Who is funnier?

[Nick Hull]

my two favorite comedians.
just wondering what everybody else thought.

[kazuma_ootaro28]

Don't know much about Jim Gaffigan. All I know is, Tosh.O annoys me to no end.

[azure19]

But... I love them both! Voted for Gaffigan though, heard more of his stuff. Hilarious.

[Nick Hull]

Don't know much about Jim Gaffigan. All I know is, Tosh.O annoys me to no end.
you can not judge him by that show fairly.
it's so much different from his stand-up.

[showyourteeth]

you can not judge him by that show fairly.
it's so much different from his stand-up.

definitely
his actual stand up is hilarious

[Indoor Living]

These guys are both funny, but nowhere near my personal favorites. That being said, Tosh takes the cake quite easily.

Going along with the people above, yes, his show sucks. He doesn't.

[Gardenhead]

Jim Gaffigan barely wins it for me here.

[FullCollaspe]

Tosh takes it by far.

[Broden Terry]

Tosh. Although he's definitely not my favorite.

[industrialbelt]

louis ck is funnier than both of them. but gaffigan is better.

[Pawan1993]

No love for Russel Peters?

[fightinirish217]

my two favorite comedians.
just wondering what everybody else thought.

This is the greatest poll ever man. My favorite two comedians as well. I voted Tosh but it's really a tie for me. Saw Tosh at my school two years ago, amazing.

[Nick Hull]

No love for Russel Peters?
I like russel peters. but I think these two on a completely different comedy level.

[And Hours Pass]

These guys are both funny, but nowhere near my personal favorites. That being said, Tosh takes the cake quite easily.

Going along with the people above, yes, his show sucks. He doesn't.
I like Tosh a lot, but I think that he overdoes the "see what I did there? I bet you didn't think you could get helen keller and delta airlines in the same joke. But I did." It was funny the first few times, but he really does it way too often.

My favorite stand up special is far and away Kevin James: Sweat the Small Stuff. I know that some of you are going to say you hate King of Queens, and that's fine, but if you haven't seen his comedy special you have to. It's one of the funniest things I've ever seen.

I would also put Nick Swardson's stand-up in my favorites as well.

[Indoor Living]

I like Tosh a lot, but I think that he overdoes the "see what I did there? I bet you didn't think you could get helen keller and delta airlines in the same joke. But I did." It was funny the first few times, but he really does it way too often.

My favorite stand up special is far and away Kevin James: Sweat the Small Stuff. I know that some of you are going to say you hate King of Queens, and that's fine, but if you haven't seen his comedy special you have to. It's one of the funniest things I've ever seen.

I would also put Nick Swardson's stand-up in my favorites as well.
Kevin James and Nick Swardson are both funny, but Patton Oswalt is far and away my favorite comedian.

[bard]

I like Tosh a lot, but I think that he overdoes the "see what I did there? I bet you didn't think you could get helen keller and delta airlines in the same joke. But I did." It was funny the first few times, but he really does it way too often.

My favorite stand up special is far and away Kevin James: Sweat the Small Stuff. I know that some of you are going to say you hate King of Queens, and that's fine, but if you haven't seen his comedy special you have to. It's one of the funniest things I've ever seen.

I would also put Nick Swardson's stand-up in my favorites as well.
this is absolutely hilarious. i loved that show, and that special makes me laugh every time i listen to it. i listened to it this morning actually.

pretty much everything he says is amazing.


out of these two, gaffigan is better. tosh is annoying and overrated. he's almost as bad as dane cook.

[pens4life2]

best stand up shows : Chapelle , Katt Williams, Mitch Hedberg

[teh_erica]

I love Jim Gaffigan.

[sargentlgfuad]

Hot Pockets.

[I am Mick]

not a fan of either but really dislike Tosh

[yourneck]

tosh is an annoying dick. he reverts to easy targets for his jokes too much

[NateGolubiewski]

Gaffigan. It would've been a close vote if Tosh.0 wasn't one of the most annoying shows out there.

[And Hours Pass]

Kevin James and Nick Swardson are both funny, but Patton Oswalt is far and away my favorite comedian.
Doesn't he have a new special coming out soon (or maybe that came out very recently)?

[And Hours Pass]

this is absolutely hilarious. i loved that show, and that special makes me laugh every time i listen to it. i listened to it this morning actually.

pretty much everything he says is amazing.


out of these two, gaffigan is better. tosh is annoying and overrated. he's almost as bad as dane cook.
If only I had a magic carpet... I'd be there in like 2 hours...

[Indoor Living]

Doesn't he have a new special coming out soon (or maybe that came out very recently)?
Yeah, dude. My Weakness Is Strong. Sunday night. Gonna be super, super funny. He's hilarious.

[BulleTheory]

i love me some Gaffigan

[Nick Hull]

If only I had a magic carpet... I'd be there in like 2 hours...
that was my favorite joke of his special, by far.

[And Hours Pass]

that was my favorite joke of his special, by far.
Mine too. Easily. I also really liked the "it's fruit frederick!" bit. I honestly like the whole thing. My least favorite part is probably the greeting card bit. But the rest is excellent.

[VIVALAMATT]

Both are great. I gotta go with Tosh though. Both are super funny and original, but I feel like most times I'm only laughing at Gaffigan because he's making some weird noise or something. lol

[Rakkalakka]

i love this poll! they're two of my favs too :]

[billy_yo]

Rhys Darby's stand up is pretty funny. SHINFO

[zachff]

Jim Gaffigan

[Un'Aria Ancora]

Tosh.
Although that show is crap.

[maker_break]

I think that Tosh just acts like a douche and his jokes are borderline annoying. Gaffigan is just genuinely funny.

P.S. Any love for Lewis Black?

[Colin1755]

tosh all the way, he is so funny, love his viral videos show.

[drzafs]

Brian Regan is my favorite comedian. He's awesome.

[tonighttonight0]

Jim Gaffigan

[yoyostring]

tosh 2.0 is a bad show. but his standup is funny, so i went with Gaffigan.

[yoyostring]

tosh 2.0 is a bad show. but his standup is funny. i went with Gaffigan.

[yoyostring]

I like Tosh a lot, but I think that he overdoes the "see what I did there? I bet you didn't think you could get helen keller and delta airlines in the same joke. But I did." It was funny the first few times, but he really does it way too often.

My favorite stand up special is far and away Kevin James: Sweat the Small Stuff. I know that some of you are going to say you hate King of Queens, and that's fine, but if you haven't seen his comedy special you have to. It's one of the funniest things I've ever seen.

I would also put Nick Swardson's stand-up in my favorites as well.

Kevin James' standup is HILARIOUS, that's my favorite as well. Pablo Francisco's is a favorite of mine too. and i love the King of Queens, i think it's hilarious. :shrug:

[And Hours Pass]

Kevin James' standup is HILARIOUS, that's my favorite as well. Pablo Francisco's is a favorite of mine too. and i love the King of Queens, i think it's hilarious. :shrug:
I'm a fan myself, but I do think that not liking king of queens doesn't mean you won't love his stand-up. It is too funny.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Gaffigan, but I enjoy them both.

[bladerdude360]

This was a toughie for me. However, I've known Gaffigan for longer and have seen him live so went with him. Both are great though.

[Yellowcard2006]

Two of my favorites also. I gotta go with Tosh.

[sfpunk]

kind of a silly poll

Jim gaffigan is known for his clean humor and tosh is known for pushing it to the limit and being completely edgy, i wouldnt even think to compare the 2

if you did Jim Gaffigan vs Brian Regan, that would be a tough one. Both are clean and just use observational humor and never fail to make me laugh.

[ArtForLovers]

I dont even know who Tosh is... Its Gaffigan all the way!

"Caliente Pockets"

[Nick Hull]

I dont even know who Tosh is... Its Gaffigan all the way!

"Caliente Pockets"
If you don't know...don't vote.
I don't think I've ever laughed so hard as I have at Tosh's 'Survivor' joke.