Which band has the stronger discography?

[MattDennis]

Vote! Discuss!

[JimmyIymmiJ]

Definitely Led Zeppelin. I've never been a Pink Floyd fan.

[rickmo]

Led Zeppelin far and away.

[briewer]

Meh. I'd call it pretty even. If I HAD to choose, I'd say Led Zeppelin.

[slImChanCe]

Floyd for me, Division Bell FTW!

[SD_John]

Definitely Led Zeppelin. I've never been a Pink Floyd fan.

Same here. Pink Floyd never caught me. Zep has a variety of songs and all different genres.

[MattDennis]

Meh. I'd call it pretty even. If I HAD to choose, I'd say Led Zeppelin.

Yeah I agree. It really comes down to the fact that Floyd had two albums I'm not so hot on while the only Zep release I don't like is In Through the Out Door. Out of both catalogues my favorite album is Dark Side for sure, but after that most of my preference goes to Zep.

[Hull]

Definitely Led Zeppelin. I've never been a Pink Floyd fan.
I'm the exact opposite.

[Undue Noise]

Led Zeppelin

[Theseventhson]

Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin is so overrated.

[cburton92]

Pink Floyd definatly

[Tim Lincecum]

Zep, Floyd has a lot of weird stuff

[BulleTheory]

this is way too damn hard to choose...2 of my favorite bands of all time

[MyWorldEntire]

Zeppelin

[VIVALAMATT]

I think Zeppelin IV is one of the best of all time, but I think Pink Floyd has more great albums than Led did.

[Goat01]

"Floyd is very cool."


I choose Floyd.

[derekmoyer4]

zeppelin has the stronger discography, but i am a little more partial to pink floyd.

so i had to vote for zeppelin.

[CarouselBoy]

By stronger discography I'm guessing you mean who had more "better/good" albums....which I'd say is Led Zeppelin. The first 4 of 5, and arguably the first 5 period were golden. To me, you can make the case for 3 of pink floyd's, maybe 4.

[jwicklun]

Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin is so overrated.
blasphemy

[IceAge/HeatWave]

Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin is so overrated.

john bonham died for your sins, this is how you repay him?


i have said and always will say that the three perfect bands are:

the beatles, radiohead, led zeppelin.

[Broden Terry]

Pink Floyd :nod:

[denissuxx]

Pf

[jawstheme]

Zeppelin for sure. I love Floyd but they are up against the best.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

Zeppelin for sure. I love Floyd but they are up against the best.

you usually do make very good sense.

[superichie]

led zep fo sho

[jawstheme]

john bonham died for your sins, this is how you repay him?


i have said and always will say that the three perfect bands are:

the beatles, radiohead, led zeppelin.

I say this all the time. Although if yours are in order mine are a little different: Led Zeppelin, The Beatles, Radiohead. I may only have Radiohead 3rd because I've seen them (religious experience!!!) and I only dream and cry myself to sleep over never being able to see The Beatles or Zep live, especially Led Zeppelin.

[muchoawesomeo]

floyd

[yrfacemyfist]

Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin is so overrated.
Waa?

[hiddenjem]

I could care less about either for the most part but Led Zep leads this category without question...if it werent for Led, a lot of the bands i listen to may not be the same...

[MattDennis]

I could care less about either for the most part but Led Zep leads this category without question...if it werent for Led, a lot of the bands i listen to may not be the same...

You could say the same thing about Pink Floyd if you listen to anything progressive.

[hiddenjem]

You could say the same thing about Pink Floyd if you listen to anything progressive.

good point...

[Un'Aria Ancora]

I say this all the time. Although if yours are in order mine are a little different: Led Zeppelin, The Beatles, Radiohead. I may only have Radiohead 3rd because I've seen them (religious experience!!!) and I only dream and cry myself to sleep over never being able to see The Beatles or Zep live, especially Led Zeppelin.

Radiohead, The Beatles, Floyd, Zepp (At least we have how the west was won.)
It's a close call, but come on:
Piper
Saucerful
Meddle
Dark Side
WYWH
The Wall
Animals
AHM

mmhmm