Best Right Fielder of All Time

[Chris M.]

Poll coming.

[CarouselBoy]

such a sick list of players. Hammerin Hank gets my vote. I'd go with him, ruth, and rose as top 3.

[youkwalks]

Mel Ott. Beautiful OBP and probably wont get the voted Ruth or Aaron will.

[Colin1755]

obvisouly pete freaking rose.

[rcrook]

Mel Ott. Beautiful OBP and probably wont get the voted Ruth or Aaron will.

Huh? The Babe had a much better OBP.

[youkwalks]

Huh? The Babe had a much better OBP.
I know, but he'll already get the recognition. Ott wont.

[rcrook]

I know, but he'll already get the recognition. Ott wont.

So you're voting based on who deserves recognition as a great RF not who the best is?

[youkwalks]

So you're voting based on who deserves recognition as a great RF not who the best is?
I feel as though these polls have clear cut winner most of the time (Ruth for instance) and no discussion is really needed. So I, in my bored state, picked a player who should be 2nd or 3rd in the voting, but will probably be bumped to around 5th because names like Aaron, Rose, and Ichiro will beat him out.

Did I answer the question correctly, no, but I bet I just started a new debate. (and yes I could have been more clear in my first post, but im working....which reminds me....)

[poppa Q]

Went with Hank.

[startBBtoday]

obvisouly pete freaking rose.

Yeah, obvisouly.

Went with ruth

[donwagenblast]

I thought sosa played left?

[rcrook]

I thought sosa played left?

He played 14 career games in left...

[The Summer Ends]

babe did more with hot dogs and beer than today's players can do with bull testosterone

[inthemidst]

Clemente, hands down. Of course, I'm a Pirates fan, so I'm a little biased haha.

[ActionActionFan]

Obviously Hank

[QuikTrig]

there's only one "obvious" answer here, and its the babe.

the debate starts for whose second best.

[bigmike]

babe did more with hot dogs and beer than today's players can do with bull testosterone
And segregated pitching where pitchers were asked to max out their arms and, thus, were throwing in the middle 80's on their fastball by the end of the year. Oh, and an even shorter RF porch than what was in the old yankee stadium at the end of her days.

Hate that argument about Ruth, even though I picked him.

[The Summer Ends]

And segregated pitching where pitchers were asked to max out their arms and, thus, were throwing in the middle 80's on their fastball by the end of the year. Oh, and an even shorter RF porch than what was in the old yankee stadium at the end of her days.

Hate that argument about Ruth, even though I picked him.
sorry :(

[donwagenblast]

He played 14 career games in left...


Wow. Goes to show how much I know haha. Sorry about that

[Colin1755]

rose was better than ruth look at the stats.

[Spicoli hey bud]

babe did more with hot dogs and beer than today's players can do with bull testosterone
How original.

[QuikTrig]

rose was better than ruth look at the stats.
:unsure:

[bigmike]

rose was better than ruth look at the stats.
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahahaha. That's the most laughable thing I've ever heard on this website. Jesus christ.

[COTA]

Babe Ruth

[Colin1755]

look at the fucking stats rose is better than ruth.

[rcrook]

look at the fucking stats rose is better than ruth.

in what category you dope? the only category in which rose trumps ruth is hits and rose had almost 6,000 more at bats.

[bigmike]

look at the fucking stats rose is better than ruth.
You're a joke.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

Clemente is my favorite..

but I gotta go with Ruth

[Colin1755]

Pete Rose.

[FueledByFrodo]

Colin no way Rose tops Ruth.

[Colin1755]

u mean ruth tops rose?, becasue u agreed then disagreed haha, where u been dude?

[FueledByFrodo]

u mean ruth tops rose?, becasue u agreed then disagreed haha, where u been dude?
I've been home and working. And no, I mean Ruth is better than Rose.

[Rodeo]

<< Only vote for Kaline.

[fightinirish217]

Sultan of Swat

[bigmike]

<< Only vote for Kaline.
Kaline's always underrated, but I don't know how you can logically vote him over Ruth.

[Talib Scottie]

Ruth, Rose, Clemente.

Clemente's arm was unreal.

[Timma]

Gotta love Kaline. Not a single game in the minors.

[A7XXX]

Ichiro is the man. He brings excitement to the game everytime he comes to the plate.

[justbrett]

Clemente. If he had a full career i don't think it wolud be disputable.

[rcrook]

Clemente. If he had a full career i don't think it wolud be disputable.

Better than Ruth? Get real. It's not like the dude passed away in his early thirties. He was 37 during his last season so unless he would have played til he was 50 there is no way he is better than Ruth.

[bigmike]

I don't even think Clemete was better than Al Kaline.

[ted is lying]

I'm going to stay Aaron.