Should Andrew McMahon go back to S.C.?

[Colin1755]

i like both bands, just wanted an opinion becasue i think they are both equally good. Tell Me Why
Yes
No

[BulleTheory]

yessssssssssss, enough of jack's

[Crowe41]

I loved Leaving Through the Window, North not so much. I think musically he has matured further with Jack's Mannequin and I like the direction he's taking it so I'd have to say no. Well if he could do them both then yes.

[TangledUp]

I loved Leaving Through the Window, North not so much. I think musically he has matured further with Jack's Mannequin and I like the direction he's taking it so I'd have to say no. Well if he could do them both then yes.
I love your avatar hahaha

[MADSTA]

As long as he keeps making music, I'll be happy.

[domotime2]

i dont understand andrew mcmahon. He basically IS jack's mannequin...and yet now he's going on a solo tour. This guy sounds kind of pretentious? no?

[Colin1755]

i think it will just be him and a piano maybe for the tour maybe? and yeah i did like both SC albums but i think JM is a little better now.

[Machu505]

I only like a few of JM songs. :shrug:

[Fedaykin]

Yes
Because then I could see SC in concert

[tragedyco]

For a tour? Yes. For good? No.

[phil19]

yes. i liked something corporate

[VIVALAMATT]

No. Thought his JM stuff was incredibly better than anything SC did.

[muchoawesomeo]

i love sc, i'd like to see them back in action

[zachff]

fuck anyone who says no. seriously, i will fight you

[Zippedychick]

I started listening to him with Jack's Mannequin. I do like Something Corporate but not as much as Jack's.

[roche]

Of course he should, I would love another SoCo album or reunion tour.

[lonelysuperstar]

Jack's Mannequin is better. So no.

[sargentlgfuad]

hellllllllllllllllllllll no.

[Takk...Ros]

i dont understand andrew mcmahon. He basically IS jack's mannequin...and yet now he's going on a solo tour. This guy sounds kind of pretentious? no?
Don't speak badly of Andrew McMahon. I will cut you M-(
Juuusst kidding, but on topic, I said yes because I see no reason why he couldn't do both.

[threepunchjim]

For a tour? Yes. For good? No.

my thoughts exactly. nothing wrong with a good ole' reunion tour, but the jack's is too good to bury.

[maker_break]

Yes. Though I love both... SoCo > Jack's Mannequin by a long shot.

[Broden Terry]

I prefer Jack's Mannequin but I wouldn't be disappointed if he went back to Something Corporate.

[color_coded]

I prefer Jack's, but I love SoCo, too.

[i breathe music]

if only for another tour, yes, but i think what he is doing with jack's is better music. soco is more nostalgic for me at this point.

[fightinirish217]

I'd love another SC album/tour. Then he can go back to Jack's...maybe.

[denissuxx]

Favorite musician, SoCo is my fav. band, so yes.

[Theseventhson]

No, SoCo sucked.

[m_rue]

A little reuinion tour would be nice, but the Jack's albums are so much better than what he did in Something Corporate (don't get me wrong though, I do love both).

[tttygxlove]

As long as he keeps making music, I'll be happy.
Agreed.

[fadedmemories]

Jacks is decent, but SoCo was great

[jjjkman]

Jack's is great....but I feel that North is the best thing Andrew has ever put out, so if he could one up that with another SoCo album, that would be great. Plus I'd love to see SoCo live.

[ericsounds41]

Doesn't really matter to me as long as he keeps making music I'll be happy.

[pianorocklove]

fuck anyone who says no. seriously, i will fight you

This.

[AbbeyCarbs]

no, ive always liked jacks mannequin better

[crimsonandclovr]

I started listening to him with Jack's Mannequin. I do like Something Corporate but not as much as Jack's.

have to agree with this. i voted yes, but really, Jack's did more for me than SoCo. although him coming back would be unbelievably splendid.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Yes. I loved the first JM album but couldn't get into the newer one as much. Although both bands are good, I'd prefer more SoCo.

[nicoteen]

fuck anyone who says no. seriously, i will fight you

THIS!

[And Hours Pass]

No. Thought his JM stuff was incredibly better than anything SC did.
Me too. I think that North was a great album (I love Down & Me and the moon), but I think that Everything In Transit is one of my favorite albums of the past 10 years. It was honestly brilliant. I think SoCo were great, but Andrew has matured a lot since writing those records and I think that SoCo fans would be disappointed if he went back because he wouldn't be writing songs with the same maturity level as "I woke up in a car," or "I kissed a drunk girl." Those songs are timeless, but that era has passed.

[ianxcurtis]

Jack's is great....but I feel that North is the best thing Andrew has ever put out, so if he could one up that with another SoCo album, that would be great. Plus I'd love to see SoCo live.
This

[Indoor Living]

if only for another tour, yes, but i think what he is doing with jack's is better music. soco is more nostalgic for me at this point.
Yep. Exactly this.

[Clark]

No. He should start a new project. Both of his bands' debut albums are amazing, but their follow-ups are just okay.

[AsItFallsApart]

LTTW = EIT
North > TGP

since i think north is the best he's done i'd have to vote for soco, though i'm happy to hear whatever he puts out