Trainwreck vs. What To Do When You Are Dead [Archive]

FinchBulldog2

03/02/06, 01:36 PM

Trainwreck. Pretty good album when it finally hits you. And the band actually plays interesting music.

DroppedUrPocket

03/02/06, 01:38 PM

I voted Trainwreck, by the way. This stemmed from me calling AFS dogpoo in my Myspace bulletin looking for tickets to their sold out show, and duffe messaged me back saying WTDWYAD>>>>>>Trainwreck.

duffe

03/02/06, 02:07 PM

WTDWYAD>>>>>>Trainwreck.
Ditto :)

DroppedUrPocket

03/02/06, 02:09 PM

Ditto :)
You are slick.

Stereo Mike

03/02/06, 02:10 PM

Bno.

duffe

03/02/06, 02:14 PM

You are slick.
:D

duffe

03/02/06, 02:16 PM

Bno.
http://yelims4.free.fr/Pasdaccord/NonNon04.gif

DroppedUrPocket

03/02/06, 02:16 PM

http://yelims4.free.fr/Pasdaccord/NonNon04.gif
That smiley is hilarious.

duffe

03/02/06, 02:18 PM

That smiley is hilarious.
http://yelims4.free.fr/Daccord/Accord07.gif

Stereo Mike

03/02/06, 02:51 PM

http://yelims4.free.fr/Pasdaccord/NonNon04.gif
haha, it certainly is hilarious.

Domenic182

03/02/06, 04:04 PM

I totally thought everyone was gonna go for WTDWYAD, and I voted Trainwreck, because that was one of my favorite summer albums, and I scroll down, to see everyone loving some BNO. Sweet.

a speedo model

03/02/06, 04:18 PM

Boys Night Out, hands fucking down.

DroppedUrPocket

03/02/06, 05:51 PM

mm bno

ALtheKILLER

03/02/06, 07:52 PM

Trainwreck by far
i liked AFS's first album better

Bobcat46308

03/02/06, 09:43 PM

all of the titles of the songs end in -ing

Pat Brown

03/03/06, 07:22 AM

all of the titles of the songs end in -ingyes...they are called gerunds. I voted for armor for sleep. I only like a few songs on bno's album: medicating and waking being the top 2. But the more you talk the less i hear beats any song on trainwreck.

golfchick

03/03/06, 09:48 AM

Boys Night Out, hands fucking down.

couldn't have said it any better.

duffe

03/03/06, 10:44 AM

Afs !!!

DroppedUrPocket

03/03/06, 10:45 AM

Afs !!!
:D

Boring Pop Song

03/03/06, 11:11 AM

trainwreck

duffe

03/03/06, 12:16 PM

Come on people, vote for What to Do When You're Dead. Please.

cahrishurr

03/03/06, 02:18 PM

i hate armor for sleep

generic as hell
boys night out..i like them, i have their albums..they are better than afs but still not amazing,

kazuma_ootaro28

03/04/06, 04:08 AM

I enjoyed about 4 songs off What To Do When You're Dead. I enjoyed about one song off Trainwreck. Both albums disappointed me for the most part.

duffe

03/04/06, 09:32 AM

unwritten

03/05/06, 08:03 PM

If this thread was made when BNO's album came out then they would have gotten my vote. Now? it is definitely AFS. Much more lasting power.

GoWaitInTheCar

03/05/06, 08:14 PM

I just watched an interview on, On Demand with Boys Night Out.

They seem like they dislike their first album, Make Yourself Sick, cause it was "immature."

Then they go on to say, a lot of BNO fans are pissed, cause they dislike the new album.

My personal opinion is clearly Trainwreck is better.

As for Armor For Sleep. Their new cd is so cookie cutter and whiny. It's sucks. The old one is way better. But Trainwreck beats it.

GoWaitInTheCar

03/05/06, 08:15 PM

i hate armor for sleep

generic as hell
boys night out..i like them, i have their albums..they are better than afs but still not amazing,

I couldn't agree more with what you just said.

domesticyeti

03/15/06, 06:02 PM

i love trainwreck. i thought some of the music was really interesting, especially with the addition of the keybaords.
i could never get into AFS. way to generic, songs about saying sorry and dropping flowers at your grave.
Boys Night Out, no contest

whiteboypain

03/17/06, 10:09 AM

AFS I like both AFS albums. The first BNO album is awesome. I thought trainwreck sounded awful. They changed so much.

a speedo model

03/17/06, 12:36 PM

couldn't have said it any better.

why thank you.

satanisanerd

03/20/06, 02:52 PM

I bought Trainwreck and I didn't like it AT ALL! I do like the Armor for Sleep album though.

imthenewcancer

03/21/06, 07:59 AM

not that armor for sleep isnt cool and all...but in no way is that album sonically better than trainwreck...

HeartLikeAGun27

03/23/06, 02:55 PM

Trainwreck hands down.

RandomHero1230

03/23/06, 04:31 PM

tough one...

I'm gonna go with Trainwreck

Co and Ca

03/26/06, 08:48 PM

Trainwreck...duh

Drew Beringer

03/26/06, 08:54 PM

Can't choose.

burn with power

03/26/06, 10:12 PM

armor for sleep, by far.

MotionIsntMeaning

03/31/06, 06:28 PM

bno......so great....

Criesofthepast7

03/31/06, 06:47 PM

boys night out, for sure.

imelliott

04/04/06, 02:28 PM

WTDWYD is at least 30 times better thatn Trainwreck. WTDWYD is more fine-tuned and w/ trainwreck i think there there is alot of loose ends and it doesn't sound as whole.

DroppedUrPocket

04/04/06, 02:31 PM

WTDWYD is at least 30 times better thatn Trainwreck. WTDWYD is more fine-tuned and w/ trainwreck i think there there is alot of loose ends and it doesn't sound as whole.
I think you're drunk.

ryheeles

04/04/06, 05:03 PM

Trainwreck. Boys Night Out is where it's at.

Emoknight

04/06/06, 12:40 PM

trainwreck

ishotthepilot

04/06/06, 03:56 PM

i probably like AFS as a band more, but trainwreck was no doubt better than wtdwyad.

atomicgarden134

04/10/06, 05:53 AM

what the hell kind of question is this shit? I listened to both cds. TRAINWRECK was the best cd of 2005. Armor for sleep, i stop listening to this shit when he said i dont care. And that was the first track. Then i heard their video, that sucked too. Saw them live, they were slightly alright. BNO>AFS

we are cured

04/10/06, 12:00 PM

this shouldn't even be a question. there is way more musicianship in boys night out.

idefyYoustars

04/11/06, 09:05 PM

boys night out
i enjoyed both cds, both good bands and all, both albums were produced by machine, but after listening to trainwreck, my reaction was wow. it was a cd i really got into, kind of like a movie. i think i might have even cried or something after listening to it. but yeah, i didnt get the same affect from wtdwyad

AreTwoKay

04/12/06, 08:17 PM

Afs

duffe

04/13/06, 02:55 AM

Looks like I win Sean :)

sometripe

04/14/06, 10:48 PM

Ehh, I find Armor For Sleep kind of boring. I can't get into it.

DroppedUrPocket

04/15/06, 12:51 AM

Looks like I win Sean :)
You be quiet duffe!

I still love you. And you spelled my name right. :)

dontgrabtindy

04/15/06, 06:45 AM

afs

duffe

04/15/06, 11:59 AM

You be quiet duffe!

I still love you. And you spelled my name right. :)
I know, i didn't remember this thread :(

Empty hearts187

04/20/06, 11:24 AM

BNO fucking owns.

mmmuffins

04/27/06, 03:22 PM

All of you who voted for AFS need to get your heads checked. Trainwreck was way better, and gets better everytime you listen to it.

crit

05/01/06, 10:52 AM

trainwreck.

love_american_style

06/05/06, 04:01 PM

i saw armor for sleep with boys night out together on tour and boys night out really suck live.

AgentX

06/11/06, 02:37 PM

wow i'm pretty suprised at the posts in this thread i htough everybody was into AFS bad.......

Ralph Wiggum

07/12/06, 06:10 PM

Armor For Sleep not because it's nesscessarily good, but i don't like Boys Night Out