Stay What You Are or Your Favorite Weapon?

[jordalsh]

Which One?

Personally, I think that Stay What you Are is Miles better

[Ari Christos]

Your Favorite Weapon was the first one I listened to and got into, but Stay What You Are still gets played today. Gotta go with STD.

[Radiology]

Stay What You Are got me into music. It's an album that aged very well, where as Your Favorite Weapon is just nostalgic (Deja aged well for them on the other hand)

[kaoskid]

Your Favorite Weapon is my favorite album of all time.

[futilespider]

wow. these are both incredible. probably one of the more difficult polls. i went with your favorite weapon. but i was not confident in my choice. haha.

[SethGrandpa]

Hardest poll ever. They're equally amazing.

[Broden Terry]

Your Favorite Weapon. I think :shrug:

[Undue Noise]

Swya

[fadedmemories]

Stay What You Are by a universe. Your Favorite Weapon doesn't even compare.

[cburton92]

Stay What You Are

[Hull]

I love both, but Your Favorite Weapon was revolutionary to my mind.

[FullCollaspe]

haha wtf, Stay What You Are by a mile

[NewFoundAndrew]

Your Favourite Weapon

[Tim Lincecum]

finally someone made a poll that brand new can actually lose on here

[brandnewsheep]

I love YFW AND It's not just my Brand New bias kicking in.

[jjjkman]

some major spamming on the first page.
I'll have to go with YFW, it still makes me happy whenever it comes on

[phil19]

ive never been a saves the day fan
your favourite weapon all the way

[jordalsh]

whats with the spam?

[I'm DC]

Dead even!

[Heart-A-Tact]

SWYA destroys Your Favorite Weapon.

[jordalsh]

The Brand New lovers on this site are getting a little ridiculous.
I thought that maybe this would be one of few polls Brand New would lose.
SWYA

[muchoawesomeo]

i can't believe how close this is. i thought brand new would be destroying std. stay what you are.... no question about it!

[abandonship]

YFW easily. I can't stand Chris Conley's voice.

[fadedmemories]

How the fuck is SWYA losing? It's a near perfect album. YFW doesn't compare.

[Heart-A-Tact]

Not surprised to see YFW winning. Depressing.

[billyboatkid]

Yfw

EDIT: Fuck I thought it was first full lengths.

I should have voted for Stay What You Are. That blows Your Favorite weapon awaay. damn it.

[rickmo]

Say What You Are

[phoenixinflames]

SWYA destroys Your Favorite Weapon.

Yup...there's really no question. Bummer YFW is winning.

[BulleTheory]

im surprised this is even close with all the BN lovers

[ericsounds41]

Brand New for me.

[smorgy]

if this was through being cool i would have voted saves the day, and the whole poll would have probably been reversed

[Machu505]

Stay What You Are is actually a good album, so I go with it.

[sokonfused]

this is a hard one. but i'm going to have to go with sta what you are.

[nellbelle]

Stay What You Are. I've tried and tried to get into Your Favorite Weapon, but it just never connects for me. Saves The Day never fail to get me, though.

[fadedmemories]

Not surprised to see YFW winning. Depressing.
It's sad

[I am Mick]

The fact that Brand New is winning this poll is fucking PATHETIC. SWYA is MILES ahead of anything Brand New has ever done or ever will do.

But go ahead, AP, keep sucking off a bunch of thieves and Colour Revolt wannabes.

[tommy's ghost]

This is sad, pathetic, infuriating, and fucking loathsome.

[DejaNew]

Bn.

[Sic Transit Zeb]

I am a huge Brad New fan but NO NO NO way YFW is better than stay what you are. Stay what you are is miles better, instrumentally and lyrically.

[Sic Transit Zeb]

The fact that Brand New is winning this poll is fucking PATHETIC. SWYA is MILES ahead of anything Brand New has ever done or ever will do.

But go ahead, AP, keep sucking off a bunch of thieves and Colour Revolt wannabes.


While I'm pissed they are winning, they are not theives or CR wannabes. BNs albums Deja and TDAG are what make me think they are my fav band. YFW is good but nothing memorable. Nowhere near Stay What You Are.

[I am Mick]

While I'm pissed they are winning, they are not theives or CR wannabes. BNs albums Deja and TDAG are what make me think they are my fav band. YFW is good but nothing memorable. Nowhere near Stay What You Are.

They charged people a dollar for lyrics they've never sent out. I'm sure 500+ people send in a dollar to get these. This means the band stole 500+ dollars from their own fans.

[Sic Transit Zeb]

They charged people a dollar for lyrics they've never sent out. I'm sure 500+ people send in a dollar to get these. This means the band stole 500+ dollars from their own fans.

I sent a dollar and I don't care at all. I supported the band, or whatever it went to. It's just a dollar to me. I coudl careless.

[I am Mick]

I sent a dollar and I don't care at all. I supported the band, or whatever it went to. It's just a dollar to me. I coudl careless.

Yeah, it's just a dollar to you. But you gotta realize that shit adds up. I feel like if any other band stole 500 bucks, collectively, from their fans, there would be a huge shit show. But Brand New is held in higher regard then God around here, for reasons I cannot comprehend. I don't even hate the bands music. They have some decent songs. It's just a ridiculous.

[Sic Transit Zeb]

Yeah, it's just a dollar to you. But you gotta realize that shit adds up. I feel like if any other band stole 500 bucks, collectively, from their fans, there would be a huge shit show. But Brand New is held in higher regard then God around here, for reasons I cannot comprehend. I don't even hate the bands music. They have some decent songs. It's just a ridiculous.

No I understand how much they got from the whole but it really doesn't matter to me, honestly. I findi t deceiving, yes but I like the band for their music, not their lyric booklets.

ANd I agree, they are loved around here and Im one of them. I love all their albums and I especially love Deja and TDAG. However, STD should be winning this poll by a land slide.

[I am Mick]

Exactly. Your Favorite Weapon is a throw away pop-punk record at best. Only two songs are worth revisting. Stay What You Are is the epitome of a great pop record.

[jgord88]

Anything Brand New Will Always Win On Here And That's Bull Shit. Even Though I Do Enjoy Them, They Are Clearly Not The Best Band In The World.

[End of Disc One]

Anything Brand New Will Always Win On Here And That's Bull Shit. Even Though I Do Enjoy Them, They Are Clearly Not The Best Band In The World.

Exactly, but without all the caps. I always thought Brand New was pretty good, but when I started coming here I couldn't understand for the life of me why they were praised as the Second Coming. Doesn't make sense to me.

As for YFW, Soco Amaretto Lime is a great song, and most of the album is enjoyable but nothing special.

[stereokiller]

Stay What You Are by a universe. Your Favorite Weapon doesn't even compare.

SWYA is freakin' amazing. IMO, YFW isn't really that special.

[stereokiller]

Exactly. Your Favorite Weapon is a throw away pop-punk record at best. Only two songs are worth revisting. Stay What You Are is the epitome of a great pop record.

i am seriously thinking twice about the credibility of this poll.

SWYA is indeed a masterpiece.

[Lemmi!]

Yfw

[seraph1214]

There's no way that Your Favorite Weapon is a better record than Stay What You Are.

[mike'smannequin]

yfw

[Lightsout911X]

Your favorite weapon, because i still listen to it today.

[just.Starla.]

Your Favorite Weapon

[ReignofFiction]

Holy hell how is YFW winning this.

[owiseone35]

Holy shit you've got to be kidding me I thought Stay What You Are would be killing this. Stay What You Are is so much better then YFW. I really didn't think the BN obsession was that big with many people on this site but I guess it is. Stay What You Are is just so much better it's depressing looking at this poll. Freakish> Anything on YFW, and thats not even their best song on it.

[nashiscash1324]

wow tough poll. (thats what she said)

anyways i went with Your Favorite Weapon but i love them both