Star Wars or The Lord Of The Rings

[kaoskid]

We all know Kevin Smith's stance on this debate, but what do you think?

[thehereaway]

Tough, but i went for Lord of the Rings. The music alone gives me chills.

[Theseventhson]

Star Wars just because of the nostalgia.

[Loge182]

Duh Duhhh Duhnuh na na Naaa! Na Na NaNaa naaa! Duh na nanaaa

[fightinirish217]

Both great, went with Star Wars, just cause...its Star Wars.

[BulleTheory]

never could really get into LOTR

[phil19]

star wars pisses all over lord of the rings

[briewer]

Sorry childhood, I went with Lord of the Rings.

[jtresk26]

I just couldn't get into Lord of the Rings. I know it is a great trilogy, but Star Wars is for me.

[Five-Star]

Lotr

[doppelganger]

more of a star wars guy.

[Piss]

more of a lord of the rings guy

[DropDeadSharkey]

LOTR is amazing but come on.. its Star Wars.

[Indoor Living]

Not a fan of either, but I had this Chewie stuffed animal when I was a kid, and I loved the shit out of that thing.

[thehereaway]

I had a friend who refused to watch both Lord of the Rings and Star Wars because he thought the plots sounded lame...

[princesschad]

Why not just combine the two?!

lv4Potdpjhw

[batmannj]

LOTR by far.

[AussieBoy]

i hate Star Wars, have nodded off in the 4 of them ive seen at points

[Burn_Burn_Burn]

Star Wars.
Just felt like declaring myself.

[ManicanParty49]

Star Wars.

LOTR is awesome, but I feel the movies are way too slow moving for their length at times, and I can't stay focused.

[Kaku]

I went with Star Wars. Never really got into LotR, though the movies are still nice to watch.

[vivian_vitality]

Lord Of The Rings by far. I never really got into Star Wars.

[VIVALAMATT]

I just don't see how people can pick lotr over star wars and all its glory.

[cburton92]

Star Wars

[Tim Lincecum]

not really a fan of either, i mean i found them to be okay, cool in some ways, boring in other ways... but everyone i know seems to love both so what do i know?

[NateFoundGlory]

Me and my friends have argued about this for ages...that and cats vs. dogs (me- cats).

I personally hate Star Wars. Love me some LOTR.

[notoaststereo]

star wars

[SanePsychotic]

It's really a toss up for me. I'm leaning more towards Star Wars though since I want to throttle Frodo most of the time.

[Poultrylicious]

LotR has the better movie
But Star Wars has had such a cultural impact
If i could have one it would be Star Wars

[cuzimlefthanded]

i love the original starwars trilogy, but the prequels seriously killed the whole thing for me.

that said, lord of the rings for me. epic battles, epic cast, epic music, epic cinematography=win

[smorgy]

star wars, i cant stand lotr

[Heart-A-Tact]

Star Wars, no contest. That's not to say I don't love most things LOTR, though.

[Ryzenfall]

LOTR. The worlds only Trilogy.

[Thesleepingwell]

Probably Star Wars... I grew up with it.
And the books are awesome too.

But Lord Of The Rings was cool too.
Only that the films for LOTR were far too long for my attention span.
The novels are better,

[Broden Terry]

Lord Of the Rings. I like Star Wars but I've never been a really big fan.

[ApricotChick]

Star Wars. I mean, duh.

[lesto17]

Star Wars, no question.

[Shin Akuma]

Harry Potter :P

[SuchAPerson22]

Staaaaar Waaaaaaaars!
I wanted to be a Jedi every year for Halloween for years but my mom would never let me. :(
I'm doing it this year! :-p

Edit: 500 WHOO!

[crit]

Star Wars, always.

[thehereaway]

Staaaaar Waaaaaaaars!
I wanted to be a Jedi every year for Halloween for years but my mom would never let me. :(
I'm doing it this year! :-p

Edit: 500 WHOO!

I never went trick or treating as a child, am i missing out?

[Forever.Zero]

I have to bias my vote for Star Wars seeing as how I haven't watched the LOTR trilogy fully.
But even then I preffered Star Wars

[SuchAPerson22]

I never went trick or treating as a child, am i missing out?
Yes.
Yes, you poor, poor child. (Okay well you're not really a child...)
Free candy? How could you not be missing out! haha :)

[thehereaway]

Yes.
Yes, you poor, poor child. (Okay well you're not really a child...)
Free candy? How could you not be missing out! haha :)

I suppose its a bit late now, If i went and knocked on an old ladies' door covered in fake blood she would probably call the police.

[SuchAPerson22]

I suppose its a bit late now, If i went and knocked on an old ladies' door covered in fake blood she would probably call the police.
Hahaha that is very possible... Maybe if you dressed up like a... Princess or something... She wouldn't be as tempted to call the police. :D
Or you know, you could always steal little kids' candy while they aren't looking... :whistle: haha

[ericsounds41]

Star Wars for me.

[seraph1214]

Star Wars.

"There's only one Return, and it ain't of the King, it's of the Jedi." - Randal Graves

[Undue Noise]

I'm way more into LOTR than Star Wars.

[setthestage]

FUCK LOTR. i got into a fist fight with my friend over this. i will back star wars until the day i die!

[phil19]

so happy star wars is winning!

[oncedarkness]

LOTR. I just don't get the appeal of Star Wars....me and no one else.

[kdefrisc]

Star Wars by miles, but only the old ones. I fell asleep in all three LOTR movies.

[XchrisX]

Star Wars

[kaycey]

however old and classic star wars maybe LOTR still has it all.

[MyHereAfter]

There is only one "return" and it is of the Jedi

[MyHereAfter]

Star Wars.

"There's only one Return, and it ain't of the King, it's of the Jedi." - Randal Graves

Damnit I didn't see that you beat me to it

[Miss Heartcore]

Thread needs more DeadKidSean.

Both are classics but LOTR rules my life.

[lftcoastenvy05]

i can at least stay awake through an entire star wars movie, i cant make it through more than 15 minutes of a LOTR film

[GamabuntaSS]

Gandalf would totally kick Darth Vader's butt!

[antron]

i had to go with star wars, just because lord of the rings are just so long

[seraph1214]

Gandalf would totally kick Darth Vader's butt!

False.

[tiannaj23]

LOTR, no doubt.

[tiannaj23]

False.

Haha, that is false that you said false...
Erm...that sounds odd.

I disagree with you and I agree with the other person!
Haha, wow...I hope that makes sense...

[seraph1214]

Haha, that is false that you said false...
Erm...that sounds odd.

I disagree with you and I agree with the other person!
Haha, wow...I hope that makes sense...

Haha yeah I got it. Guess we'll agree to disagree.

[GamabuntaSS]

Haha yeah I got it. Guess we'll agree to disagree.

I concur.

[muzicislife31]

Ahhh I can't choose!

[IceAge/HeatWave]

lord of the rings. by a mile.


lord of the rings.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

Gandalf would totally kick Darth Vader's butt!

and yoda's.

[darkmartheight]

all of the LOTR's is too long for me. I fall asleep after ~2.5 hrs straight of watching anything. good movies, but overly long.

[rckstr29]

I had a friend who refused to watch both Lord of the Rings and Star Wars because he thought the plots sounded lame...

You need to strap that kid down and make him respect.

[billyboatkid]

Star Wars.

LOTR is alright, just not my style. I like blowing shit up.

[billyboatkid]

Lord of the G-Strings is better.

[tiannaj23]

HAHA, all these people saying they fell asleep during LOTR because they are too long!!!
I stayed up all day and night watching them ALL.

(obviously with breaks)

But nevertheless, it was amazzzzzzzing.

[arson]

Star Wars all the way.