Death Cab for Cutie vs. Modest Mouse

[Loge182]

The choice is yours.

[nolan182]

Death Cab.

[kdefrisc]

Easily Death Cab

[PunkRocks]

The answer is obvious: Brand New.

[nolan182]

^^lol

[Broden Terry]

I prefer Modest Mouse.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

Lyrically: modest mouse
Musically: modest mouse
Better live show: modest mouse


I used to lovedeath cab, but they don't do much for me anymore.

[Yontsey]

Easily modest. I don't see why people are interested in DCfC

[Theseventhson]

Modest Mouse is leagues better.

[mike'smannequin]

Deathcab!

[Zippedychick]

Death Cab

[ericsounds41]

Death Cab

[just.Starla.]

I like Modest Mouse, but I prefer Death Cab.

[billyboatkid]

I absolutely hate Modest Mouse.

I've just recently started to like DCFC.

[George-Michael]

deathcabdeathcabdeathcabdeathcabdea thcabdeathcab

[provethatIexist]

hard decision, but i'd have to say Modest Mouse.

[trappedintime]

Death Cab owns. And I could never get into Modest Mouse.

[Dymytry Vance]

This has to be a fucking joke. Modest Mouse... all the way....

[Dymytry Vance]

Modest Mouse for sure. They are my favorite band and I have never been able to get into DCFG. Their boring,lifeless, and monotone vocals make them unlistenable
Another this.

[FullCollaspe]

Modest Mouse have made more great albums than Death Cab will probably ever release.

[Praetor]

Wow...I love Death Cab, but "Modest Mouse > Death Cab" is barely debatable.

[BulleTheory]

cant get into death cab...modest mouse for me

[Yellowcard2006]

Brand New are basically modest mouse now. So I gotta go with Brand New (i.e. Modest Mouse)


No but for serious I voted death cab.

[bowl of oranges]

Modest Mouse

[konvalbr]

modest mouse gives me a migraine listening to that garbage

[Un'Aria Ancora]

MM by far.

[Neo Cassady]

Death Cab. MM to me is very hit or miss; their style works really, really well with some songs but is cringeworthy in others.

[Nick Hull]

there is no loser in this poll, but I went Death Cab.

[Meeze]

they are both fantastic... Modest Mouse though

[JordanBuell]

Modest Mouse have made more great albums than Death Cab will probably ever release.


death cab has released more studio albums than modest mouse.......

[jwicklun]

modest mouse. I like death cab but lyrically, musically, and in creativity modest mouse are far more talented.

[mrnegativezero]

My instinct told me Death Cab. But I have to give Modest Mouse a lot of credit.

[briewer]

Modest Mouse. If DCFC starts producing albums of the quality of The Moon And Antarctica, The Lonesome Crowded West, and Good News For People Who Love Bad News, then we'll talk.

[GamEin]

Cab.

[fran.182]

Death Cab For Cutie all the way!

Imo, Modest Mouse sucks, except for a couple songs.

[ohioforlovers]

Death Cab!! I listened to them this weekend in my ipod while i painted my house :) they make the time go by more swiftly.

[Dagless]

Modest Mouse

[azlisa]

DCFC is one of the greatest bands ever. They can do no wrong in my eyes and ears. I enjoy Modest Mouse though!

[GamabuntaSS]

I respect Death Cab to the highest level,but Modest Mouse is the winner in my book.

[neurosis]

Modest Mouse

[abcdefghijake]

MM LCW
I don't even need to use words.

[zachff]

not a big fan of either, to be honest
IMO they're about =

[bandrewes]

death caaab but modest mouse are also so good