View Full Version : Who is the best singer?
Who is the best singer, not your favorite singer, out of these talented dudes?
I chose Dallas Green b/c he is GOD.
inthemidst
09/03/09, 08:54 AM
I don't think Dallas Green is God, but he has very lush clean vocals, and has a very balanced delivery. Anthony Green is a good vocalist, but I have trouble listening to him for more than about 7 or 8 songs because of his extremely high-pitched piercing vocals. Jonny Craig also is very talented, but he tries too hard.
Poe-tryGirl
09/03/09, 01:11 PM
Anthony Green. Dallas is not God.
briewer
09/03/09, 01:58 PM
Woof.
BulleTheory
09/04/09, 10:29 AM
Brandon Boyd kicks the shit out of all of these guys.
jonny's voice never gets tiring (but his songs do)
Indoor Living
09/04/09, 05:17 PM
Dallas is the best out of these three.
TotalCollapse
09/04/09, 06:03 PM
Dallas
seraph1214
09/04/09, 06:06 PM
My favorite singer out of these three is Anthony. The best is also Anthony.
AbbeyCarbs
09/04/09, 07:03 PM
cannot get enough of dallas green
xJesusFreakx
09/04/09, 07:36 PM
Dallas Green is easily best out of these vocalists.
HometownHero
09/04/09, 09:08 PM
Dallas by a fucking long shot
Machu505
09/04/09, 09:49 PM
I like none.
George-Michael
09/04/09, 11:03 PM
Tough choice excluding Craig
Broden Terry
09/05/09, 12:37 AM
Anthony Green. Closely followed by Dallas.
VIVALAMATT
09/05/09, 01:21 AM
Of these three, Anthony Green reigns supreme.
THE_SICKEST
09/05/09, 03:47 PM
I love both Greens.
Neo Cassady
09/05/09, 05:26 PM
None of these.
I like none.
None of these.
then who?
Green > Green > Craig
which Green?
I love both Greens.
Take a stand!
SuNDaYSTaR
09/05/09, 06:09 PM
My favorite singer out of these three is Anthony. The best is also Anthony.Dallas is in a whole other league than Anthony.
eleven eleven
09/05/09, 07:06 PM
Wh ois johnny craig?
ThatswhatUget23
09/05/09, 10:45 PM
Wh ois johnny craig?
He's in Emarosa and used to be in Dance Gavin Dance.
muchoawesomeo
09/06/09, 07:34 AM
tony, dallas is great tho.
Nick Hull
09/06/09, 12:10 PM
Dallas Green. incredible.
Ryzenfall
09/06/09, 05:59 PM
I am guessing people continue to pick Anthony Green because of Circa and Saosin, but Avalon was ridiculously bland.
Had to go with Dallas. He seems to only improve.
Jonny is talented, but his style so far seems very one dimensional, while Dallas can do both hard and soft music well.
jay_klinkhammer
09/06/09, 06:23 PM
It's Jonny Craig easily. Best best best voice and he had the best platform to use it in while in DGD. No contest.
I am guessing people continue to pick Anthony Green because of Circa and Saosin, but Avalon was ridiculously bland.
Had to go with Dallas. He seems to only improve.
Jonny is talented, but his style so far seems very one dimensional, while Dallas can do both hard and soft music well.
I like Avalon, but otherwise, I have to agree with you. Dallas is by far the superior singer.
BulleTheory
09/06/09, 08:57 PM
Dallas...cant stand Anthony's voice after about 4 seconds.
handlikesecret
09/06/09, 10:29 PM
wicked difficult. i'd have to say Dallas because of the better variety we've seen from him. maybe it's just because i prefer his solo stuff to Anthony's.
dallas green is my choice
TangledUp
09/07/09, 04:28 AM
Dallas!
Theseventhson
09/07/09, 07:49 AM
They're all really obnoxious singers. I guess my vote goes to Anthony Green, though, just because I like Circa.
blue_bedlight
09/07/09, 11:49 AM
Brandon Boyd kicks the shit out of all of these guys.
Fact.
blue_bedlight
09/07/09, 11:52 AM
Green's Saosin is the only Saosin I can listen to. Cove blends in far too much with the riffs. And I don't know the other two, so therefore Anthony gets my vote. But Brandon Boyd kicks the shit out of all three of them.
fightinirish217
09/07/09, 12:37 PM
Anthony Green
AMackChuck
09/08/09, 04:38 AM
Dallas is leaps and bounds above the others, sorry.
They're all really obnoxious singers. I guess my vote goes to Anthony Green, though, just because I like Circa.
Dallas Green is not obnoxious...who is ur favorite singer overall?
Theseventhson
09/08/09, 04:30 PM
Dallas Green is not obnoxious...who is ur favorite singer overall?
He is quite annoying. My favorite singer is probably Thurston Moore, him or Mark Arm.
CodeName - Nate
09/08/09, 08:05 PM
I went with Craig, because I like how he fluctuates in range and tone. He can sing soft when he wants and get gritty as well. But that takes nothing away from thinking both Greens are phenomenal. I really just enjoy all of them as a whole.
doppelganger
09/08/09, 08:18 PM
not a big fan of any of them but i guess il pick dallas.
whataclush
09/08/09, 08:24 PM
I went with Craig, because I like how he fluctuates in range and tone. He can sing soft when he wants and get gritty as well. But that takes nothing away from thinking both Greens are phenomenal. I really just enjoy all of them as a whole.
holy shit, someone who actually knows what they're talking about. a rarity on AP.net.
He is quite annoying. My favorite singer is probably Thurston Moore, him or Mark Arm.
why is Dallas annoying? I checked out the other two singers, and in my opinion, they sound quite generic to their time. I guess that is the impression I'm am going to receive from listening to two songs apiece...but still...
Jonny Craig.Damn my bf, with out her I would have picked Anthony Green-
introduction
09/10/09, 04:47 AM
anthony green has a unique voice.
S9Dallasoz
09/10/09, 12:01 PM
Anthony Green. Dallas is not God.
LIES!
Poe-tryGirl
09/10/09, 12:21 PM
LIES!
Nu uh!
mike'smannequin
09/12/09, 07:02 AM
anthony green
Anthony Green. Dallas is not God.
LIES!
jbaseball44
09/12/09, 07:29 AM
4th option needed
Zack Haughton
09/12/09, 09:24 PM
Green is obviously the best.
i enjoy both dallas green and anthony green but i went with dallas
MyNameIsRoss
09/14/09, 08:12 PM
bad these singers are bad
konvalbr
09/15/09, 09:46 AM
anthony green obviously
ExtremeAvalanch
09/15/09, 10:32 AM
why is anthony green showered with praise? His voice is flatout whiny and he isn't that great of a singer. He sounds exactly like this kid that was in my high school, and everyone thought he was the greatest singer ever but he was just a kid. dallas is an incredible singer, but brandon boyd is the best singer in the world.
why is anthony green showered with praise? His voice is flatout whiny and he isn't that great of a singer. He sounds exactly like this kid that was in my high school, and everyone thought he was the greatest singer ever but he was just a kid. dallas is an incredible singer, but brandon boyd is the best singer in the world.
Incubus lost me w/ that shitty Light Grenades. HORRIBLE.
Indoor Living
09/15/09, 02:24 PM
Incubus lost me w/ that shitty Light Grenades. HORRIBLE.
What was bad about it?
blue_bedlight
09/15/09, 08:36 PM
What was bad about it?
I have to agree with him. I didn't like Light Grenades either. It just didn't seem like Incubus to me. It was like, an Incubus rip-off, with Brandon Boyd, minus turntables. Wasn't big on it. Granted that my favorite of theirs is Make Yourself so that might have something to do with it.
What was bad about it?
it lacked the edge of the previous Incubus efforts and felt, dare I say it, like radio-rock. a forced piece of turd that was placed upon this earth to ruin people's idea of Incubus...it showed little to no progression, musically, and lyrically, it was mediocre at best. def not their best effort.
Indoor Living
09/15/09, 09:19 PM
I have to agree with him. I didn't like Light Grenades either. It just didn't seem like Incubus to me. It was like, an Incubus rip-off, with Brandon Boyd, minus turntables. Wasn't big on it. Granted that my favorite of theirs is Make Yourself so that might have something to do with it.
it lacked the edge of the previous Incubus efforts and felt, dare I say it, like radio-rock. a forced piece of turd that was placed upon this earth to ruin people's idea of Incubus...it showed little to no progression, musically, and lyrically, it was mediocre at best. def not their best effort.
If you're calling A Kiss To Send Us Off, Rogues, Pendulous Threads, Light Grenades, maybe even Papers Shoes radio-rock, I feel you are extremely mistaken. Yes, there are a few that were meant to be good singles, but what Incubus album hasn't had that?
blue_bedlight
09/15/09, 10:34 PM
If you're calling A Kiss To Send Us Off, Rogues, Pendulous Threads, Light Grenades, maybe even Papers Shoes radio-rock, I feel you are extremely mistaken. Yes, there are a few that were meant to be good singles, but what Incubus album hasn't had that?
I will give you Quicksand and A Kiss To Send Us Off. Quicksand was a ridiculous intro for Kiss, and Kiss is just, amazingness encapsulated in 4:16. Dig was moderately decent. I enjoyed it the first few times I heard it, and still kinda do. The remix they do for it live, no words. You have to see it. Your brain will turn to mush. Anna Molly reminded me of a mix between Sick Sad Little World & Beware! Criminal, which I enjoyed and still do. Light Grenades the song, second favorite on the album. All the other ones, kinda fell to the wayside. I love slower Incubus, actually alot of slower, mellower music, but I just couldn't get into the ones on this record. I hated Earth To Bella, both parts. I really can't figure out why. I listened to them my first few listens of the CD, then to them one after another a couple times and every time it was the same thought. I can't stand this. I'm looking forward to their next CD hardcore though. They really seemed back when I saw them live, plus I fucking love Black Heart Inertia. It's like Crow all over again, which I really dug.
Indoor Living
09/16/09, 05:23 AM
I will give you Quicksand and A Kiss To Send Us Off. Quicksand was a ridiculous intro for Kiss, and Kiss is just, amazingness encapsulated in 4:16. Dig was moderately decent. I enjoyed it the first few times I heard it, and still kinda do. The remix they do for it live, no words. You have to see it. Your brain will turn to mush. Anna Molly reminded me of a mix between Sick Sad Little World & Beware! Criminal, which I enjoyed and still do. Light Grenades the song, second favorite on the album. All the other ones, kinda fell to the wayside. I love slower Incubus, actually alot of slower, mellower music, but I just couldn't get into the ones on this record. I hated Earth To Bella, both parts. I really can't figure out why. I listened to them my first few listens of the CD, then to them one after another a couple times and every time it was the same thought. I can't stand this. I'm looking forward to their next CD hardcore though. They really seemed back when I saw them live, plus I fucking love Black Heart Inertia. It's like Crow all over again, which I really dug.
Ok, so let me get this straight. Are you saying Crow is probably your favorite Incubus record? Cause if so, then the reasoning behind being moderately disappointed with Light Grenades makes sense.
blue_bedlight
09/16/09, 09:02 AM
Ok, so let me get this straight. Are you saying Crow is probably your favorite Incubus record? Cause if so, then the reasoning behind being moderately disappointed with Light Grenades makes sense.
Crow is second favorite. Make Yourself is hands-down my favorite.
Indoor Living
09/16/09, 10:15 AM
Crow is second favorite. Make Yourself is hands-down my favorite.
That still makes sense. I think those two go together, as do Morning View and Light Grenades.
YoungSavage
09/16/09, 02:11 PM
It doesn't really matter because its just a survey but it's lame that it seems like 2/3 of the people voting don't even know who Jonny Craig is. I feel like before you vote you should have to listen to "And I told them I invented Times New Roman", "Lemon Meringue Tie", "Set it off like napalm" and "What I would give to be Australian".
I love all three vocalists and I am a Circa Survive fan but sometimes I feel like i'm taking crazy pills when I talk to people about Anthony. Dude has one tone! He's a good singer for sure but as far as being able to escalate ranges, tones and vary power I just don't think he really compares to Dallas or Jonny.
Dallas and Jonny are my two favorite singers on the planet but I have to give the nod to Jonny because when he is singing heavier songs he can add this amazing grit to his voice while hitting such a high range and thae transfer to this soothing and soulful almost R&B quality instantly. He might not have written songs quite up to the caliber of some of Dallas's work yet but he's in his very early 20's and I think when its all said and done he will be known of one of the greats period not just in the "scene"
I also love the I haven't heard of these guys but Brandon Boyd kicks there ass comments. First off that's ignorant and retarded and second Brandon has lost the passion in his vocals. I was a big fan of Incubus in high school and went to a ton of shows. They still occasionally have some good tracks but I just feel like Brandon especially has been phoning it in and have just been bored to death by a lot of the newer songs.
It doesn't really matter because its just a survey but it's lame that it seems like 2/3 of the people voting don't even know who Jonny Craig is. I feel like before you vote you should have to listen to "And I told them I invented Times New Roman", "Lemon Meringue Tie", "Set it off like napalm" and "What I would give to be Australian".
I love all three vocalists and I am a Circa Survive fan but sometimes I feel like i'm taking crazy pills when I talk to people about Anthony. Dude has one tone! He's a good singer for sure but as far as being able to escalate ranges, tones and vary power I just don't think he really compares to Dallas or Jonny.
Dallas and Jonny are my two favorite singers on the planet but I have to give the nod to Jonny because when he is singing heavier songs he can add this amazing grit to his voice while hitting such a high range and thae transfer to this soothing and soulful almost R&B quality instantly. He might not have written songs quite up to the caliber of some of Dallas's work yet but he's in his very early 20's and I think when its all said and done he will be known of one of the greats period not just in the "scene"
I also love the I haven't heard of these guys but Brandon Boyd kicks there ass comments. First off that's ignorant and retarded and second Brandon has lost the passion in his vocals. I was a big fan of Incubus in high school and went to a ton of shows. They still occasionally have some good tracks but I just feel like Brandon especially has been phoning it in and have just been bored to death by a lot of the newer songs.
i agree w/ almost every thing you say, except, i give it to Dallas. I just think he is more the consistent singer. I really do <3 all 3 though...Anthony tends to just have the same tone the entire time... Either way, sick response!
blue_bedlight
09/17/09, 08:23 PM
That still makes sense. I think those two go together, as do Morning View and Light Grenades.
I think that's their thing. Just so they don't have the same album twice in a row and critics talk smack about no progression or something. Which makes me just think that, the next cd, will be like Crow and Make Yourself. Which if Black Heart Inertia was an indication, means I will definitely enjoy the hell out of it.
blue_bedlight
09/17/09, 08:28 PM
I also love the I haven't heard of these guys but Brandon Boyd kicks there ass comments. First off that's ignorant and retarded and second Brandon has lost the passion in his vocals. I was a big fan of Incubus in high school and went to a ton of shows. They still occasionally have some good tracks but I just feel like Brandon especially has been phoning it in and have just been bored to death by a lot of the newer songs.
I resent that. I've heard all three. I still like Boyd better.
k1guitar
09/19/09, 11:58 PM
WOW! did not see that result at ALL!
Ok, so let me get this straight. Are you saying Crow is probably your favorite Incubus record? Cause if so, then the reasoning behind being moderately disappointed with Light Grenades makes sense.
Crow is by far my fav. Incubus LP
WOW! did not see that result at ALL!
i am so happy that people here at AP are giving Dallas the credit he is owed...Anthony is one hell of a singer, so is Jonny, but neither is as dynamic as Dallas.
Indoor Living
09/22/09, 05:11 PM
Crow is by far my fav. Incubus LP
i am so happy that people here at AP are giving Dallas the credit he is owed...Anthony is one hell of a singer, so is Jonny, but neither is as dynamic as Dallas.
So your second favorite is Make Yourself? I'm just guessing.
So your second favorite is Make Yourself? I'm just guessing.
na, i dont really like any other incubus...not bad, but just dont really care for any of their other stuff
Indoor Living
09/22/09, 09:10 PM
na, i dont really like any other incubus...not bad, but just dont really care for any of their other stuff
Fair enough. Haha.
murrich
09/22/09, 09:16 PM
All three are boring.
All three are boring.
def disagree. which singer entertains you?
murrich
09/23/09, 04:20 PM
def disagree. which singer entertains you?
Tom Waits
Mark Hollis
David Eugene Edwards
Tom Waits
Mark Hollis
David Eugene Edwards
those are no where close to the same style of singing as the Greens or Craig... i just cant compare. although, i am impressed that you are into them...specially Tom Waits...old school as fuck.
murrich
09/25/09, 03:11 AM
those are no where close to the same style of singing as the Greens or Craig... i just cant compare. although, i am impressed that you are into them...specially Tom Waits...old school as fuck.
Old school? He's still making music.
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.