PDA

View Full Version : Poison The Well - The Tropic Rot


Drew Beringer
08/04/09, 01:11 AM
Poison The Well – The Tropic Rot
Release Date: July 7, 2009
Record Label: Ferret

After a revival of sorts from their 2007 album, Versions, Poison The Well looks to expand on their new approach with their second Ferret Music album, The Tropic Rot. While the post-hardcore staples’ influence on the scene seem to get swept under the rug, that hasn’t stopped the band from releasing unforgiving music that continually progresses. The core three of the band remains – guitarist Ryan Primack, drummer Chris Hornbrook, and vocalist Jeffrey Moreira – and with the addition of bassist Bradley Grace and guitarist Brad Clifford, Poison The Well has set out to release their most ambitious record yet.

The vibe of The Tropic Rot is very similar to recent Thrice releases, such as The Alchemy Index. The parallels of the two bands are very close, as each band has tried the major label thing as well as continually trying to push the boundaries of their music. If you are a fan of Thrice’s newer stuff, yet have never listened to Poison The Well, this may be the album that gets you hooked. The Tropic Rot actually begins similar to Versions, as opening track, “Exist Underground” pummels itself through your membrane. Moreira’s transition between clean vocals and gruff yells is very smooth, while Hornbrook paces the track.

Over the years, PTW has dropped the breakdown all together from its repertoire; exchanging it for guitar leads that just barrel you over, as apparent in “Sparks It Will Rain.” Such an approach brings out a cohesiveness that was never heard on previous albums. Tracks like “Cinema” and “Makeshift Clay You” will ignite the pit, while “Who Doesn’t Love A Good Dismemberment” is one of the album highlights, transitioning from straight-forwardness right into chaos.

The Tropic Rot gets a little earthy with “When You Lose I Lose As Well,” a twangy foot-tapper that showcases Moreira’s clean vocals. The eerie “Without You And One Other I Am Nothing” closes the album with another fine melodic-chaotic effort, although the album relies a little too heavily on that formula.

The Tropic Rot focuses a lot on melodic side; specifically Moreira’s clean vocals. Moreira does a fine job, but recurring melodies drag it down a bit. And while the lyrical content isn’t as good as albums past, it’s still nothing to scoff at. Instead, Poison The Well continue to release relevant albums by never staying stagnant for long, as PTW continue to flex their creative muscles with The Tropic Rot.

Track Listing:
1. Exist Underground
2. Sparks It Will Rain
3. Cinema
4. Pamplemousse
5. Who Doesn’t Love A Good Dismemberment?
6. Antarctica Inside Me
7. When You Lose I Lose As Well
8. Celebrate The Pyre
9. Are You Anywhere
10. Makeshift Clay You
11. Without You and One Other I Am Nothing
Produced by: Steve Evetts

Poison The Well is:
Jeff Moreira – vocals
Ryan Primack – guitar
Chris Hornbrook – drums
Bradley Grace – bass
Brad Clifford – guitar

Official Myspace (http://www.myspace.com/poisonthewell); Official AP.net Profile (http://www.absolutepunk.net/artists/showlink.php?l=3970)

Brandon_WalshDK
08/04/09, 02:05 AM
Great review. Love the comparison between Thrice and PTW... sooooo true!

Chris Fallon
08/04/09, 02:42 AM
Really dig this album -- very true about the Thrice comparison. One of their better releases. Good work.

Chemical Love
08/04/09, 04:29 AM
Really good review. Going to see them Sunday on 10x10, cant wait.

cereal4life
08/04/09, 04:37 AM
I really like Thrice and I've intended to check PTW out for a long time so this review has certainly tipped the balance to making me get this album! Nice review, Drew.

I wish you did RIYLs, Drew. You are an anti-RIYL-ite, aren't you? DO IT.

EndSerenading
08/04/09, 04:50 AM
as usual, great review.

bolgy99
08/04/09, 04:51 AM
I think the Thrice comparison works well, they have both grown and matured alongside, though PTW is the angsty brother. This album is a real step forwards, thoroughly enjoying it.

I really like Thrice and I've intended to check PTW out for a long time so this review has certainly tipped the balance to making me get this album! Nice review, Drew.

I wish you did RIYLs, Drew. You are an anti-RIYL-ite, aren't you? DO IT.

I also like RIYLs, I find it a good measure of whether or not I will like the band, alongside the review, of course. Sometimes sounds are just too hard to explain. For a review of a seasoned band such as PTW, though, it isn't really necessary.

berskyjr
08/04/09, 11:10 AM
Although I like Versions better than TTR at the moment, I know I will love it just as much as versions.

bard
08/04/09, 11:14 AM
How similar is it to You Come Before You?

Brett3
08/04/09, 11:16 AM
Good review. Really like this album.

MyHereAfter
08/04/09, 11:19 AM
How similar is it to You Come Before You?
The Chorus' on this album are very similar to that album in my opinion.

CellarGhosts
08/04/09, 11:21 AM
Good review, Drew. Love this album.

MattDennis
08/04/09, 11:23 AM
Love newer Thrice, not a huge fan of this release.

THE_SICKEST
08/04/09, 11:32 AM
I love this record sooo much. It's such a progression for hardcore and I love to see bands push the mostly stale genre. And like everyone's been saying there is definitely a good comparison in Thrice with this band.

This could be my favorite release so far this year... Maybe my favorite PTW record.

Good to finally see a staff review of this as well. Or maybe I missed one?

Simulcast
08/04/09, 11:40 AM
Nice review, but how does this score the same as TDWP?

Also, I have yet to read a review that mention "Are You Anywhere?" That track is killer.

ctmk
08/04/09, 11:40 AM
wondering when there was going to be a review for this sweet album

andthetruthwill
08/04/09, 12:15 PM
I want to hear this. Haven't had the money to buy it yet, but this review has peaked my interest into committing to get it. That plus Steve Evetts producing. Anything he does now seems to be notable and very enjoyable.

Rob Hrx
08/04/09, 12:18 PM
Mmm... Versions grew on me slowly, this sounded pretty awesome just from the stream. Looking forward to a decent copy through some headphones...

airik625
08/04/09, 12:41 PM
I think I liked Versions better, but this is still pretty good.

Poochemist
08/04/09, 01:18 PM
Still haven't gotten into this album yet, despite having it for about a month now.

youngmountain
08/04/09, 02:03 PM
I really need to pick this up, probably pick it up with new 'thrice' and 'noah and the whale'

zubinmoosa
08/04/09, 02:50 PM
Good review Drew. You've really been churning them out in the last couple of months :-d

defmytones
08/04/09, 03:50 PM
"are you anywhere?" is probably one of the best songs PTW has ever written. This album is solid, but "Antarctica Inside Me" makes me cringe when I hear Jeffery scream "Constantly, on TIPPY TOES!" :-|

RyanFTW
08/04/09, 03:59 PM
All I can imagine when "Cinema" kicks in is just a circle pit immediately forming at any place in time. You could start a circle pit in a convent with this song.

dantar
08/04/09, 04:28 PM
glad i'm not the only one who recognizes the thrice similarities.
i love the shit out of this album.

InaGreendase
08/04/09, 05:14 PM
I kinda thought this was a regressive retread (http://www.punknews.org/review/8510) of Versions, but it's still pretty cool.

PomonaForEmpusa
08/04/09, 06:01 PM
PTW sounds nothing like newer Thrice in my opinion. sure i can see the comparison between the two on how each band has toyed with and expanded on their sound with every release but musically as of right now they sound nothing a like.

Thrice it seems has been progressively moving further and further away from their hardcore roots while PTW has been still holding firmly onto them, just taking those roots and tweaking/stretching them to see what they can do with them.

don't get me wrong, i love both bands.. just don't see the comparison between Tropic Rot and the Alchemy Index.

PlanetDahmz
08/04/09, 06:52 PM
I do really enjoy this album, my favorite is Sparks It Will Rain.

I also see the Thrice similarities, but like the previous poster said, PTW maintains the heavier sound while still being "experimental" like Thrice.

mymusicismylife
08/04/09, 06:56 PM
For fans of new Thrice? I'll definitely check it out.

cereal4life
08/04/09, 08:38 PM
I want to hear this. Haven't had the money to buy it yet, but this review has peaked my interest into committing to get it. That plus Steve Evetts producing. Anything he does now seems to be notable and very enjoyable.
*Piqued. I only learned that yesterday! Just thought I'd help out a fellow human-being.

shoop
08/04/09, 09:00 PM
lovvvin this album, great band to catch live too!!

kittypants
08/04/09, 09:03 PM
Great album. Like it tons more than Versions.

Alex DiVincenzo
08/04/09, 09:49 PM
Nice review. I couldn't get into Versions, but I'm digging this one. It's almost like it should have been released between You Come Before You and Versions as a transition between the two.

drewz5
08/05/09, 02:10 AM
Gonna have to check this out now

Dymytry Vance
08/06/09, 02:10 PM
Sparks It Wil Rain gets boring, and because that's the only song I've heard from this album... I don't think I'll be buying.

AntiCult
08/06/09, 03:06 PM
Sparks It Wil Rain gets boring, and because that's the only song I've heard from this album... I don't think I'll be buying.
your missing out. that song is beast so idk what your talking about.

Dymytry Vance
08/06/09, 07:16 PM
your missing out. that song is beast so idk what your talking about.
I like the ambience, but it's just one of those songs that's so close to being great that it ultimately turns out bad.

AntiCult
08/07/09, 04:55 PM
I like the ambience, but it's just one of those songs that's so close to being great that it ultimately turns out bad.

you shouldnt write this off because you don't like one song. so much pro stuff here.

Dymytry Vance
08/07/09, 05:02 PM
you shouldnt write this off because you don't like one song. so much pro stuff here.
Well after hearing that it's one of the best songs on here, I find it hard to want to spend 12 dollars for three songs or so... but I'll check youtube before I completely write it off.