All Time Low: SWIR or NP?

[Deadbolt01]

Just want an overall opinion. For me Nothing Personal has not lived up to So Wrong at all, an album I really liked. Its a shame, for me anyways. What about you?

PS: No "I Hate ATL they are the worst thing thats happened to music blah blah"-esque comments necessary.

[11:11]

Swir.

[jjjkman]

I wasn't a very big fan of So Wrong its Right, and I'm pretty addicted to almost every song on Nothing Personal right now, so I'm gonna have to go with it, that could always change though.

[darkmartheight]

Haven't heard NP enough yet, but so far SWIR is better.

[Broden Terry]

Haven't listened to Nothing Personal. I'll come back and vote when I have... If I remember. :-)

[Piss]

the party scene

[GoodTimes]

SWIR was pretty mediocre but NP is god awful

[rckstr29]

the party scene

Ya. They should have at least mentioned this album. It's pretty awesome. I actually prefer PUOSU myself.

[seraph1214]

Nothing Personal. I never could fully get into SWIR, and NP has ridiculously good hooks.

[idonotnosry]

the party scene
yes please.

[hf57]

so wrong it's right, by far.

[S9Dallasoz]

Nothing Personal. Hands down.

[xxxjessicaxx255]

yes please.

Defiantly The party scene it wasn't as over produced, but I like all their music.

[Paulb-182]

Other

[muttley]

Other.

[kazuma_ootaro28]

Ya. They should have at least mentioned this album. It's pretty awesome. I actually prefer PUOSU myself.

Put Up or Shut Up is the correct answer.

[handlikesecret]

Put Up or Shut Up.

but from the choices up there, Nothing Personal by far. So Wrong was just awkward.

[Yeahhitslindsey]

I just think that NP is over produced. To many fake pop-ey sounds. I want the BAND to play, not the computerized instruments. The lyrics are decent, and Poison made the album so much better in my opinion.
But I think SWIR is the best of the two. For the most part I love all of the songs on SWIR, where on NP I skip at least two songs every time I listen to it because its just annoying.
I'm a HUGE All Time Low fan, but I will say that NP was a bust. I still love the band, but NP is just not up to my ATL standard.

[Deadbolt01]

Ya. They should have at least mentioned this album. It's pretty awesome. I actually prefer PUOSU myself.
Would have done but I was only after a comparison between these two. Party Scene kinda gets mixed up with put up or shut up anyways, loads of the songs are the same.
Haven't listened to Nothing Personal. I'll come back and vote when I have... If I remember. :-)
hehe busted. *Nostalgia*
I just think that NP is over produced. To many fake pop-ey sounds. I want the BAND to play, not the computerized instruments. The lyrics are decent, and Poison made the album so much better in my opinion.
But I think SWIR is the best of the two. For the most part I love all of the songs on SWIR, where on NP I skip at least two songs every time I listen to it because its just annoying.
I'm a HUGE All Time Low fan, but I will say that NP was a bust. I still love the band, but NP is just not up to my ATL standard.
Exactly how I feel :)

[Paulb-182]

I just think that NP is over produced. To many fake pop-ey sounds. I want the BAND to play, not the computerized instruments. The lyrics are decent, and Poison made the album so much better in my opinion.
But I think SWIR is the best of the two. For the most part I love all of the songs on SWIR, where on NP I skip at least two songs every time I listen to it because its just annoying.
I'm a HUGE All Time Low fan, but I will say that NP was a bust. I still love the band, but NP is just not up to my ATL standard.

The last two albums were utter shit.

This band had potential then fucked it up by trying to appeal to people who don't like music

[ManicanParty49]

SWIR was too safe. Six feet under the stars sounds like they literally sat down and said "we need a single". I like some of the songs, but most of them blend together and nothing really stands out. I'm really glad that they took some risks on NP, because imo it really paid off, and will help separate them in the long run.

[Ari Christos]

I've never really gotten into this band (I tried, I just can't) but I did give Nothing Personal a fair listen, and enjoyed some of those tracks. So, I guess that.

[jjjkman]

the party scene

yes.

[MusicTalks]

NP's got hooks for days.

[Alli<3ATL!!!!!!]

I LOVE NOTHING PERSONAL ITS AWESOME!!!!

[ApricotChick]

I can't say.. havn't listened to NP yet. But I have SWIR, and it took awhile to grow on me..But once it did, I was obessed with it.

[ApricotChick]

I LOVE NOTHING PERSONAL ITS AWESOME!!!!
There's no way your 19.

[Alli<3ATL!!!!!!]

There's no way your 19.
Uhm well I am Okay.

[kristanxmarie]

Both are awful, but NP makes SWIR sound like a work of genius, so I went with SWIR.

[tjb4233]

Nothing Personal is better for me.

[Hull]

...how about no atl?

[jbaseball44]

3rd option needed.

[fadedmemories]

I am a biased fan of this band.

[Deadbolt01]

Shut up with the 'other' or 'I don't like the band at all' posts. Clearly not the point of the poll, I wanted to see which of those two people thought was better.

[tttygxlove]

Haven't heard NP enough yet, but so far SWIR is better.
agreed.

[Indoor Living]

There's no way your 19.
Look where she's from.

So Wrong It's Right.

[FullCollaspe]

What about neither?

[ApricotChick]

I bought NP today, and maybe it's just the fact that I'm not as familiar with it as I am SWIR, but SWIR wins by a landslide. NP is very over produced, some songs I really like like 'Damned..' but SWIR def.

[Forever.Zero]

I Hate ATL they are the worst thing thats happened to music

:)

[The Summer Ends]

I think both albums are good, but SWIR has too many throw away songs. On NP there's Hello Brooklyn, but on SWIR there's Come One Come All, The Beach, and Poppin' Champagne.

[TelAllUrFriends]

SWIR. I've listened to NP once and can't bring myself to give it a second chance. Maybe some day.

[TelAllUrFriends]

I bought NP today, and maybe it's just the fact that I'm not as familiar with it as I am SWIR, but SWIR wins by a landslide. NP is very over produced, some songs I really like like 'Damned..' but SWIR def.

yes.

[bduke13]

The correct answer is The Party Scene

[ApricotChick]

I think both albums are good, but SWIR has too many throw away songs. On NP there's Hello Brooklyn, but on SWIR there's Come One Come All, The Beach, and Poppin' Champagne.
I had a hard time w/ SWIR because I could barely tell the difference between the songs, but now I think they're all gems and couldn't see any of them being '"throw away" songs. I just don't think NP lives up to SWIR in any way; it's so straight up pop and over produced. Maybe it was just completely different than what I expected, but I still don't like it.

[MattRM]

So Wrong It's Right hit me at a better time than Nothing Personal did. Although, nostalgia aside, I really do think SWIR is a better album.

[Wait_For_It]

So Wrong, It's Right

[Deadbolt01]

wow, close. Like it.

[nickthehick2]

Wow, Nothing Personal is winning by 1? Where's The Party Scene?

[Krs-One]

voted so wrong it's right but party scene will always be their best

[nerdvglc]

i went withh swir, but there's a chance i just haven't heard the new album enough to have given it an equal-opportunity-chance. and unfortunately, i got into this band right after the release of put up or shut up and haven't come by the party scene record, so i have no idea as to how that lp compares.

[doppelganger]

i picked 'swir' because its fun to say.

[Deadbolt01]

Man, exactly 50-50, thats coool.

[zachff]

Damn, 50-50. I went with So Wrong It's Right

[tttygxlove]

I broke the tie with NP - there are only two songs I can't get into, I still can't get into much of SWTR since it came out.

[sokonfused]

from these two choices, i'm going to have to go with nothing personal. but it's definitely not my favorite overall.

[fortythieves]

Everything on SWIR sounded the same to me.
Though neither of those choices are my favorite.

[crimsonandclovr]

i feel like some tunes and melodies on SWIR were a bit forced. (does that makes sense?)
NP is just ridiculously addicting. Lyrics are better, guitar hooks are catchier.

not to be one of those kids, but i still love Put Up or Shut Up more than those two combined. As for The Party Scene, it's awesome and all. but i need to find a tangible copy of it! frustrating.

[VIVALAMATT]

Neither!

[UnderclasHero]

SWIR beats them ALL! I'll tell you why. Because they went a little downhill with NP with walls hello brook, and too much. you cant me you actually like too much. they're my fav band and I was so shocked when I heard that monstrosity of a song. Overall swir IS atl. Its their original sound, and prob best describes them.. theres not 1 song on there I dont like. there you go

[brokencyde]

Nothing personal. Even though its over produced

[gjpinizz]

pathetic that this is tied. nothing personal is so bad compared to so wrong its right

[fanberlinboy]

So Wrong, It's Right for sure. I only listen to maybe 3 tracks from Nothing Personal still.

[karadoll]

I enjoy Nothing Personal more, but So Wrong, It's Right is better.

Love all of their stuff, though.

[chelsealouanne]

So Wrong, It's Right.
Although, I like Nothing Personal aswell. Just don't think it tops Swir.