PDA

View Full Version : Moneen - The World I Want to Leave Behind


Jeremy Aaron
09/24/09, 01:17 PM
Moneen - The World I Want to Leave Behind
Record Label: Vagrant Records
Release Date: September 15, 2009

It's been a long three-and-a-half year wait, but Moneen have finally arrived with the full-length follow-up to the brilliant, Brian McTernan produced The Red Tree, a huge step up for the Canadians that brimmed with both sincerity and fiery intensity. My excitement for this release only intensified with the release of the teaser Hold That Sound EP, the title track of which suggested that the band had reached an even higher level of skill in marrying passion with huge hooks. Not a moment too soon, The World I Want to Leave Behind has dropped, and alas, it's not exactly the game changer I hoped it would be. Still, it serves as an effective showcase of the band's many talents, and it's hard to view it as anything other than a success.

The introductory title track initially gives you a false sense of security, opening with dulcet guitar tones and Kenny Bridges' soft vocal delivery. Knowing that the band, like most of their peers, likes to play off soft-loud dynamics, one can anticipate the oncoming storm. It's a little cliche by now to begin an album with an understated intro that culminates in an epic rise, but when Chris Hughes' stratospheric post-rock-tinged guitar erupts, you just can't resent their use of the well-worn convention. Above all, Moneen are a band that clearly know what they're good at and what their fans want to hear. They put it all together on the marvelous "Hold That Sound," a song that expertly pits aggression against beauty, utilizing guitars that are alternatingly sinister and soaring, thunderous drums and one of the strongest vocal hooks of the band's career.

"Did you wake up today? Did you find the strength to say the world is your own," Bridges sings on the hopeful, empowering "Believe," which finds Moneen exploring their straightforward pop-rock side, with nary a hint of their usual subtle math-rock and post-rock tendencies. The back-to-back ballads "Redefine" and and the string-accented "The Way" are flat-out gorgeous; though typically not known as balladeers, Moneen revisit the format often here and prove themselves capable again on late-album cuts "Waterfalls" and "Lighters." All these slower tunes contrast sharply with "The Long Count," which catches you off guard with Hughes' guitar roaring to life, Steve Nunnaro's drums delivering a crushing blow, and the record's most cathartic vocal performance.

At their best, Moneen make some exciting and inventive music, so if there are some minor pitfalls on the album, it's when they start to sound bland and unimaginative, as on "Great Escape" and "Red Eyes," a couple of mid-tempo pop-rock tunes that sound more inspired by bands like Spitalfield than anything else. Not that there's anything wrong with Spitalfield (or these songs for that matter), there's just nothing all that special about them, and Moneen have proven themselves capable, in the past and at times on this record, of creating some truly special output.

If The Red Tree was the sound of a band realizing their potential, The World I Want to Leave Behind sounds, at times, like a band trying to distance themselves from their previous effort. Much of the spacy, ethereal vibe of The Red Tree is absent here, though whether this is the band's doing or the result of not working with McTernan (who has brought that feel to a number of records in recent years) this time around is up for debate. Whatever the case, it's not necessarily a bad thing, as a stylistic venture like "Waterfalls" and it's Sleeping at Last-style orchestration makes for a welcome departure and a powerful demonstration of the band's breadth. Still, the presence of a few borderline boring tracks knock the album down from exceptional to merely very good. The point is, approach this album with healthy expectations, and there's more than enough good stuff to satisfy.

Park's It Won't Snow Where You're Going
The Cast Before the Break's As Your Shoulders Turn on You
Evaline's Postpartum Modesty. A Portrait of Skin
Thrice's Vheissu
Spitalfield's Better Than Knowing Where You Are

1. The World I Want to Leave Behind (1:57)
2. Hold That Sound (3:18)
3. Great Escape (3:12)
4. Believe (3:30)
5. Redefine (3:26)
6. The Way (4:17)
7. The Long Count (3:53)
8. The Monument (2:42)
9. Waterfalls (3:45)
10. Red Eyes (4:09)
11. Lighters (4:09)
12. The Glasshouse (6:09)

xapplexpiex
09/24/09, 01:36 PM
I bought this the other day and I had to look all over town for it. This small record store had it and only one copy left. It's pretty good, but The Red Tree is better. Nice review.

owiseone35
09/24/09, 08:06 PM
Spot on man, I'm lukewarm on this release. I just think the slow songs are pretty lame. Coming from a kid who loves his ballads too.

emkvetwin
09/25/09, 12:14 AM
I think that's fair. I personally love "Redefine" among others, but the record does grow a little static at times. Still a big fan.

Chris Fallon
09/25/09, 01:39 AM
Spot on review. This one is in the middle of their catalog for me. I loved The Red Tree dearly, and this isn't nearly as lush or powerful to me ... but it's still quite good. Just could be a bit better.

Indoor Living
09/25/09, 05:54 AM
Spot on review. This one is in the middle of their catalog for me. I loved The Red Tree dearly, and this isn't nearly as lush or powerful to me ... but it's still quite good. Just could be a bit better.

My exact opinion.

inthemidst
09/25/09, 06:08 AM
Hmmm...I have to put my name in the "I love this album dearly" category. I think "Great Escape" and "Red Eyes" have incredible hooks and layers of intensity. The only thing I disliked on the album was the order of the songs. Spacing the ballads probably would've worked a bit better, than putting three slower tracks in a row. Other than that, this album is spot on. I loved your review, though, Jeremy. Great description, and though I love Red Tree a bit more, this is an immensely beautiful release from a very understated band in the scene.

FRAMEY
09/25/09, 06:17 AM
I think this is up there with The Red Tree, my favourite album so far this year. The dvd that came with it is also awesome.

RoboZombieKitty
09/25/09, 06:29 AM
Can't stop listening to this. So so good.

ramomcferno
09/25/09, 06:32 AM
I really like this album. Upon more listens I may be able to decide whether I like this or Red Tree more. I have to say though that the Glasshouse is my favorite ever .moneen. song! It is brilliant. Great review!

roisterboy
09/25/09, 06:51 AM
Great review! This album is awesome..and I loved The Red Tree. The thing is you cannot compare the two.

live.
09/25/09, 07:04 AM
This album got me into the band, but as soon as I grabbed Red Tree I stopped listening to this. Great review.

zachff
09/25/09, 07:21 AM
I could never get into Red Tree. I'll give this a listen and I'm a big fan of Park (RIYL) but I don't know, something about Moneen I just can't latch on to.

TwoTongues
09/25/09, 07:35 AM
love this album! guess I have to agree about some weaker songs in the mix, but still definitely going to be high on my AOTY list.

sean_tbl
09/25/09, 07:56 AM
I personally love this album, I think "Great Escape" is an amazing song. But the amount of ballads do hurt, mostly "Waterfall" Yeah and "Hold That Sound" is one of the best songs I've heard in a long time, love the contrast of detuned guitars and bright shiny chorus.

fightoffyrdmns
09/25/09, 08:13 AM
Believe. That is all.

Nothing but love for this band.

xapplexpiex
09/25/09, 09:00 AM
I really like this album. Upon more listens I may be able to decide whether I like this or Red Tree more. I have to say though that the Glasshouse is my favorite ever .moneen. song! It is brilliant. Great review!
I like The Red Tree alot more. Idk why, but I can't get into this one. And I like your avatar. Desmond and Penny, right?

Nap
09/25/09, 09:12 AM
I agree that this is not better than The Red Tree. But this album is still very good and solid.

whyte39
09/25/09, 09:43 AM
Canada's best band. Well, along with Stars.

astaticskyline
09/25/09, 10:10 AM
Oddly enough, this is my favorite record they've put out... way different than red tree, but i like it better

GeeBee
09/25/09, 10:12 AM
Only a handful of truly awesome songs on this album, but still a worthy release.

t00latef0rr0ses
09/25/09, 10:43 AM
i really do enjoy this album.

Co and Ca
09/25/09, 11:40 AM
This and Daisy are currently battling for my AOTY. Moneen are one of my top 5 favorite bands, so I'm going to be bias towards them. I can't help it though. They have never let me down. They've stayed consistent they're whole career which is a rare feat these days.

ak4
09/25/09, 01:27 PM
I thought Red Eyes was an excellent track. Those Whoa's are extremely infectious.

Short-Lived
09/25/09, 01:58 PM
Great review. This is currently my AOTY and "The Long Count" is easily my fave track off this record.

ramomcferno
09/25/09, 02:14 PM
I like The Red Tree alot more. Idk why, but I can't get into this one. And I like your avatar. Desmond and Penny, right?

I feel like this album is a grower. Give it a little more time, it seems to get better on every listen.

Thanks! Yeah, they are my favorite characters. I can't wait for the new season!

xapplexpiex
09/25/09, 03:12 PM
I feel like this album is a grower. Give it a little more time, it seems to get better on every listen.

Thanks! Yeah, they are my favorite characters. I can't wait for the new season!
I'm listening to it again now, and you're right. It's not too bad. And yeah, me neither. I'm rewatching all the seasons on DVD.

zack-182
09/25/09, 03:48 PM
disappointment

dietoseeyoufail
09/25/09, 05:00 PM
It's an ok album. I really wish they'd do something new.

but it's alot better than half the shit out there

jesse_hitz
09/25/09, 05:23 PM
To me this album blows red tree away by far. It's a bit more radio friendly yes but you can sure tell the musicianship and song writing have matured and become a lot better.

HometownHero
09/27/09, 12:09 AM
This cant seem to grow on me at all. I wanted it to. But it just wont

HoldThatSound
09/27/09, 09:30 PM
Album of the year.

Poochemist
09/28/09, 01:35 PM
I think I had the same reaction to this album. Very good album, but I don't think it will be high on my AOTY list, if at all.

a speedo model
09/28/09, 05:08 PM
Great CD. I refuse to compare it to the Red Tree..

cereal4life
09/29/09, 05:13 AM
An excellent review as always, Jeremy!

I especially appreciate your album RIYLs. They're a lot more accurate than simply naming an artist or band. Some artists undergo such drastic sound changes and maturation that simply giving their band-name as a RIYL is vague and a bit ambiguous. Eg, Thrice and Radiohead. They are mentioned as a RIYL band for so many bands and yet both of them have such a diverse catalogue and have changed their sound since their inception that it doesn't really say much about the album being reviewed.

Paulb-182
09/29/09, 05:16 AM
Never really got into The Red Tree. I'm gonna have to give it another listen.

jasonisasleep
09/29/09, 08:45 AM
I've had The Red Tree for years, but just never got into it. Maybe I didn't give it the chance it deserved, but this new record really hits me. I can't stop listening to it. It's the perfect blend of old and new sounds. It has a great deal of emotion and depth. Love it.

Cheesus
09/30/09, 05:29 PM
purchased. can't wait to listen. coooool review

brenByah
10/16/09, 11:32 PM
This record's a grower. The first time I heard it I liked it, but wasn't blown away. After the 5th listen it finally clicked. Great record (though not Red Tree great, that album won't be topped).

TheSkyline
09/02/11, 05:51 AM
Nothing tops Are We Really Happy.. but this album is pretty sweet too.