PDA

View Full Version : Attack Attack! - Someday Came Suddenly


Andrew33
09/18/09, 12:26 PM
Attack Attack! - Someday Came Suddenly
Record Label: Rise Records
Release Date: November 11, 2008

While listening to the debut album by Attack Attack! for probably the hundreth time, I find myself confused at much of the dislike this band has generated. Although I do realize all music tastes are subjective to the listener, I don't see how a band with this much talent has been compared to such horrible acts such as Brokencyde. I have listened to them back when If Guns Are Outlawed, Can We Use Swords? (Unreleased EP, 2008) was making its way around the internet and onto my iTunes. If you haven't listened to them yet, or have only heard the cover of Katy Perry's song "I Kissed A Girl", I recommend getting the closest pair of earbuds and looking them up on YouTube.

The album opener "Hot Grills and High Tops" is crunkcore-esque, but (very) thankfully it ends there. Their first actual song, and their single, kicks right into action after that, with the opening scream and breakdown of "Stick Stickly" leading the way. Although the band did make two music videos for this song, which I think was a mistake, it's still the second best song on the album and one of my favorites, even though the newer music video gave birth to the term "crabcore", based on how the band members were standing while they played the breakdowns. I'm pretty sure the word "crabcore" started out as an insult, but it has almost turned into something other bands look for.

"Bro, Ashley's Here" follows smoothly, continuing the lyrical content and eloquent synth work found in "Stick Stickly". The album's title comes from this song, in the very powerful line "Someday came suddenly, and now I'm left standing here." "Shred, White, and Blue" continues the odd song titles, catchy synths, and a heavier sound than the first three tracks.

"Party Foul" follows and is the only song to have only screaming. The synth parts in this song are impressive, and the ending could fit on any The Devil Wears Prada album. A techno song fits in after "What Happens If I Can't Check My Myspace When I Get There?" (an obvious reference to Attack Attack!'s popularity), and it shows the skill Caleb has on his keyboards. "The People's Elbow" follows, with great heavy screams and greater breakdowns. The surprising thing about this song is that the lyrics are about making a mistake with a girl, an abnormal change from the almost exclusively Christian-inspired lyrics.

"Kickin' Wing, Animal Doctor" is a remake of "If Guns Are Outlawed" from their EP, and ends with another incredible breakdown. "Dr. Shavargo, Pt. 3" begins with a techno twist, than goes right into screaming "As always, it's all for You". The album ends with the same line, but in a more surprising manner- it softly raises you up, and then drops you down into a breakdown/double bass ending. The last song (but not the last track) is my favorite song, "Catfish Soup". Austin (the lead vocalist) and Johnny (the clean vocalist/guitarist) trade back and forth throughout the song, ending in possibly one of the best breakdowns and one of the best lyrics written to end an album:

"Hallelujah, I've been saved by grace,
Hallelujah, saved by grace,
and this is why, I've been saved,
by His grace.

Just think about this now,
as we come to an end.
The decisions you have,
made will come back to haunt you,
and as the story ends and
you look to the sky,
this couldn't have happened by chance."

Following this, "Outro" carries you away with a piano ending (reminding me of "This Is Who We Are" by As I Lay Dying, a little bit?). This ending is perfect for the album, as you've probably heard enough breakdowns by now. Although the album barely clocks in over 30 minutes, it still packs quite a punch.

The musicianship is impressive, and the thing that gets the most criticism also gets the most credit from me: the keyboards. The guitarists do their job, the drums are impressive (though repetitive), but the vocalist is probably the low point of them all. Austin could only hit the high screams, no singing, and they had Caleb do the low screams (see the end of "Shred, White, and Blue"). Although, to Attack Attack!'s credit, they now have a new vocalist named Nick, who will appear first on their new album in 2010. The lyricism is superb, mostly based on Christianity, although the whole band isn't Christian. The songs do sound alike though, to each other and to their multiple-genres they fall under (not crunkcore).

It's a very solid effort by a good hardcore band. I definitely will be purchasing their future releases, and suggesting you do the same.

I See Stars, The Devil Wears Prada, A Skylit Drive, Breathe Carolina, A Day To Remember

Check out Attack Attack! on Myspace (http://www.myspace.com/attackattack).

FullCollaspe
10/03/09, 01:18 PM
lol 9 for lyrics, and the ''hardcore band'' part

PureBlueSF
10/03/09, 07:25 PM
http://i42.tinypic.com/2cqekht.gif

Andrew33
10/03/09, 09:39 PM
http://i42.tinypic.com/2cqekht.gif
I am very proud of you sir, for being the first person to post this. certaintly not last tho

PureBlueSF
10/03/09, 10:04 PM
At least I'm good at it :-p

Crabcore jokes aside, this band is nowhere near as bad as some people make them out to be. They're not great, but their songs are usually damn catchy. The main thing that bothers me is that (with the exception of Kickin' Wing) all the songs have incredibly annoying T-Pain-styled autotuned singing. Some of the synth sections work well but others will just ruin the song. They're not absolutely terrible but they are inconsistent.

Andrew33
10/04/09, 08:47 AM
yeah, i know what you mean. personally, the autotune never has bothered me too much (although there is bands that i hate only because of it), but it might be that I'm immune to it or whatever, it doesnt seem to bother me. i probably like them because ive been a Sky Eats Airplane fan forever, and i think of them of a less-original more-catchy version of them. still dont understand crabcore though, it makes me laugh lol.

kevinAIWW
10/05/09, 09:18 AM
I hate attack x2 . theyre dicks.

always have been and they always will be. not to mention how generic the music is.


this album deserves way lower score

npmshah
10/05/09, 08:37 PM
Your review was rather lenghty. I enjoyed it for the most part, but the conclusion paragraph just killed it for me. While you got your point across, it was a chore to read. You need to improve you eloquence slightly.

The Summer Ends
10/05/09, 08:55 PM
holy lol at the score for this

gr33ndayfr3ak
10/05/09, 10:02 PM
This band isn't as great as you make them out to be, but they aren't quite as terrible as what everyone makes them out to be.
That aside, your writing skills need some work.

joesmedicated
10/05/09, 10:04 PM
I guess your opinion is your opinion. But.. Eh, whatever. Don't even know why I clicked the link.

NateFoundGlory
10/05/09, 10:06 PM
I guess your opinion is your opinion. But.. Eh, whatever. Don't even know why I clicked the link.

I clicked it to lol, and it delivered.

To each their own, I guess.

Andrew33
10/06/09, 03:01 AM
This band isn't as great as you make them out to be, but they aren't quite as terrible as what everyone makes them out to be.
That aside, your writing skills need some work.

Any specific criticism? This is my first review and that would be helpful. Although, the funny thing about this comment is that your name is 'gr33ndayfr3ak'.. personally I hate Green Day more than just about any other band lol.

gr33ndayfr3ak
10/06/09, 10:24 AM
Any specific criticism? This is my first review and that would be helpful. Although, the funny thing about this comment is that your name is 'gr33ndayfr3ak'.. personally I hate Green Day more than just about any other band lol.
Haha well to each their own, I guess. They always have been and always will be my favorite band.

A lot of your sentence structures are kind of awkward. For example:
"...trade back and forth throughout the song, ending in possibly one of the best breakdowns and one of the best lyrics written to end an album:"
"The lyricism is superb, mostly based on Christianity, although the whole band isn't Christian. The songs do sound alike though, to each other and to their multiple-genres they fall under (not crunkcore)."
"Although the band did make two music videos for this song, which I think was a mistake, it's still the second best song on the album and one of my favorites, even though the newer music video gave birth to the term "crabcore", based on how the band members were standing while they played the breakdowns"

I do think you did a good job giving your thoughts on a majority of the songs while not making the review too lengthy, and your RIYLs are pretty accurate.

Andrew33
10/06/09, 01:35 PM
Haha well to each their own, I guess. They always have been and always will be my favorite band.

A lot of your sentence structures are kind of awkward. For example:
"...trade back and forth throughout the song, ending in possibly one of the best breakdowns and one of the best lyrics written to end an album:"
"The lyricism is superb, mostly based on Christianity, although the whole band isn't Christian. The songs do sound alike though, to each other and to their multiple-genres they fall under (not crunkcore)."
"Although the band did make two music videos for this song, which I think was a mistake, it's still the second best song on the album and one of my favorites, even though the newer music video gave birth to the term "crabcore", based on how the band members were standing while they played the breakdowns"

I do think you did a good job giving your thoughts on a majority of the songs while not making the review too lengthy, and your RIYLs are pretty accurate.

Good point, thats what makes music tastes subjective. thanks for actually giving me points, most people dont when critiquing- i didnt realize how long winded some of my sentences got. When i write the next one, ill make sure to keep that in mind.. thanks!

princesschad
10/06/09, 03:13 PM
Look like crabs, talk like people

gr33ndayfr3ak
10/06/09, 03:59 PM
Good point, thats what makes music tastes subjective. thanks for actually giving me points, most people dont when critiquing- i didnt realize how long winded some of my sentences got. When i write the next one, ill make sure to keep that in mind.. thanks!
Yes exactly! I wish more people on this site would understand that.

Yeah, haha it happens. I find that if I read through what I've written a few times after I think I'm finished it's pretty easy to pick out problem areas like that. Good luck!

thiseternalsnow
10/07/09, 06:36 PM
Ahahahahaha.

red8ge
10/10/09, 08:36 AM
I feel like their excess of breakdowns try to cover up for creativity(in my honest opinon).

Not a bad review though, you bring up some decent points.

kbi the crowing
10/10/09, 10:30 AM
Look like crabs, talk like people
yes

review was meh, mainly because I think a linear review like this are less informative than one that judges the album as a whole

marsvoltamcr
10/10/09, 10:48 AM
Attack Attack! is a good band. That is all.

Raarzipan
10/10/09, 11:36 AM
I don't think a lot of the hate comes from the music, so much as it does the fact that they over auto tune and are really rude people. They have super rockstar attitudes and their current frontman can't even scream.

king marcello
10/10/09, 03:37 PM
this band is hated waaaaay too much.
they arent that bad, but they arent anything special.
and they took that crab core thing farther than it needed to go.
just my opinion.

Chrisj182
10/11/09, 03:55 AM
Agree completely, great review.

denissuxx
10/11/09, 07:58 AM
Hhahahahahahahha

You must be joking, please?

Andrew33
10/11/09, 01:36 PM
I feel like their excess of breakdowns try to cover up for creativity(in my honest opinon).

Not a bad review though, you bring up some decent points.

personally, i think that many bands do use breakdowns to cover up creativity, mainly in the deathcore styles of music. but i think that bands closer to this genre show their creativity with breakdowns. a good example of that would be The Taste of Regret by In Fear & Faith- amazing song, and the breakdown at the end illuminates their creativity rather than subtracting from it. now if this was Whitechapel, id completely agree.

AWilhelmPetter
10/11/09, 04:41 PM
Please, don't say that you think Whitechapel are bad and lack creativity when you state that you reckon Attack Attack! have any at all. I enjoy their some of their songs, but that's just because they are fun to listen to - not because it's quality music. Whitechapel, on the other hard, is quality.

anthonydarko
10/11/09, 06:20 PM
Lolololololololololololololololol at review.

Andrew33
10/11/09, 09:27 PM
haha personally, I really don't like Whitechapel. but it might be because I don't listen to much deathcore- My Bitter End, old BMTH, Iwrestledabearonce... that's about it. even Suicide Silence is a little far for me. Although, Dr. Acula makes me chuckle.

miketheauthor
10/16/09, 12:56 PM
Hate this band. They are awful

LastDeclaration
10/20/09, 02:41 PM
It's true they aren't nearly as bad as people claim, and I don't understand why they're compared to Brokencyde, Breathe Carolina, etc., but they're still mediocre and generic. 5/10 for me.

Handraa
10/24/09, 11:53 AM
I am very proud of you sir, for being the first person to post this. certaintly not last tho
now drop it lowwww

Mario57
11/11/09, 05:58 AM
the UK attack! attack! are x10000 better than this

Andrew33
11/15/09, 09:00 AM
the UK attack! attack! are x10000 better than this

they have no reason to be compared except that they have the same name, so i don't compare them

xAUST-BOSSx
11/28/09, 04:12 PM
as soon as you get to the over-the-top autotunin' it's just pathetically boring and predictable... it's music that people will listen to because it's trendy. there's nothing too unexpected or unique, nothing that hasn't been done before. i'm a fan of hardcore, but it's just sad when every part of a song can be identified as something already done before.

Dystroxia
01/03/10, 11:25 AM
The Devil Wears Prada has NOTHING to relate to this band with.

You did write a good review, though.

nathaniel
01/03/10, 10:15 PM
This album is great! It may not be completely outstanding in every aspect, but it's such a fun album to listen to. And the lyrics are fantastic.

Dystroxia
01/09/10, 06:46 PM
holy lol at the score for this
LMAO

That was hysterical

holy lol, oh wow that was funny

AirTraffic
05/11/10, 09:40 PM
Like a lot of people have said, the album isn't as good as you make it out to be, but I like it. It has some good stuff on it. Sadly, this will be the only decent album this band ever puts out.

ImFromAustralia
05/12/10, 01:12 AM
This isn't the most talented band in the world, but they're quite good at what they do
The first song from their new album has little to no auto-tune, and Caleb as the screamer
I feel as though Attack Attack! may win some new fans who were put off by the auto-tuned singing and the high pitched screaming.