what is the best punk band?

[nimrod180]

what do you think the best punk band of all time is?

[Shatter590]

talk about a heated and overused thread topic...

[TheByrus]

descendents.


/thread

[Sinister Rouge]

bad religion

[Dan CiTi]

The Clash or London Calling is the best punk record.
or:
The Ramones(pop-punk-esque)
Desendents
Lifetime
Kinda:
Green Day(pop-punk)
Nirvana(punk-esque until they had lots of fame)
Goldfinger(under-rated)

[WeRAllD00dz]

Kinda:
Green Day
Nirvana(punkish until they had lots of fame)
Goldfinger
are you high?

[Butaire]

all or the descendents

[riseagainst89]

Proper english would be who do you think the best punk band of all time is? And id be a little bias because they are my faviorite band but Rise Against.

[Darren McLeod]

probably black eyed peas

[Dan CiTi]

are you high?
I was...sorta; I see how stupid that is now I do that a lot. Nirvana was probably the last great rock band though.

[Darren McLeod]

I was...sorta; I see how stupid that is now I do that a lot. Nirvana was probably the last great rock band though.
blue album > nevermind.

discuss.

[mrzippo3]

IMO- Bad Religion, NOFX

[btbam > you]

my favorites are rancid, nofx, and the clash.

[FinchBulldog2]

The Clash

I was...sorta; I see how stupid that is now I do that a lot. Nirvana was probably the last great rock band though.
No, Chili Peppers are great and existed after Nirvana.

[Carlo Marx]

the best punk band of all time? difficult to say.

the best pop-punk album of all time = descendents - milo goes to college.

[Dan CiTi]

The Clash


No, Chili Peppers are great and existed after Nirvana. True, as for most important/influental/innovative of all time:
1.The Beatles
2.Nirvana
3.The Ramones
4.U2 or Led Zeppelin
5.Pink Floyd

[Dan CiTi]

the best punk band of all time? difficult to say.

the best pop-punk album of all time = Descendents - Milo Goes To College. Or
Green Day - Dookie
Saves The Day - Through Being Cool
Lifetime - Jersey's Best Dancers
Ramones - Rocket To Russia(people will hate me for saying that so look here:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4595384/ [the article is opinoin but contains quotes & facts])

[aminorthreat55]

Either you said The Clash or you're wrong.

[Carlo Marx]

Or
Green Day - Dookie
Saves The Day - Through Being Cool
Lifetime - Jersey's Best Dancers
Ramones - Rocket To Russia(people will hate me for saying that so look here:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4595384/ [the article is opinoin but contains quotes & facts])

no and no on green day and std. lifetime isn't a pop-punk band. and the ramones were never all that good.

[Dan CiTi]

Either you said The Clash or you're wrong.
huh?

[Shoes]

True, as for most important/influental/innovative of all time:
1.The Beatles
2.Nirvana
3.The Ramones
4.Pink Floyd
5.U2 or Led Zeppelin
Pink Floyd sucked after Sid Barret went insane, but their first album was brilliant.

[-trapped]

My chemical romance and hawthorne heights

[TheByrus]

lifetime isn't a pop-punk band.


who said anything about pop punk?

[Carlo Marx]

who said anything about pop punk?

i did. that guy was responding to my post about milo goes to college being the best pop-punk album ever. he responded with jersey's best dancers.

[mikeford]

there are two acceptable answers to this question.

either the clash or the ramones.

and for the record, nirvana had very much a punk influence (pat smear was in the fuckin germs for god sakes) but by no means would i ever refer to them as a punk band.

[nbl]

sex pistols!

[aminorthreat55]

there are two acceptable answers to this question.

either the clash or the ramones.

and for the record, nirvana had very much a punk influence (pat smear was in the fuckin germs for god sakes) but by no means would i ever refer to them as a punk band.
All correct. But c'mon, as much as I love The Ramones, The Clash are way better.

[boysdontcry17]

what about modern punk bands? best modern punk bands=nofx and against me!

[FourdyOz]

hard question. i would say bad religion/minor threat/misfits

[BreakerBreaker]

The Ramones are horrible. Iggy & The Stooges are the best ever!

[aminorthreat55]

The Ramones are horrible. Iggy & The Stooges are the best ever!
No. I mean I enjoy Iggy and the Stooges, but no.

[BreakerBreaker]

Probably, but the Ramones shouldn't have this many supporters.

[greeleyxcore]

AFI....back in the day

[NobodyKids]

Green Day and Panic! at the disco is tyied.

[punkskater33]

Rise Against. No Lie!

[IAmHolocaust]

Green Day and Panic! at the disco is tyied.
:-D
Funny guy.

[The Revisionist]

Wheatus obv.

[mht]

the mc5 (1960s-1970s)
the new york dolls.(1970s)
nofx.(1980s-present)
bear vs shark (2002-2006)

graphed by decades for your pleasure of best punk.

[mikeford]

All correct. But c'mon, as much as I love The Ramones, The Clash are way better.

oh believe me, the clash is my answer but the ramones is the other acceptable answer.

[Andy]

The Clash

[aminorthreat55]

The Clash
Good viking.

[El_Jeffe]

as much as i love musical discussion
i really couldn't see how anyone could not vote for the clash

some good bands have been bought up though

[thisdecemberhop]

the culprits.
i think.

but to go with more known stuff.

operation ivy.

[punkangel86]

The Used & I'm not high! or EMO..

[Dustinwr]

What a joke. The best punk bands are bands that were actually punk in message and life. Check out Crass, Minor Threat, Dead Kennedeys, Black Flag, or Antischism.

[ExhaleThePain]

NOFX, I guess.

[Dina]

http://www.dankosleepteam.com/banners/alt_486x60.gif (http://phobos.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewAlbum?id=151173524&s=143441])




click on this link. love it!

[handguns4hearts]

Either The Clash or the Sex Pistoles.

[insidepunk]

I think I'll have to go with The Clash too.

[Dan CiTi]

I think I'll have to go with The Clash too. yup. London Calling is the best punk album of all time(IMO).

[Dan CiTi]

I did. that guy was responding to my post about milo goes to college being the best pop-punk album ever. he responded with jersey's best dancers.
sorry, but a reveiw for hello basturds starts out with:In the surpisingly crowded world of pop-punk,Lifetime is a rare find. IMO those are the best STD(SWYA is great too) & GD pop-punk albums.

[Dan CiTi]

there are two acceptable answers to this question.

either the clash or the ramones.

and for the record, nirvana had very much a punk influence (pat smear was in the fuckin germs for god sakes) but by no means would i ever refer to them as a punk band.
Thats what I meant,at the time I couldn't think of the words to say.

[Dan CiTi]

i did. that guy was responding to my post about milo goes to college being the best pop-punk album ever. he responded with jersey's best dancers.

I DO think Milo Goes To College is the best pop-punk record and London Calling is the best punk record. Those others are runner-ups.

P.S . why I posting 4 times in a row? to clear things up, because some people get pissed at multiple posts.

[isterica]

best punk band....Sex Pistols...
and for the idea that i have about punk...nirvana...

[xHollywoodHit]

Sex Pistols. Don't even have to think about that one.

[BattleofHeroes]

blink 182

[OMGzzBreakdownz]

LOL. blink 182 is not punk at all.

i like iggy and the stooges.

but my fave right now is probably rise against

[dbarker02]

Such a pointless thread...:(

I think aminorthreat55 is the only poster on here who half knows what he's talking about.

[Dustinwr]

What a joke. The best punk bands are bands that were actually punk in message and life. Check out Crass, Minor Threat, Dead Kennedeys, Black Flag, or Antischism. See

[dbarker02]

http://www.glam-rock.de/dolls.jpg

[Ilovepoprock]

anyone like no use for a name?

[mrzippo3]

anyone like no use for a name?

Awesome band, awesome live show, my only complaint is that their new record sucks and that makes me sad

[NOFXROCKS!]

The Ramones, The Sex Pistols, The Clash, The Skumbagz, The Remnants, Zeke, NOFX, Rancid, Against me(well, thats folk punk), and way more :D:D:D

[PDon11]

Besides the Clash, Sex Pistols and ramones, which is ur typical top 3.

MC5, i cant believe they've been mentioned only once. and Dead Kennedys, Black Flag, Fugazi, Misfits, Bad Brains, minor threat, Husker Du, Minutemen, nation of ulysess. Newer bands would be at the drive-in, nofx, refused, old AFI, ect.

And the best punk album to me is Kick Out the Jams

[pinkmonkey]

Hands down, the casualties are the best new punk band and the sex pistols take it for classic punk band

[deathwish]

Green Day. Just For The Record, Theyre Not Pop Punk.

[ThirdTimeAround]

Green Day. Just For The Record, Theyre Not Pop Punk.

Who cares? Labels are gay.

[xvszero]

I honestly don't get how the Ramones get so much praise. I think they did a lot back when punk was still a fairly new thing but for the most part all their songs are way too similar.

I'd say Bad Religion, even though they put out a string of not so hot albums for awhile and I lost interest in them. Process of Belief got me caring again, but then the album after (forget the name) I wasn't too big on.

So LATELY Strung Out is the only punk band that consistantly appeals to me.

[Czarsy]

The answer would be Minor Threat.

[fullydownfan]

Leftover Crack, anyone?

[Neo Cassady]

Hands down, the casualties are the best new punk band and the sex pistols take it for classic punk band

the casualties are just laughable.

[charlotte39]

blink 182 is the best band !!!!!

[xvszero]

^^^ No.

[Tovenaar]

That's a personal opinion :) But at the moment I like Slick Shoes very much.

[fcknazisympathy]

fall out boy i love them so punx

[Broken Parachute]

fall out boy i love them so punx
I totally agree, dude. The best punk song ever : Dance, Dance

[fcknazisympathy]

Leftover Crack, anyone?

who listens to real punk
god guys
rancid and nofx are so punk
leftover crack isnt i mean
anti nazi anti homophobe thats so not punx

[Broken Parachute]

who listens to real punk
god guys
rancid and nofx are so punk
leftover crack isnt i mean
anti nazi anti homophobe thats so not punx
lolz ur so gangster

[fcknazisympathy]

I totally agree, dude. The best punk song ever : Dance, Dance

damn straight
i think where is your boy tonight is more punx tho

[Broken Parachute]

damn straight
i think where is your boy tonight is more punx tho
lolz true true

[fcknazisympathy]

What a joke. The best punk bands are bands that were actually punk in message and life. Check out Crass, Minor Threat, Dead Kennedeys, Black Flag, or Antischism.

thank god someone listens to real music

[domesticyeti]

i'd say NOFX.

[Gumboots1128]

i like the used myself but hey w/e bert is sooooo hot and quinn and his sexy bi-ness. SCREW U HOMOPHOBES!!! i like rise against and taking back sunday too. o and afi they're chouette

[dropkick_p]

theres a huge lack of dead kennedys support...come on theyre like the best punk band of all time (my two choices are tem and operation ivy)

[LightSleeper]

The Clash or Minor Threat

[The Revisionist]

Minutemen.

[Chris_FirstTime]

True, as for most important/influental/innovative of all time:
1.The Beatles
2.Nirvana
3.The Ramones
4.U2 or Led Zeppelin
5.Pink Floyd

U2 and pink floyd are the most horrible bands in the history of music

Greatest punk band - Social Distortion

[The Revisionist]

You have apparently not heard of REO Speedwagon?

[xvszero]

What a joke. The best punk bands are bands that were actually punk in message and life. Check out Crass, Minor Threat, Dead Kennedeys, Black Flag, or Antischism.

What does "punk in life" mean, like getting wasted a lot, sleeping in gutters and screwing random chicks?








And yes, I'm being sarcastic.

But only kind of.

[x togepi x]

crass or fugazi.

[Dan CiTi]

U2 and pink floyd are the most horrible bands in the history of music

Greatest punk band - Social Distortion they fucking influenced a lot of people, as far as best punk bands:
1.The Clash
2.The Ramones
3.Fugazi
5.The Descendents
6.Green Day
7.Goldfinger
8.Lifetime
9.Misfits
10.Bad Brains

[xvicxlovesxgdx]

Green Day :)

[Koopato]

The Ramones or The Clash, but im sort of biased because there the only real punk bands I've heard alot of.

[alkalinetrio33]

Lower Class Brats!

[fcknazisympathy]

i like the used myself but hey w/e bert is sooooo hot and quinn and his sexy bi-ness. SCREW U HOMOPHOBES!!! i like rise against and taking back sunday too. o and afi they're chouette

id say they arent punk so pull the trigger immeadiately

[Dirtylilsecret]

omg i luv the band Avenged Sevenfold :)

[Rice and Bread]

minor threat
dead kennedys
against me!

[Ralph Wiggum]

All Time:
Dead kennedys
The Clash
The Ramones
The Sex Pistols

Recently (Last 10 years):
Refused
NoFx
Green Day
Bad Religon
Pennywise

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Misfits

[Czarsy]

Whoever said Led Zeppelin, U2, and Pink Floyd must be on drugs. While they did influence the bands that started punk, saying that they are punk bands is retarded. That is like saying that Beethoven is pop-punk because he technically influenced Fall Out Boy.

Whoever said U2 and Pink Floyd suck: You are a total moron.

[fifi_lykewhoa]

probably black eyed peas


Someone's on crack, foshizzle.

[James Johnson]

Panic! at the disco LALZ!!!1!!1

[fcknazisympathy]

oHh Mi gOddD
takInG bACk sUndAy n BLiNk 182 n GrEenNdayYy

[Broken Parachute]

jacks mannequin

[Rice and Bread]

Circle Jerks.

[MySuicidalLove]

Misfits or Dk.

[born to expire]

they fucking influenced a lot of people, as far as best punk bands:
1.The Clash
2.The Ramones
3.Fugazi
5.The Descendents
6.Green Day
7.Goldfinger
8.Lifetime
9.Misfits
10.Bad Brains

Your list is fucked up.

Even though they were a hardcore band, the correct answer is Bad Brains.

[fcknazisympathy]

hawthorne heights
they are so hardcore
cut my wristssssssssssss
and kill my selfffffffff

[Grugs]

Everyone thinks differently. Everyone has his own best band

[mht]

Righteous Jams.

[starfirekiss]

erm...too many bands such little time!!

i kinda like (think they are great)

hawthorn heights
system of a down
all american rejects
greenday
taking back sunday (or something :P:P )
.....shall i continue??

[mht]

erm...too many bands such little time!!

i kinda like (think they are great)

hawthorn heights
system of a down
all american rejects
greenday
taking back sunday (or something :P:P )
.....shall i continue??



i thought this was the best punk band, not the shittiest band in music period thread?!

[Mr_V1tr1oL]

punk bands?sex pistols and the ramones

[xXMissMurderXx]

im afraid if i stated my opinion i'd get shot.........

[sk8erpunk52]

probably black eyed peas
Tell me ur not fucking serious.
Hell no.

[fcknazisympathy]

Tell me ur not fucking serious.
Hell no.

shut the fuck up black eyed peas are so punk

[turncoat93]

the SEX PISTOLS, THE CLASH, THE MISFITS, BLACK FLAG, CIRCLE JERKS, THE RAMONES

best newer punk bands
ANTI FLAGs
and NOFX

[funnylittlefrog]

the clash.the ramones.the descendents.nofx.and fall out boy. lol

[Arad]

Rancid hands down

[Conz]

Pennywise

[i said poop]

poison idea
minor threat
gorilla biscuits
black flag
7 seconds

[love_american_style]

the ramones is the greatest punk band of all time without them punk music would be crap
(the clash and sex pistols and the misfits are also good, but the ramonesare the best, and who ever said fallout boy, hawthorn heights, and the super non-punk black eyed peas are good then your just a fucking retard

um...no. there were punk bands before the ramones...ramones are totaly overated and quit using that fucking font you fucking n00b.

[Smiggypie_xLove]

best punk band ever?

depends on your opinion.

social distortion?

[love_american_style]

hey gre-d'n i'll use what ever fucking font i want jack-ass
of couse there were punk bands before the ramones but they had a big effect on punk dick

well you need to specify that you fucking douche bagel!

i hope you get aid's.

[TheByrus]

descendents.


/thread


winner!

[ramones1234]

well you need to specify that you fucking douche bagel!

i hope you get aid's.


why are you so angry gre-d'n you must have some sand in your vagina or something
anyway i think you should search ramones on wikipedia and read about them or search them on google and that will tell you everything "douche bag"

i hope you get nut cancer ******


p.s. is my font better dick

[love_american_style]

why are you so angry gre-d'n you must have some sand in your vagina or something
anyway i think you should search ramones on wikipedia and read about them or search them on google and that will tell you everything "douche bag"

i hope you get nut cancer ******


p.s. is my font better dick

yeah because wikipedia is such a reliable source.....they fuck up on a lot of stuff.

just saying i really think the ramones are one of the most overated punk bands of all time. it's not that i completely hate them or anything.....i listened to them for years and realized there were way more better punk rock bands out there. by the way dont act offended you little bitch i'm just fuckin w/ you for the most part.

like you're font much better, douche bag.

[ramones1234]

yeah because wikipedia is such a reliable source.....they fuck up on a lot of stuff.

just saying i really think the ramones are one of the most overated punk bands of all time. it's not that i completely hate them or anything.....i listened to them for years and realized there were way more better punk rock bands out there. by the way dont act offended you little bitch i'm just fuckin w/ you for the most part.

like you're font much better, douche bag.


good point, but i still think the ramones are one of the best

[love_american_style]

good point, but i still think the ramones are one of the best

eh, okay...agree to disagree....i'm sick of arguing over this.

[ramones1234]

eh, okay...agree to disagree....i'm sick of arguing over this.

yeah, your right

[love_american_style]

yeah, your right

but it sure helped me raise my post count!

[ramones1234]

[QUOTE][but it sure helped me raise my post count!
/QUOTE]

lol me too, since im new here and dont have many

[love_american_style]

lol me too, since im new here and dont have many

keep it up!

[nesquikkk]

probably black eyed peas

christ. are you joking?

[screamatme]

It has to be either The Clash or The Ramones. True awesomeness in them both lol.

[BILLY AGE 8]

i just read over that whole ramones argument,

made me laugh,

but in all seriousness the ramones are overrated, ESPECIALLY since its been 30 years since they first came around

but they were good

[Dustinwr]

hey gre-d'n i'll use what ever fucking font i want jack-ass
of couse there were punk bands before the ramones but they had a big effect on punk dick

You're a total noob. I wouldn't take any opinion on Punk serious from a guy with the name "Ramones1234". Take your Merch Rock and shove it.

[FyUoCuK]

Sex Pistols
Dead Kennedys
Minor Threat

[Thebermudian]

Personally I think you can't really rate the best punk band ever , because you first have to argue what punk is because the lines have become so blured and there is so many branches off the original sound.

If we are talking about the best band to follow the origianl punk sound then my vote is The Clash , but as we get into the other branches of punk it is alot harder to decide cause there is Hardcore the best hardcore band is The Dead Kennedys .

Then there is Post-Punk bands , my vote for that catagory is Joy Divison . Then there is OI punk for that I would have to say The Dropkick Murphys , then there is Pop-Punk ..the winner for that group is Blink- 182 . There is also the genre of Skate Punk , the best skate punk band is Rancid . And then there is Ska-Core the best Ska-Core band is The Mighty Mighty Bosstones .

So there is really no best punk band ever , the question should be what are the best bands from the different types of punk music.

[Thebermudian]

Personally I think you can't really rate the best punk band ever , because you first have to argue what punk is because the lines have become so blured and there is so many branches off the original sound.

If we are talking about the best band to follow the origianl punk sound then my vote is The Clash , but as we get into the other branches of punk it is alot harder to decide cause there is Hardcore the best hardcore band is The Dead Kennedys .

Then there is Post-Punk bands , my vote for that catagory is Joy Divison . Then there is OI punk for that I would have to say The Dropkick Murphys , then there is Pop-Punk ..the winner for that group is Blink- 182 . There is also the genre of Skate Punk , the best skate punk band is Rancid . And then there is Ska-Core the best Ska-Core band is The Mighty Mighty Bosstones . The best Anarcho-Punk band is Propaghandi .

So there is really no best punk band ever , the question should be what are the best bands from the different types of punk music.

[ThePressCorpse]

No such thing, a lot of punk bands are the same in talent and quality.

[boxcarcola324]

the ramones hands down

[ramones1234]

You're a total noob. I wouldn't take any opinion on Punk serious from a guy with the name "Ramones1234". Take your Merch Rock and shove it.

fuck you so what if i am

[TXHCryan]

blue album > nevermind.

discuss.
daydream nation > doolittle > pinkerton > blue album > nevermind.

[TXHCryan]

Oh and my answer to this question is Descendents and the Clash.

[BILLY AGE 8]

Personally I think you can't really rate the best punk band ever , because you first have to argue what punk is because the lines have become so blured and there is so many branches off the original sound.

If we are talking about the best band to follow the origianl punk sound then my vote is The Clash , but as we get into the other branches of punk it is alot harder to decide cause there is Hardcore the best hardcore band is The Dead Kennedys .

Then there is Post-Punk bands , my vote for that catagory is Joy Divison . Then there is OI punk for that I would have to say The Dropkick Murphys , then there is Pop-Punk ..the winner for that group is Blink- 182 . There is also the genre of Skate Punk , the best skate punk band is Rancid . And then there is Ska-Core the best Ska-Core band is The Mighty Mighty Bosstones . The best Anarcho-Punk band is Propaghandi .

So there is really no best punk band ever , the question should be what are the best bands from the different types of punk music.

you had some good thoughts here, until you said the best pop-punk band was Blink-182,

once again i have got to say to some one, Blink was not punk, they were Super pop, power pop, whatever you want to call it

someone tried to explain to me that the genre pop-punk was just a bunch of bands most people think are punk but are not, trying to justify that blink was pop-punk, but i didnt buy it.

pop punk is punk with a "poppy" sound to it, which is not Blink 182, They do not deserve the "best pop punk" title

and you may say they are punk, and you may not, but the majority of people i know who actually give a shit about music will agree with me, then you have the people who dont care and are fans of blink, and they think what they want

and i believe you can compare any genre of punk, the only time i think you cant cross compare is when its the base genre, such as Funk, punk, alternative, elecronica, etc.....

bet you even have bands that cross the base genre

creating stuff like

electro punk,

and i think if you had to put a top band in this sub genre it would either be

Atom & his Package

or

Intro5pect

[grant rager]

Dead Kennedys,hands down.The stoogesand lets not be shy The sex pistols.Rancid

[Rice and Bread]

minor threat is the answer, OK.

[XitalianpunkerX]

Nickelback

[xwisebuddhax]

hahaha, fuck you mick

[grant rager]

you will go far.Miner Threat has got to be up there

[Girl@TheRockSho]

Blink 182 ! They Are Like My Favourite Band Of All Times !
And Also Panic! At The Disco ; Fall Out Boy ; Simple Plan ; Motion City Soundtrack ..

[Melissa Johnson]

Blink 182 ! They Are Like My Favourite Band Of All Times !
And Also Panic! At The Disco ; Fall Out Boy ; Simple Plan ; Motion City Soundtrack ..
You're calling THOSE the best bands of all time? Those don't have any place in this thread.

[Melissa Johnson]

omg i luv the band Avenged Sevenfold :)

i like the used myself but hey w/e bert is sooooo hot and quinn and his sexy bi-ness. SCREW U HOMOPHOBES!!! i like rise against and taking back sunday too. o and afi they're chouette
These are jokes too right?

Also, Bert McCraken is scuzzy and dirty. Why would you call someone who looks/resembles a hobo hot?

[roggie1590]

AFI


even if you dont like decemberunderground and sing the sorrow, their old albums are amazing.

[love_american_style]

your mom w/ a cock up her ass...great punk band.

[Czarsy]

minor threat is the answer, OK.
Yep.

[decom_poseur]

Rise Against, The Misfits, Descendents...but there are way to many great bands to name...

[OisNOTdead87]

you will go far.Miner Threat has got to be up there


Learn how to spell.

[poppunkinDC]

i really think hanson was one of the best punk bands of all time...that mm bop song...the political message was amaizing.......... it did alot for the punk movment

[The Godfather]

I don't know if you could crown one band to be the 'Almighty punk-rock band'. Punk-rock is so complex, alot of bands are good for diffrent reasons. I don't think it's possibly to decide on just one.

[BILLY AGE 8]

i really think hanson was one of the best punk bands of all time...that mm bop song...the political message was amaizing.......... it did alot for the punk movment

oh, and Savage Garden, right?

jeez, some of these jokes might have been funny at first, but.......

actually they really were never funny so, uhhh....

kill yourself tomorrow afternoon around, hmmmm, 3:45 Mountain time, got that?

[boysdontcry17]

what a retarded thread

[poppunkinDC]

hey litle billy shut the fuck up ok guy, thanks

[BILLY AGE 8]

oh, why do you have to be so harsh

[Stereo Mike]

:excited:

[OisNOTdead87]

Does anyone agree with me here? I mean P!ATD is SO GREAT! MCR is too...and Senses Fail. I love em.


Of course no one agrees with you, you're a 15 year old girl.

[poppunkinDC]

oh, why do you have to be so harsh
sorry man it was a bit harsh...hope you accept the appologie and forgive the fact that its not spelled right

[level4loser]

hey litle billy shut the fuck up ok guy, thanks

dude, your jokes are lame and so are you.

[level4loser]

sorry man it was a bit harsh...hope you accept the appologie and forgive the fact that its not spelled right

appologie?

you are not 19 years old.

[lfdfforever]

M.D.C. or Destroy

[BILLY AGE 8]

sorry man it was a bit harsh...hope you accept the appologie and forgive the fact that its not spelled right

i might think about it, i am just kind of sick of this thread, its all a bunch of lame people trying to start arguments with fake profiles

oh and i still think your lame

[echo630]

In my own opinion: blink-182. Yeah, there have been a ton more punk bands out before them, but I view them as the best. Their lyrics could dictate certain parts of my life with different songs, and they're shows were great. The band was perfect, and I have never liked any other band more.

[Czarsy]

M.D.C. or Destroy
Wow, someone made non-crappy choices.

[echo630]

Eh . . . . people, saying MCR and PANIC! At the Disco punk bands is like . . . . calling Tom Hanks African American.

[BILLY AGE 8]

calling Blink - 182 punk is like saying your not a retarded peice of shit

which last time i checked....

In my own opinion: blink-182. Yeah, there have been a ton more punk bands out before them, but I view them as the best. Their lyrics could dictate certain parts of my life with different songs, and they're shows were great. The band was perfect, and I have never liked any other band more.

Eh . . . . people, saying MCR and PANIC! At the Disco punk bands is like . . . . calling Tom Hanks African American.

(although this second one is right, your before statement just adds to my point)

yeah, you are

[poppunkinDC]

appologie?

you are not 19 years old.


I actually am 19, just very intoxicated whe I posted that. you think im lame? your the 20 year old self proclamed loser that listens to dragon force :-), still live at home with your parents probably to right.

[poppunkinDC]

i might think about it, i am just kind of sick of this thread, its all a bunch of lame people trying to start arguments with fake profiles

oh and i still think your lame
well, i tried to be nice and apologize, if you just want to be a dick go for it, Im not to worried about what you think of me

[echo630]

calling Blink - 182 punk is like saying your not a retarded peice of shit

which last time i checked....





(although this second one is right, your before statement just adds to my point)

yeah, you are

Aren't you just the investigative one . . .

[Livia Teresa]

Jonny Was .is the best band ever

[FrankMareno]

Dead Kennedys, Bad Religion, and Black Flag and The Clash many great punk rock bands to choose

[poppunkinDC]

bad religion and black flag are the shit

[YouAteMyDog182]

old school blink was punk ie touchdown boy

[BILLY AGE 8]

old school blink was punk ie touchdown boy

oh jeez, when will you all learn,

they were NEVER punk, they are what most of us call, superpop

GET IT!!!!!!!!

a few powerchords is not what makes up a genre, ok!!

[OisNOTdead87]

The Clash are over rated.

[echo630]

oh jeez, when will you all learn,

they were NEVER punk, they are what most of us call, superpop

GET IT!!!!!!!!

a few powerchords is not what makes up a genre, ok!!

That doesn't make sense. Pop = popular. That's it. They weren't some gamour band or anything. the fact that they became a pop band simply meant that they became popular. They were pop punk. Popular punk.

What do you think makes a punk band?

[James Johnson]

This thread annoys me, I hope it hurry up and dies or gets locked.

[BILLY AGE 8]

That doesn't make sense. Pop = popular. That's it. They weren't some gamour band or anything. the fact that they became a pop band simply meant that they became popular. They were pop punk. Popular punk.

What do you think makes a punk band?

ok, first of all pop does not equal popular, it equals pop, a GENRE of music

now, my step brother is the only other person who has said to me what you just said,

everyone else agrees with me that pop is a GENRE, so pop punk is punk with a "poppy" sound

but even according to your logic, how are they pop punk, if they were popular, shouldnt they just be pop,

now, my step bro said to me, that pop punk was just a bunch of bands that everyone THINKS are punk, but ARENT, so even he admitted that they really arent punk

its just that people misunderstand pop punk,

so if they arent punk, they dont deserve the punk name, so they are Super pop, or Power Pop,

Pop = Pop , not popular

jeez your an idiot


and attention to all you who are going to fight against me,

you will not sway me, because this is a forum, and all i need is the reasurance that most of the punk population agrees with ME, and most of the NON PUNK population agrees with ME.

I dont care what the Blink fans think, especially the ones who listen to emo and hardcore, and say that they like a few punk bands and name Blink as their favorite punk band. In fact the a lot of the blink fans agree with ME that they arent punk,

so please SHUT UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

besides compared to most punk bands, in my opinion, blink is not on the top best list,

yes they may have a talented drummer, but put with the rest of the band they sound bad

This thread annoys me, I hope it hurry up and dies or gets locked.

it annoys me too, if you cant tell, its completely gotten off track,

i am sick of declairing blink not punk, and putting up with Panic fans

some one PLEASE SHUT THIS THREAD DOWN

[YouAteMyDog182]

no one is punk ne more...we are all posers....punk music is different to everyone

[OisNOTdead87]

no one is punk ne more...we are all posers....punk music is different to everyone

Dude, if the forum you're from is that "punkdisasters.com" website you're even more of a tool that I thought!

Punk music isn't different to everyone, you just think that because you have no clue what the fuck you're talking about.

[alteridem1]

the vandals, baby

[Carlo Marx]

Bomb the Music Industry.

[echo630]

Well, I kind of asked for an explanation from the hierarch here what his definition on punk is.

[sexpistolsjunki]

what the hell. theres a shittload.

[[sex pistols, yay]]

[OisNOTdead87]

Sex Pistols are also over rated.

[Fiend138]

well depends Punk music has become so big there is horror punk(misfits), *** pag (Green Day), Irsih POUnk (flogging Molly), Punk rock(blink-182) pop punk(The Raomones) and so on and so forth but I gotta say I think it would have to be The Addicts one of the few bands able to keep their original line up for as long as them

[BILLY AGE 8]

i would waste my time, but i now decided to just stop posting in this thread,

so bye bye, crappy thread

this thread should be renamed......

to

hey all the douchbags who think blink is punk, come talk about how they are the greatest! hooray!!



well, i am out of here

[decom_poseur]

well depends Punk music has become so big there is horror punk(misfits), *** pag (Green Day), Irsih POUnk (flogging Molly), Punk rock(blink-182) pop punk(The Raomones) and so on and so forth but I gotta say I think it would have to be The Addicts one of the few bands able to keep their original line up for as long as them

If I were you I'd try harder in school

[AlyssaAsthenia]

i would waste my time, but i now decided to just stop posting in this thread,

so bye bye, crappy thread

this thread should be renamed......

to

hey all the douchbags who think blink is punk, come talk about how they are the greatest! hooray!!



well, i am out of here
blink is the greatest. we should base our whole society around those 3 men. no other bands will be aloud. we will all be naked.

descendents and screeching weasel are the best imo.

[ashmore404]

what do you think the best punk band of all time is?
Boys Like GIRLS!!!! Catchy as hell! http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v649/Ashmore404/SME_0101_WK_676283.jpg

[xwisebuddhax]

best punk band???? Uhhh, punks dead. Just Kidding, id go with

Old:UK Subs
New:Casualties or Cheap Sex

[OisNOTdead87]

best punk band???? Uhhh, punks dead. Just Kidding, id go with

Old:UK Subs
New:Casualties or Cheap Sex


Wrong answer(s).

[Carlo Marx]

I just picked up the Anti-Nowhere League collection. Good stuff.

[Troggy]

as far as things i listen to: descendents, no use for a name, lifetime...

[A7XFOBPATD]

probably Iron Maiden

[rocktometal]

probably Iron Maiden

when did they become punk?

[OisNOTdead87]

when did they become punk?

They didn't, and their singer still sucks too.

[mikeford]

the clash is still the right answer.

[Logan95]

Social Distortion is definitely not getting the respect they deserve on this thread. While I don't believe there is any "best" punk band; in all this bickering I expected to see more support for Mike Ness and the boys.

[kill_witha_bass]

true that

[TheWeakest]

blue album > nevermind.

discuss.

haha yes!

[OisNOTdead87]

Social Distortion is definitely not getting the respect they deserve on this thread. While I don't believe there is any "best" punk band; in all this bickering I expected to see more support for Mike Ness and the boys.

They're really good live (I saw them with Matt Freeman on bass).

[sotheysay91]

i do think social distortion and the descendnts should be up there, also the adolescents and black flag, and defintely bad religion

[nadiapunk]

obvius that is NIRVANA:-p

[OisNOTdead87]

obvius that is NIRVANA:-p

I hate you, go away.

[corrupt_rocker]

Audible "punk rock" - Sex pistols,the clash, Bad Religion, Crimpshrine, Operation Ivy, Rocket from the crypt, anti-flag, the Unseen, Black Flag

Unaudible "punk rock"- Nausea, Toxic Narcotic

I love Nirana but they aren't punk rock. Nirvana is Grunge/ alternative/ rock/ and something else that i cant think of right now. Social D is amazing so i guess they should be up there too

[Czarsy]

I love Nirana but they aren't punk rock. Nirvana is Grunge/ alternative/ rock/ and something else that i cant think of right now. Social D is amazing but their punk not punk rock..make sense? lol i bet it doesnt but..eh
Since when are punk and punk rock different?

[echo630]

i would waste my time, but i now decided to just stop posting in this thread,

so bye bye, crappy thread

this thread should be renamed......

to

hey all the douchbags who think blink is punk, come talk about how they are the greatest! hooray!!



well, i am out of here

Looks like someone has a crappy attitude. Need a hug?

[trancedsailor]

I'm gonna go with Bad Religion. Been around since 1980, have had more political impact/insight than pretty much any other band EVER.

I have never been into the Clash, the Ramones, Black Flag, or any of those bands.

[sotheysay91]

Looks like someone has a crappy attitude. Need a hug?
he doesnt deserve a hug

[corrupt_rocker]

Since when are punk and punk rock different?

See how i said i bet it doesnt make sense? just listen to that part ignore the rest of it.

[OisNOTdead87]

See how i said i bet it doesnt make sense? just listen to that part ignore the rest of it.

We all wish we could ignore you.

[fcknazisympathy]

Crass is the best punk band. Thanks.

[level4loser]

Crass is the best punk band. Thanks.

great, its this guy again

[untamed]

rancid and tha clash:-)

[nofx5675]

there underated but has to be bad brains

[OisNOTdead87]

there underated but has to be bad brains
I really don't think Bad Brains is under rater, nor are they over rated.

They're one of the founding members of hardcore, how in the fuck could you under rate them?

[everiedmndae]

either the clash or the adicts

[MaTtR.LuVr01]

Rise Against is the Best punk band, but Lifetime is also a great punk band tooo.

[level4loser]

Rise Against is the Best punk band, but Lifetime is also a great punk band tooo.

how can you say rise against is better than lifetime while at the same time rocking a taking back sunday avatar?

[decom_poseur]

how can you say rise against is better than lifetime while at the same time rocking a taking back sunday avatar?

haha

[corrupt_rocker]

We all wish we could ignore you.

so why dont you start already

[(+Clark)cLash]

there's no such thing as a best
there are some damn good ones
there should be a point when you realize, no one is going to think the same
my favorite punk band is 1989-2000 green day
but i'm not gonna claim it's the best band in punk

[OisNOTdead87]

so why dont you start already

Are you asking me a question? If so i couldn't tell, there's no question mark in your post.

there's no such thing as a best
there are some damn good ones
there should be a point when you realize, no one is going to think the same
my favorite punk band is 1989-2000 green day
but i'm not gonna claim it's the best band in punk

You better not claim it's the best punk band, because then you'd be wrong.

[MaTtR.LuVr01]

Well Taking Back Sunday is not Punk there EMO duh.

[MaTtR.LuVr01]

it's my opinion who i think is the best punk band.

[sotheysay91]

it's my opinion who i think is the best punk band.
ya even if it sucks

[James Johnson]

http://sword-masters.com/catalog/images/threadlocker.jpg

[emily'smyhomie]

BUT, OF COURS3 TH3 BEST PUNK BAND OF ALL TIME WOULD HAVE TO GR33N DAY. I LOVE THEM! JOE (MY COUSIN) L3T M3 COM3 AND S33 TH3M PLAY ALL THE TIM3! I LOVE HAVIND FAMOUS FAMILY! :-p

[decom_poseur]

BUT, OF COURS3 TH3 BEST PUNK BAND OF ALL TIME WOULD HAVE TO GR33N DAY. I LOVE THEM! JOE (MY COUSIN) L3T M3 COM3 AND S33 TH3M PLAY ALL THE TIM3! I LOVE HAVIND FAMOUS FAMILY! :-p

Fuck I hope this was a joke

[Carlo Marx]

BUT, OF COURS3 TH3 BEST PUNK BAND OF ALL TIME WOULD HAVE TO GR33N DAY. I LOVE THEM! JOE (MY COUSIN) L3T M3 COM3 AND S33 TH3M PLAY ALL THE TIM3! I LOVE HAVIND FAMOUS FAMILY! :-p

do the human race a favor and off yourself.

[Emoboyluver]

The best punk band is Blink182.*

[(+Clark)cLash]

You better not claim it's the best punk band, because then you'd be wrong.
i didn't fucking say they were u fucking idiot

[Girl@TheRockSho]

Blink 182; Ramones & Fall Out Boy

[fcknazisympathy]

Blink 182; Ramones & Fall Out Boy

no

[ethan_9000]

dead kennedys fool

[laxman209]

nah i'll have to be the clash

[decom_poseur]

Blink 182; Ramones & Fall Out Boy

this really upsets me

[exotic36084]

Some of the bands u guys listed , haha, the word pop and the word punk should not even go together!There are a few in my book, The Clash, Ramones, Black Flag(before Rollins), The Damned, and Crass(sucked at playin there instruments) but they got their message across!!

[Carlo Marx]

Some of the bands u guys listed , haha, the word pop and the word punk should not even go together!There are a few in my book, The Clash, Ramones, Black Flag(before Rollins), The Damned, and Crass(sucked at playin there instruments) but they got their message across!!

the damned are fucking brilliant. machine gun etiquette is a (near) perfect album.