pick one

[livelovecrydie]

your favorite weapon

[FOBPrettyNPunk]

They're both pretty equal in my opinon..I can't choose one.

[x-factor6]

Hard choice between TBS' best and BN's second best (Deja is better about 0,001 point).
As a band its much Easier. Brand New.

[bigal00004]

soco amareto lime and seventy times seven are better than every song on tell all your friends, I have to go with Your Favorite Weapon.

[Java Nick]

fuck this one was so hard. i picked brand new because for the summer of 03 that album defined who i was. tayf is still an amazing album though.

[i breathe music]

deffinatly a tough one, but i had to go with taking back sunday. i think tayf was amazing as a whole and your favorite weapon just had a bunch of awesome songs...

[pretty_in_punk3]

im surprised TBS are winning...

i voted for your fav. weapon

[dashboard1190]

Tayf

[hubbabubbal3ts]

i love both of these cds. tayf had more of an impact on my life so i'm going to have to go with that.

[golfchick]

for me, Brand New would win over TBS, but TAYF was in my cd player for about 1 year straight, Your Favorite Weapon is second to any other album though, so all pretty close anyways.

[Base3Studd]

tbs's best > bn's 2nd best (barely)

[dontgrabtindy]

tayf

[zbrmike79]

i voted Your Favorite Weapon.. but i dont know if i ment it... i love both

[oldprospector]

i choose tayf but if it was deja vs. where you want to be id take brand new.

[melvicious]

hard.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

deja > tayf > yfw > louder > wywtb