Best NFL QB for 09

[saveferris]

Who is this year's best Quarterback in the NFL?

[IcedOpethBlind]

Peyton Manning thus far

2nd and 3rd would be Drew Brees, Eli Manning

[Cameronisonfire]

Peyton Manning thus far

2nd and 3rd would be Drew Brees, Eli Manning

1. Matt Schaub
2. Matt Ryan...
Just kidding, thats just my Texans/fantasy QB bias. You have it right.

[SgtSmegma]

1. Matt Schaub
2. Matt Ryan...
Just kidding, thats just my Texans/fantasy QB bias. You have it right.

In all seriousness, Schaub is up there though. Top 5, I'd say.

[AMackChuck]

Brady has had his struggles but he is starting to get back into his game after getting injured. Really excited for the game against Denver today.

[Srsly]

JaMarcus!!

No, Peyton, Brees then Rodgers.

[crit]

Peyton Manning.

[Killadelphia]

corn on the kolb

[writeacliche]

Jay Cutlah fa shuurrre.

Dahh Bears.

Nah. Honestly I've been most impressed with Brees/Manning.

[LPcatitoRJA]

Phillip Rivers

[writeacliche]

Rivers is unreal. I was watching the Pitt game where they nearly came back.

[Carolina.Alex]

Phillip Rivers. Of course, I am a little biased as a wolfpack fan.

[sleepyseanzzz]

1 peyton manning
2 drew brees
3 eli manning
4 brett favre
5 mark sanchez

best team thus far: giants, colts and saints not far behind

[ActorInThisPlay]

Peyton Manning is the obvious choice here.

[Illuminate]

Hasselbeck - 7 Touchdowns in 2 games! Haha loved him today..

[xbrokendownx]

1 peyton manning
2 drew brees
3 eli manning
4 brett favre
5 mark sanchez

best team thus far: giants, colts and saints not far behind




more INT than TD, 71.2 QB rating.....

[blowmybutthole]

1 peyton manning
2 drew brees
3 eli manning
4 brett favre
5 mark sanchez

best team thus far: giants, colts and saints not far behind

ehh as weird as it sounds i can see where you're coming from but i think you'd have to put aaron rodgers at 5 because he is the most sacked QB in the NFL BUT still has 6 TDs and 1 INT. and thats a tough thing to say since im a Vikes fan

[Mibabalou]

1 peyton manning
2 drew brees
3 eli manning
4 brett favre
5 mark sanchez

best team thus far: giants, colts and saints not far behind

im a huge jets fan but saying mark sanchez is top 5 is nuts

[konstantine008]

1. peyton manning
2. drew brees
3. big ben rothlisberger

[theguy77]

manning, manning, favre, brees, ryan

[dignan]

They call me the Brees! I really wanted him to take that record from Dan Marino.

But I also love Philip Rivers... one of the best college QB's ever. NC State has been shit since he left. and he's from Alabama. he rules.

[the suspence]

1-5. Jake Delhomme

the guy is so good he cant throw it to just his receivers

really though off the top of my head with nothing to back it up: P. Manning, Brees, Brady, Ryan, Rivers

[f00te]

Peyton Manning easily