Goodbye Sky Harbor vs 23

[Helpless]

Long, emotional, awesome.

Vote plox.
You don't get an obligatory funny third option. Sorry.

[cason eat world]

Two of my favorite JEW songs but ultimately I chose 23.

[mrnegativezero]

23 is one of the best songs by Jimmy Eat World. As much as I love Goodbye Sky Harbor, it's too repetitive to go against 23.

[MADSTA]

I don't like Goodbye Sky Harbour that much.
Or Clarity for that matter...

[jared091]

23 is JEW's best song

[jay_klinkhammer]

23 might be my favorite JEW song

[The Boat]

23 is one of my most favourite songs ever let alone my favourite jew song.

[superichie]

REALLY?! 23 is beating Goodbye Sky Harbor?

Such a shame. Don't get me wrong, I love "23" (one of the few songs to bring tears to my eyes actually), but I just can't say it's better than "Goodbye Sky Harbor".

[A Man Of Ideals]

I'm shocked that 23 is winning this. I read "A Prayer For Owen Meany" just because of the song Goodbye Sky Harbor.

[PunkRocks]

23 is a great song. Its a beautiful song.

But to me, Goodbye Sky Harbor is one of the most completely satisfying pieces written by a band in my lifetime.

23 is a movement. GSH is a symphony.

[fightinirish217]

Yea, 23 is one of my favorite songs ever. Goodbye Sky Harbor is more than incredible but I voted 23.

[jordalsh]

Goodbye Sky Harbor just goes on wayyy too long.
23 is my favorite JEW song

[Rogers]

23 for sure. Goodbye Sky Harbor is really really really awesome, but 16 minutes can be a bit much.

[AussieBoy]

23 for sure

i cant stand how GSH drivels on for a good 10+ mins of the same bit im usually done with it after the 5th min, in fact might chop the last 10mins out in itunes now

[NorthstarPark]

23 for sure as it is not only one of my favorite Jimmy songs but one of my favorite songs period. Like people are saying Goodbye Sky Harbor is great but it just drags on a little too long. it pains me to say that though but it is the only 16 minute song I can listen to without getting bored.

[skellorock]

i like playing 23 on the guitar more (especially the solo), not quite sure that makes it my fav tho, i mean Clarity is probably my all time favorite album, i mean its the first that pops in my mind when i name favs haha.

[inthemidst]

"23" is my favorite Jimmy Eat World song. If I had one song in the background of my life, it would be this track.

[TJ Wells]

This is sad.