Which is the best '00's pop-punk breakthrough album?

[jtresk26]

Since I've been posting so many polls I thought this one would be a cool one to see what people think.

[Loge182]

I really like CttM more then any other Motion City Album, but Fall Out Boy amd Yellowcard are clsoe runners up.

[BulleTheory]

either Ocean Avenue or All Killer No Filler for me...the rest are just meh.

[jjjkman]

I loved From Under the Cork Tree, almost as much as Take This to Your Grave, but Cartel and Yellowcard are pretty close for me.

[JimmyIymmiJ]

I wasn't paying attention and voted for TBS because I thought it was Tell All Your Friends. BUT, after actually using my reading skills I would go with NFG.

[Neo Cassady]

I voted FOB because I didn't read it and figured it'd be TTTYG. But I would have voted Sticks and Stones.

[cowlord]

Sticks and Stones

[ArtForLovers]

Fall Out Boy. Their only great album

[derekmoyer4]

ocean avenue, thank you.

[Everiggs]

Chroma had the biggest impact for me.

[darkmartheight]

For me, Sticks and Stones. From under the cork tree is second.

[seraph1214]

Some great choices on here, but my choice is Ocean Avenue.

[kazuma_ootaro28]

Would Saves the Day's Stay What You Are be considered a "breakthrough" album?

[Broden Terry]

For me personally, it's Chroma.

[VIVALAMATT]

Definitely Sum 41. When "Fat Lip" hit MTV, they fucking exploded. Love that album.

[phil19]

favourite album on that list is sticks and stones so i went with that

[nlo13]

Take Off your Pants and Jacket.

[charmer]

i know a lot of people wont agree but i chose panic. they opened up a whole new style of pop punk. their debut album was huge when it first hit.

[Theseventhson]

WYWTB is the only album I like here.

[SendALetter]

Cartel is my favorite...but i would say the best/biggest was All Killer No Filler.

[jtresk26]

Take Off your Pants and Jacket.
Dude, that is definitely not their breakthrough album. Enema of the State is and there is no arguing that.

[nlo13]

Dude, that is definitely not their breakthrough album. Enema of the State is and there is no arguing that.

kidding.

[jtresk26]

kidding.
Okay good haha, you had me going for a second there.

[mike'smannequin]

cttm

[batmannj]

Of the choices, Sticks and Stones

[starynightsky]

dang, that was a hard poll.

[gabrielM]

there was 5 here that i really really liked. tough decision.

[MyFriendPeter]

sticks and stones, wywtb at a close second.

[SeanEBoy2686]

Ocean Avenue... with Sticks & Stones following

[Heart-A-Tact]

Commit This To Memory is one of my all time favorite albums.

[gr33ndayfr3ak]

For me, Sticks and Stones. From under the cork tree is second.

This.
Two of my favorite albums of all-time.

[MSIndulgence]

no valencia / blink? and there's pink spiders on here.. that album did nothing for me at all

[fadedmemories]

FUCT all the way, Chroma and Sticks and Stones in a tie for second.

I don't really think that SWIR and CTTM could be considered as "Breakthrough" albums.

[Indoor Living]

Fall Out Boy. Their only great album
So wrong.

Commit This To Memory is one of my favorite cd's of all time, and i voted on my favorite, but I agree it's not much of a breakthrough.

[End of Disc One]

By "breakthrough album" do you mean the album that first made them popular? I'd say New Found Glory's self titled album made them more popular than Motion City Soundtrack, Cartel, All Time Low, and The Pink Spiders.

[superichie]

either Ocean Avenue or All Killer No Filler for me...the rest are just meh.

NFG Sticks & Stones blows both of those records out of the water.

[Toothache]

good, nfg better be winning

[domotime2]

My faves
- sticks and stones
- all killer
- commit to memory


im trying to think which of these was the most important...or which made the biggest impact......
FUCT, All Killer, Ocean Avenue, Sticks and Stones...all had such equal impacts to the pop-punk scene. All Killer I think really paved the way for Ocean Avenue....but the blow up of FUCT sparked a NEW sorta scene, and took fall out boy to such incredible heights that it allowed such crappy bands like cartel/all time low to grow as well as years progressed.

id have to saw FUCT in that category....but i still just went with my favorite, and best album imo.

[Piss]

Would Saves the Day's Stay What You Are be considered a "breakthrough" album?

nope, they never made it big

[SuchAPerson22]

A Fever You Can't Sweat Out, because that's the album that brought me into this scene.

[blinkme]

Commit This to Memory rules my world.

[Protested Hero]

This poll is kinda, eh.

Anyway I would've picked Saves the Day.

[Protested Hero]

nope, they never made it big

Yes they did. They were being played on MTV.

[spunkmastaflex]

a lot of those are really good, but i think sum 41 got a lot of people into this genre

[Metal Now]

From Under the Cork Tree completely changed my life when it dropped, so I'll have to go for that.

[cory-182]

Ocean Avenue, Take This to Your Grave and Chroma are all in my Top 20 albums.

I wouldn't call TBS, The Pink Spiders or Panic! pop punk, but to each their own.

[suppyguppy]

nope, they never made it big

They definitely made it as big as at least half of these bands while maintaining more credibility than most as well.

[Simonthm]

startng line - say it like you mean it

[Indoor Living]

Ocean Avenue, Take This to Your Grave and Chroma are all in my Top 20 albums.

I wouldn't call TBS, The Pink Spiders or Panic! pop punk, but to each their own.
I wouldn't call the Pink Spiders anything.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Sticks and Stones

[leifstar]

Sad to say I just started to get into Chroma.

[dylanluthier]

i went with FOB cause idk...it was a great album when it came out and the others you listed had to grow on me really... if you would have put TBS's TAYF, then i prob would've voted for that...or brand new's yfw.

[dylanluthier]

startng line - say it like you mean it

another valid album that's missing

[tcemoo]

Shit, I voted for Commit This to Memory because I figured the ... was "I Am the Movie". Take it back, plz.

[allisterkid]

What a shitty list of choices. There were way better breakthrough albums than all of these in the early 00's.

[Paulb-182]

Tough call but I went with FUCT

[nerdvglc]

fuct, but it was pretty close. fun poll.

[1mastalker]

I voted FOB because I didn't read it and figured it'd be TTTYG. But I would have voted Sticks and Stones.
Me too.

/sigh

[SandManTEND13]

I am a bigger fan of From Under The Cork Tree

[SLoT]

FOB easily.

[songydarko]

NFG by far. Sticks and Stones is still one of my favorite albums ever.

[Brandao]

this was really hard to decide....but went with Ocean Avenue

[Croggs]

Would Saves the Day's Stay What You Are be considered a "breakthrough" album?

It'd be considered freakin' awesome.

[stereokiller]

A tie between Chroma and Commit This.

voted for Chroma because I predicted it would get the lower count. and was right.

[kcpunk]

All Killer No Filler for sure.