PDA

View Full Version : an americanized government in post-war iraq


Mr. Chainsaw
03/26/03, 10:33 AM
my question is, are we really giving the people of iraq what they want? we all know that saddam is a terrible person and does not treat his people well, this has never been argued, however it comes down to the people's perception of him. as a student of business, when you try to introduce a product into a market that has never seen such a product, such as democracy and a free market economy, because you see it as a need, but do so with little market analysis, the product usually fails.

people in 3rd world countries who need protein often won't purchase protein substitutes, people who need water purifiers because their water is undrinkable often won't use them. why? because market penetration was not executed in a way that convinced these people that they needed these products, even though they were truly needs. so what makes us think that an americanized government and free market economy will be any different?

just a different take on things that i thought could bring about an interesting discussion on an americanized government in post-war iraq.

therealhebm
03/26/03, 11:01 AM
at first, yes it will be a rough transistion. but the people will see how much better democarcy is than their previous from of govt.

yeat182
03/26/03, 11:06 AM
Iraq isn't some backwater, third world country. Sanctions have created the perception that it is, because Saddam uses the oil for food money to buy weapons, or he buys food and then sells that food to other countries, and his people suffer. Iraq has electricity, running water, hospitals, schools, sattellite TV, almost all the same luxuries we have in the US. the difference is that their government won't let them enjoy these luxuries. Iraq was a democratic state before Saddam took control, it isn't like trying to introduce a western lifestlye to natives in the middle of the amazon.

bossydacow
03/27/03, 02:23 PM
still, i think it will be a rough transition. I don't know how I would react if something that was forbidden to me suddenly became unforbidden.

yeat182
03/27/03, 02:38 PM
it could be tough, but nothing worth doing is ever easy...