Goth Rockers

[Shin Akuma]

who's ur fav.goth rocker from the list? discuss

[brandnewsheep]

I wouldn't call him "Goth Rocker" but Skiba all the way.


EDIT: At least, not in the same sense as Gerard Way and Ville Valo.

[Shin Akuma]

I wouldn't call him "Goth Rocker" but Skiba all the way.


EDIT: At least, not in the same sense as Gerard Way and Ville Valo.

but .... they all have one thing in common .. EYELINER .... :p

[jjjkman]

To be honest, I feel that Skiba is the only respectable person on that list, and I wouldn't really consider him a "Goth Rocker". And I despise Ville Valo. And H.I.M. in general.

[Shin Akuma]

come on guys u know what i meant with the term "goth rockers" .. they all have the same dark melancholic feeling in their music and lyrics .. Him have more metal/alternative rock influences .. MCR sound is closer to pop-punk .. AFI roots is hardcore .. Alk3 is more straight punk rock sound .. so.. if you are more into punk rock then its obvious to choose Skiba .. A metalhead or a pop-punk teenager will not think the same with you ..

[superichie]

Davey Havok FTW!

[doppelganger]

skiba of course

[Neo Cassady]

:wallbash:

Ignoring the stupid, incorrect label, Skiba is by far the best of those.

[jtresk26]

To me, Gerard Way is like a gothic Freddie Mercury. Singing wise.

[andrew_upto11]

Any of them but Ville Valo. H.I.M. sucks.

[futilespider]

i like davey and skiba a lot, but i like more mcr songs than afi or alkaline songs. so i went gerard

[Shin Akuma]

Any of them but Ville Valo. H.I.M. sucks.

too much hate on Ville Valo hehe

[VIVALAMATT]

Of these, Gerard Way has the best voice. Then Davey, then Ville.

[Shin Akuma]

Of these, Gerard Way has the best voice. Then Davey, then Ville.

really? Gerard cant sing live to save his life ..

[kazuma_ootaro28]

Not as regarding to that list, but what about Ian Curtis or Robert Smith?

[VIVALAMATT]

really? Gerard cant sing live to save his life ..

Old, drunk-ass Gerard can't. I saw them in 2008 and his voice was cleeeaaaannnnnn

[Shin Akuma]

Old, drunk-ass Gerard can't. I saw them in 2008 and his voice was cleeeaaaannnnnn


ermmm .. lip sync maybe?? hehe okay miracles happen ...

[Croggs]

Skiba is da man, but gothic is debatable.

[VIVALAMATT]

ermmm .. lip sync maybe?? hehe okay miracles happen ...

definitely not lip syncing. but a miracle on earth? quite possibly yes.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

out of these, g. way.

[phil19]

skiba is the man, not sure how goth he is though

[Shin Akuma]

oh my goodness .... Davey Havoc is losing ...!!! in my mind was like the most respectable person in this list ... havoc > skiba > valo > way

[darkmartheight]

Matt Skiba. and not because Alkaline Trio is my favorite band, but because he's a cool guy. not the most gothic though.

[Brandao]

I wouldn't call him "Goth Rocker" but Skiba all the way.


EDIT: At least, not in the same sense as Gerard Way and Ville Valo.

that's what i was thinking.

[Radiology]

the king of goth rock

Robert Smith

[Theseventhson]

Fuck H.I.M., I don't like AFI, and Gerard Way is a poor excuse of a singer/lyricist (he holds that band back so much IMO). So that leaves Skiba.

[Theseventhson]

Old, drunk-ass Gerard can't. I saw them in 2008 and his voice was cleeeaaaannnnnn
I saw them in 2007 and he just stood there, sounded like shit and complained about the heat.

[Shin Akuma]

I saw them in 2007 and he just stood there, sounded like shit and complained about the heat.


hahahaha i knew it!!! somethings never change!!!!

[Indoor Living]

Gerard Way.

[princesschad]

lol

[anthonydarko]

Lol at this thread.

[AussieBoy]

Havok just piping Valo

[jjjkman]

To me, Gerard Way is like a gothic Freddie Mercury. Singing wise.

No offense, but I don't see that..at all.

[Ari Christos]

I loved Three Cheers for Sweet Revenge once upon a time.

[newfoundmichael]

Fuck H.I.M., I don't like AFI, and Gerard Way is a poor excuse of a singer/lyricist (he holds that band back so much IMO). So that leaves Skiba.

When I saw MCR Gerard had an amazing stage presence. It was a damn good live show and I'm not even that big of a fan.

[riseagainstfan]

"cause Matt Skiba said she was the cooler one"

Skiba FTW never considered him goth though just awesome

[sinmarian]

Davey!! <3

[PopPunkKid]

Gerard is just the fucking man. I think he's an amazing singer, and a great artist as well. He's definetly one of the best frontmen of this past decade imo. It's nice to see him getting some love on here.

Ville Valo is possibly one of the most boring singers of all time... go see H.I.M. live and enjoy watching him stand in one spot the whole time and smoke cigarettes while singing.

Davey and Matt are cool as well, but Gerard is definetly the winner in my book.

[himynameisbrett]

Gerard, shortly followed by Skiba. Gerard's got the pipes and Skiba's got the lyrics. Davey isn't horrible but he's lost his touch live. Ville Valo is just bad though. Dude just sings really low and writes pitiful lyrics.

[Poe-tryGirl]

I wouldn't consider Gerard Way a goth, but he is the cutest guy alive in my book.

[seraph1214]

Havok > Skiba >>>>> Way >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Valo

[zachff]

Havok personally, then Skiba, then Way