Best Motion City Soundtrack record?

[jtresk26]

I have been listening to their records recently and I have hard time choosing which one is better, but I wonder if people have the same tough decision that I had. For me, it was so hard to pick the best record because I love the last two records so much, but I ultimately had to go with Even If It Kills Me because that album resonates with me the most.

[Feenucks]

Commit This to Memory, followed closely by I Am the Movie. I haven't listened to much of Even If It Kills Me, but from what I've heard, it just sounds like b-sides from CTTM...

[Loge182]

Memory. Easily.

[TangledUp]

I love all three of those albums, but I picked Commit This To Memory, it's always been my favorite.

[VIVALAMATT]

even if it kills me

[Piss]

hmm i thought I Am The Movie would be leading

[jtresk26]

hmm i thought I Am The Movie would be leading
I thought differently. I thought CTtM would be leading, which it happens to be.

[tttygxlove]

Commit This to Memory.

[unwritten_law9]

hmm i thought I Am The Movie would be leading

I think I Am The Movie is the best, and I thought the majority of people agreed with me. Guess not. All 3 albums are solid though. Plus Motion City Soundtrack is fun to see live. Out of the 6 times I have seen them they have not put on a bad show.

[seraph1214]

I love all their records, but I Am the Movie is my shit.

[darkmartheight]

Commit this to memory>I am the Movie>Even if it Kills Me

[nerdvglc]

cttm>iatm>eiikm

[FullCollaspe]

cttm

[PengusNiugnep]

I went with Commit This To Memory, but Even If It Kills Me was really close.

[ilovesofie]

It's weird but when I first listened to "Even If It Kills" I thought it was their worst but it seems that that CD has the most staying power so I go for their last.

[MusicScoutJustn]

I Am the Movie was my favorite. It defined what I thought Motion City should sound like. Then CTTM came along, and although I liked it, it lacked the same fun synth sound that the first album brought.

Sadly, I wasn't impressed by Even If it Kills Me at all... It now lays in shame somewhere on my computer hard drive instead of on my iPod.

I heard the new album is going to trace back to some of the older stuff though, so I'm excited for that one at least :D

[Broden Terry]

I had to vote Commit This to Memory.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Definitely Memory for me

[Heart-A-Tact]

Commit This To Memory, easily.

[MADSTA]

And for the 23872936th time, CTTM.

[Indoor Living]

Commit This To Memory, but I love all three of their releases so much. Favorite band right here.

[muttley]

I Am The Movie. No question.
I love just about everything that this band does, and all of the albums are favorites of mine, but IATM will always be at the top of my list.

[Croggs]

cttm>iatm>eiikm

This for me.

[pr0digy]

commit this to memory and i am the movie are just about a dead tie for me. but with how fun "the future freaks me out" live is, i went with iatm

[GamEin]

I Am the Movie

[mike'smannequin]

cttm by far

[fueledbyvictory]

I've only really listened to I Am The Movie and Even If It Kills Me, but they're good.

[TangledUp]

I was just listening to part of Even if It Kills Me today, and that is an awesome album.

[Wait_For_It]

Commit This To Memory.

[optimusrob]

commit this to memory is probably my favorite record of all time.

[ManicanParty49]

I love them all for different reasons. As a whole I think Even If It Kills me is their strongest, so I chose that.

[frenchatticus]

commit this to memory no doubt, but the other two have their own highlights.

[BigAl]

CTTM was my summer album of '05, and that was a great summer.

[yellowhouse]

I Am The Movie, for sure.

[more heart]

Commit This To Memory for sure on this one.

[Brandao]

Even If It Kills me... don't know why though.....just love that album

[Ryzenfall]

Commit This Response To Memory via Expected Repetition.

[coolwithme19]

i am shocked i am the movie isnt owning this.

[stereokiller]

hmm i thought I Am The Movie would be leading

i thought so too.

i voted for Memory.

Attractive Today is a reaally good opener and Hold Me Down an amazing closer.