are the same things that I think and I just don't have the balls to admit it. What I REALLY think, Mr. Mencia, is that you can suck on my BALLS, bitch.

[Hull]

Mencia is a joke stealing ass hole.
Dane Cook at least tells his not-funny stories well.

[MADSTA]

I don't think Dane deserves all the hate he gets.

[briewer]

I don't think Dane deserves all the hate he gets.
Oh yes he does. He's just second worst to a legend in worst-ness. Dane Cook is HARRRRABLE.

[batmannj]

I think that Mencia is by far the worst of the two. Dane Cook's older stuff still cracks me.

[jay_klinkhammer]

Dane really doesn't. The reason he is famous is because of how he delivers his comedy. He could've easily just stood up there and gave dead pan delivery, but then he would just be in a sea of mediocrity.

[jbaseball44]

Both are terrible, Mencia is worse.

[TheZeroKid]

Mencia got really old really fast. I still like Dane Cook.

[hells army]

Dane Cook rules.

[i'm a big deal.]

Dane Cook is fucking hilarious.. I don't care what anyone says.

[darkmartheight]

Mencia is the bigger hack.

[showyourteeth]

easily mencia

dane cook is at least funny sometimes

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Definitely Mencia

[Neo Cassady]

Mencia by a mile.

[Bloodsucker II]

lulz, isn't Carlos' real name Ned?

[flks511]

lulz, isn't Carlos' real name Ned?
Yeah. That's one of the reasons I hate him so much, because pretty much his whole act is built around his "ethnicity" when he's even lying about that. He's not Hispanic at all.

[Machu505]

Mencia.

[Machu505]

Yeah. That's one of the reasons I hate him so much, because pretty much his whole act is built around his "ethnicity" when he's even lying about that. He's not Hispanic at all.
I'm pretty sure a person's first name doesn't determine their ethnicity.

[flks511]

I'm pretty sure a person's first name doesn't determine their ethnicity.
Shouldn't say Hispanic, I mean he's not from Mexico. But he still tries to play off the whole "I'm a beaner" thing as the main focus of his routine. Anyway, that's not the only reason I dislike him.

[superichie]

Dane has definitely begun to irritate me over the last few years, but Mencia has ALWAYS sucked.

[Machu505]

Shouldn't say Hispanic, I mean he's not from Mexico. But he still tries to play off the whole "I'm a beaner" thing as the main focus of his routine. Anyway, that's not the only reason I dislike him.
After a quick search on Wikipedia, I've found out that his dad was Mexican and Mencia was born in Honduras. I thought that counted. :shrug:

[flks511]

After a quick search on Wikipedia, I've found out that his dad was Mexican and Mencia was born in Honduras. I thought that counted. :shrug:
He isn't from Mexico. And regardless of what ethnicity he is, the point was that he changed his name to make himself seem more Hispanic so he could tell the shitty jokes he does, which pisses me off.

[Machu505]

He isn't from Mexico. And regardless of what ethnicity he is, the point was that he changed his name to make himself seem more Hispanic so he could tell the shitty jokes he does, which pisses me off.
Agreed.

[Theseventhson]

I hate both but Mencia used to actually make me mad when I heard his stupid voice.

[seraph1214]

I actually enjoy Dane Cook, but Mencia is SO fucking horrible.

[FairwayH8er]

I hate both but Mencia used to actually make me mad when I heard his stupid voice.

The very existence of carlos mencia makes me want to kill people

[ManicanParty49]

No contest. Mencia. Has never been funny. Never will be funny. At least I Dane was moderately enjoyable at one point.

[Yellowcard2006]

I like both of their comedy. I can say I've watched and enjoyed all of their specials.

[Tim Lincecum]

mencia is the worst of any comedian ive ever seen, dane cook used to be funny, but even if hated dane cook id still think he was much better than mencia, anyone who thinks mencia is funny is wrong

[texasisbrendan]

mencia.

he coined the term 'dee dee dee', which in my opinion gives him the landslide victory

[tonighttonight0]

Carlos Mencia is the poor man's George Lopez, which makes him even worse...

[zachff]

Carlos Mencia sucks

[BulleTheory]

i dont think ive ever laughed at a Mencia joke

[The Pharmacist]

mencia rips off other comics all the time

[Cal50]

both are horrible, but the difference between dane cook and mencia is that dane cook makes a career out of bad jokes while mencia just spouts a bunch of racist xenophobic shit. mencia wins (loses) in this case.

[LPcatitoRJA]

Dane Cook easilyyy

[derekmoyer4]

mencia by far.

[schenksta]

dane cook needs to give up. at least he was good in employee of the month

[shoe print]

I use to like Cook for awhile. But he gets old. Not that I dont like a good laugh, but I can't listen to him for that long. So I'd say Mencia

[zaron5551]

mencia, but barely. Dane Cook stole jokes from Louis CK

[newfoundmichael]

I was on the "hate Dane Cook" banwagon for a while, but I have to admit that he can be a funny guy at times. His new stuff had me going a bit at times.

Carlos Mencia is a joke...and not the good kind.

[harveyn590]

mencia no doubt

[harveyn590]

mencia, but barely. Dane Cook stole jokes from Louis CK


yes but mencia stole like literally 30min of a george lopez act

[bard]

just youtube "carlos mencia bill cosby" and you'll see how much of a hack mencia is

dane cook had a good first special, but went downhill after that. he's just annoying.

voted mencia

[Charblarger]

dont like either of them. But Dane cook has a few funny bits. mencia does not

[Gumbyjag]

fuck carlos mencia.

[Mikey Paine]

dane has his moments.

[spunkmastaflex]

When you say hack, i think fake. And since Mencia is a joke stealing ass hole, (see joe rogan hilarious video if you havent), Mencia is the biggest hack

[DropDeadSharkey]

Dane Cook has better delivery on his jokes at least. Carlos Mencia just isn't funny lol.