A Fever You Can't Sweat Out vs Pretty.Odd.

[AussieBoy]

with all this talk about Panic (!) being split into two and what there new sound will be like from the two albums, ive noticed most ppl seem to be fairly split down the middle which albums style they preferred

personally i went nuts for Fever, while still liking Pretty Odd (it was cruisy n nice to play when hungover etc, n had some mad songs like northern downpour) i was into Fever more as it was funner and everyone rocked out hard when those songs came on at rock clubs

no option for liking both equally... so there! :P

[Broden Terry]

I think I prefer A Fever You Can't Sweat Out. I love Pretty. Odd though.

[Burn_Burn_Burn]

Vote for AFYCSO. Pretty. Odd. Was. Horrible.

[fadedmemories]

I love both. A lot.

Right now, I'm more into AFYCSO though.

[Loge182]

I liked Pretty. Odd. alot more the AFYCSO. I loved the Beatlesness of it. Alot of the songs on Fever just bored me, although it had some gems.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

i don't like either really that much, but i love the beatles. so pretty. odd.

[Bloodsucker II]

Pretty.Odd. by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrr rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

[ghsNICK!]

Things are shaping up to be Pretty. Odd.

[FullCollaspe]

at least I can listen to one song of Pretty Odd.

[roche]

Both albums are so different it's hard to judge. But I think I listen to Pretty.Odd more than the debut though both albums are great. I'm defiantly looking forward to both of the new projects by these guys.

[icantbreakthis]

I definitely loved both and it's difficult to choose, because the two styles were so different. But currently, if I had to choose probably AFYCSO.

Although, Live In Chicago just combines the two :P

[Shin Akuma]

pretty odd is way more catchy for me ..

[just.Starla.]

I liked Pretty. Odd., but I liked A Fever You Can't Sweat Out better.

[color_coded]

Pretty. Odd. was okay, but I like AFYCSO more.

[TangledUp]

Pretty.Odd is lightyears better than Fever. Though I enjoy both albums for different reasons.

[Theseventhson]

Fever, didn't care for Pretty. Odd.

[11:11]

Loved Fever, then grew out of it. Now I love Pretty. Odd.

[didwhat77times]

Pretty. Odd.
I think I've only listened to Fever one or two time since Pretty. Odd. came out.

[TangledUp]

Loved Fever, then grew out of it. Now I love Pretty. Odd.
Yep, that's what happened with me too.

[thespearkid]

pretty. odd. may just be a beatles rip off but it showed a huge progression from the band. they were actually attempting to write lyrics that were good, not just "clever", or whatever bullshit term the Fall Out Boy crowd are using these days to excuse their favorite band's shitty lyrics. true, the results were often terrible but at least they were trying. musically, the album is a really interesting pop record. huge choruses. i like pretty. odd. a lot better.

[tomakebelieve]

i liked pretty.odd. and i will listen to it when i'm in more a melancholy mood, but Fever is what made me like panic and it still is a great jam from beginning to end in any mood.

[dru]

loved both albums for different reasons. i loved fever, it was different than anything that i really heard at the time, and it was good in a creative and catchy kind of way. i loved pretty. odd because of how original it was and how musically-impressive it was. i love both albums but i think pretty. odd wins the race for me. i still spin both albums today, panic just doesn't disappoint.

[Neo Cassady]

I could never get into P.O. with the exception of a few songs. I still listen to Fever every now and then.

[Yellowcard2006]

Pretty. Odd. I don't enjoy Fever.

[MyWorldEntire]

pretty. odd. may just be a beatles rip off but it showed a huge progression from the band. they were actually attempting to write lyrics that were good, not just "clever", or whatever bullshit term the Fall Out Boy crowd are using these days to excuse their favorite band's shitty lyrics. true, the results were often terrible but at least they were trying. musically, the album is a really interesting pop record. huge choruses. i like pretty. odd. a lot better.

Well said.

[superichie]

this is gonna be like the 2000 Election. It seems like there is a pretty even split on this one.

[superichie]

pretty. odd. may just be a beatles rip off but it showed a huge progression from the band. they were actually attempting to write lyrics that were good, not just "clever", or whatever bullshit term the Fall Out Boy crowd are using these days to excuse their favorite band's shitty lyrics. true, the results were often terrible but at least they were trying. musically, the album is a really interesting pop record. huge choruses. i like pretty. odd. a lot better.

Fall Out Boy's shitty lyrics? I actually looked at Fall Out Boy as being pretty creative the first time I heard their "clever" lyrics. Wouldn't shitty be writing lyrics that directly rip off another bands writing style? *cough* The Beatles *cough*

I'm sorry, but that opening song on Pretty. Odd. is so Sgt. Pepper sounding (musically and lyrically) that it makes me sick.

[WFUJerseyJon]

Pretty. Odd. still has yet to get old for me whereas I couldn't listen to Fever anymore after like 2 weeks.

[thespearkid]

Fall Out Boy's shitty lyrics? I actually looked at Fall Out Boy as being pretty creative the first time I heard their "clever" lyrics. Wouldn't shitty be writing lyrics that directly rip off another bands writing style? *cough* The Beatles *cough*

I'm sorry, but that opening song on Pretty. Odd. is so Sgt. Pepper sounding (musically and lyrically) that it makes me sick.
Yeah, Fall Out Boy writes shitty lyrics. Any 15-17 year old could write them.

[doppelganger]

pretty odd but i dont really like panic

[AussieBoy]

Go Fever with the comeback!!!!

[andrew_upto11]

Pretty. Odd. Hands down.

[Hull]

Fever. No contest.

[BulleTheory]

i cant stand A Fever...Pretty. Odd. was actually decent

[lolligurl159]

I loved both of them, but I think Fever is better. It was different at the time and. I still listen to it, so.

[ManicanParty49]

Pretty.Odd is lightyears better than Fever. Though I enjoy both albums for different reasons.

this.

I chose Fever though, because I think the's two different sounds (electronic and ragtime) were very complimentary, and it was a little more creative on their part.

[jtresk26]

Let's just say Pretty. Odd. is the best ttile for that CD.

[Kaku]

Pretty. Odd. neverreally grew on me. It is just not the sound I like. It may be better, musical-wise, but I am not so a sophisticated listener and like it more catchier.

[texasisbrendan]

Fever; I only liked a few songs on PO

[TheSkyline]

I think I prefer A Fever You Can't Sweat Out. I love Pretty. Odd though.

Feel the same way. I think AFYCSO, but I don't really know. Too different to pick.

[AussieBoy]

this.

I chose Fever though, because I think the's two different sounds (electronic and ragtime) were very complimentary, and it was a little more creative on their part.

true, no one else (or at least ive heard of) sounded anything like that, where Odd is a plain Beatles rip off

[rickmo]

i liked both, AFYCSO just did more for me at the time it came out. Pretty. Odd was ok, it was hardly something you can compare to bands doing that 'Beatles' sound.

[Christrings]

AFYCSO by a long way.

[zachff]

A Fever is (when it came out) and still is now one of my favorite "scene" albums. I listen to it once every few weeks.

[foisol]

I never got into Pretty. Odd. but that's cuz I listened to the singles and it didn't do it for me. Any songs on the album that I should give a spin before I even think about purchasing the album?

[WhoSaidThat?]

p.o

[BlinkMe18278]

I liked Pretty. Odd. alot more the AFYCSO. I loved the Beatlesness of it. Alot of the songs on Fever just bored me, although it had some gems.

lol i thought AFYCSO was far from boring...pretty odd was a lullaby compared to AFYCSO...thats just me tho

[Broden Terry]

I never got into Pretty. Odd. but that's cuz I listened to the singles and it didn't do it for me. Any songs on the album that I should give a spin before I even think about purchasing the album?

My personal favorites from Pretty. Odd would be Northern Downpour and She Had the World. Behind the Sea is another good one if you don't mind Ryan's vocals.

[AussieBoy]

lol i thought AFYCSO was far from boring...pretty odd was a lullaby compared to AFYCSO...thats just me tho

na not just you, i liked it as it relaxed me when i was seedy n hungover from a big night on the piss, definant lullaby stuff, while fever was what i listened to when sinkin the piss the night before


now i come to think of it, its Fevers fault, dont like it anymore, til next friday night

[spunkmastaflex]

their first album was completely different than their second. However, i prefer the first album more, much more energy

[B00sh]

Pretty.Odd.

[Ari Christos]

Fever. All the songs on Pretty. Odd. bleed together to me, and the lack of creativity leaves me bored. I hated Ryan Ross's lyrics on PO. I could tolerate them most times on Fever, though.

[Alexx Miller]

Pretty. Odd. Just cause I wasn't really a PATD fan to really begin with. I guess it just grabbed my attention more than AFYCSO did.

[PopPunkKid]

Although being catchy and having a few standout tracks, Fever is overall a mediocre, trendy, forgettable album.

Pretty.Odd. is a huge, vibrant, melodic, 60's influenced pop-rock album with a certain charm to it not heard in modern bands nowadays.

Hmm... I wonder which one I'd choose.

[PopPunkKid]

Yeah, Fall Out Boy writes shitty lyrics. Any 15-17 year old could write them.


Disagree x10.

[thespearkid]

Disagree x10.
clever =/= good.

[VIVALAMATT]

I hated hated hated Panic when they released A Fever You Can't Sweat Out. After Pretty.Odd, I actually got into them. Still can't stand that old stuff though.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Fever had a lot of catchy stuff. Couldn't really get into Pretty.

[f00te]

pretty. odd is pretty. shitty

[TSLROCKS]

P.o

[Indoor Living]

Fever, by an inch. I enjoy a lot of Pretty. Odd.

[xJesusFreakx]

Retro pop rock rip off > annoying scene pop rock.

Ryan > Brendan.