View Full Version : A Perfect Break Up
Jason Tate
05/19/06, 03:36 PM
A Perfect Circle broke up (http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1531791/20060515/perfect_circle.jhtml?headlines=true ). *Crickets*
fedhed7
05/19/06, 03:41 PM
Lolol.
SLADE775
05/19/06, 03:42 PM
Tool should do the same.
The_New_Cancer
05/19/06, 03:42 PM
Ah, dude... That really sucks. They were one of the few bands that me and my brothers all liked.:(
FeynmanWannabe
05/19/06, 03:47 PM
Ugh That sucks. I really liked APC, too. :aimfrown:
SaturnineMantra
05/19/06, 03:47 PM
1. Old news (for most Tool fans).
2. Tool > APC.
Though Mer de Noms is reaaaallllllyyyyyyyyyyyy good.
but no Lateralus.
the only songs i really ever liked by them were 3 libras and their cover of imagine.
HazeLitRise
05/19/06, 03:57 PM
oh man im gonna miss them
TheHeretic
05/19/06, 04:07 PM
this sucks....
weakerdaysawait
05/19/06, 04:09 PM
Guess that circle wasn't all that perfect.
Burning Star IV
05/19/06, 04:13 PM
even though this news sucks, i've been expecting it for quite some time, with both tool and the smashing pumpkins back again
theESCO
05/19/06, 04:21 PM
Guess that circle wasn't all that perfect.
...nice.
thewebguy
05/19/06, 04:28 PM
i wonder if it has anything to do with the new tool album going gold it's first week
Signals Corrupted
05/19/06, 04:39 PM
they have excellent music
Signals Corrupted
05/19/06, 04:39 PM
i wonder if it has anything to do with the new tool album going gold it's first week
pretty sure their last 2 releases have sold at least 500k as well
thats annoying, always enjoyed APC, probs a bit more than tool, love them both but find APC just bit more easy and nice :P
doesnt say its a definate thing, so lets hope in a couple of years we can have another album :D
EvilButters
05/19/06, 04:50 PM
Man, this sucks. I always liked A Perfect Circle more than Tool. Oh well, I guess I'll have to start listening to more Tool.
ambiotic
05/19/06, 04:55 PM
Maynard said its impossible for A Perfect Circle to exsist in this modern music age, so there was no place for them.. They were basicly just a bunch of muscians making a super group they made their political album and it tanked so they said fuck it .. and Maynard was like oh wait I'm in the greatest band of all time anyways lets go ahead and make the best album of all time in 10,000 days and take our place as music gods...
btw I am a toolhead
UrOwNdISaStR180
05/19/06, 04:58 PM
Three Libras > Every other APC and Tool song
PeteWentzisGay
05/19/06, 05:01 PM
both bands are pretty bad...
Roboman
05/19/06, 05:10 PM
Damnit, that sucks. I think APC is great...a lot more accessible than Tool, who I just can't motivate myself to listen to. Oh well...
ambiotic
05/19/06, 05:13 PM
and taking back sunday songs realy own...
Nate_RAWKS
05/19/06, 05:14 PM
One of the loudest bands i have ever heard in my concert goings years.
I wasn't their biggest fan but they had some good songs on Mer de Noms.
When Tool sells nearly 600,000 albums in it's first week A Perfect Circle is quick to fade out, i guess.
ambiotic
05/19/06, 05:15 PM
Damnit, that sucks. I think APC is great...a lot more accessible than Tool, who I just can't motivate myself to listen to. Oh well...
try getting lifted putting on some headphones in a dark room and listening to 10,000 days all the way till the end, this will help you understand
FinchBulldog2
05/19/06, 05:41 PM
crickets? they're one of the bands that does rock correctly nowadays.
IcedOpethBlind
05/19/06, 05:52 PM
A Perfect Circle broke up (http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1531791/20060515/perfect_circle.jhtml?headlines=true ). *Crickets*
a better band than The Format...
sad to see, but atleast TOOL is still going strong...
romantic rights
05/19/06, 05:53 PM
Maynard said its impossible for A Perfect Circle to exsist in this modern music age, so there was no place for them.. They were basicly just a bunch of muscians making a super group they made their political album and it tanked so they said fuck it .. and Maynard was like oh wait I'm in the greatest band of all time anyways lets go ahead and make the best album of all time in 10,000 days and take our place as music gods...
btw I am a toolhead
But he's not in The Clash....
IcedOpethBlind
05/19/06, 05:53 PM
crickets? they're one of the bands that does rock correctly nowadays.
yeah, one of the better more "mainstream" rock acts...
i think jason just wanted to get back to masturbating with his format cds...
FinchBulldog2
05/19/06, 05:55 PM
yeah, one of the better more "mainstream" rock acts...
i think jason just wanted to get back to masturbating with his format cds...
hahaha
IcedOpethBlind
05/19/06, 05:55 PM
Tool should do the same.
no.
IamTheINDUSTRY
05/19/06, 06:02 PM
Tool should do the same.
you are such a stupid bitch.
clintdaddy
05/19/06, 06:03 PM
you are such a stupid bitch.
LOL
That sucks reallly bad but...
Tool >>> APC.
As long as Tool doesn't break up I won't cry.
selftitled85
05/19/06, 06:20 PM
perfect circle was better musically and lyrically than 95% of the bands talked about here.
anthony_jr
05/19/06, 06:27 PM
=] =x
lewisonfire
05/19/06, 06:34 PM
perfect circle was better musically and lyrically than 95% of the bands talked about here.
WORD
they shouldnt break up....how about they just release a new cd in five years..
I really liked Mer De Noms
travisev
05/19/06, 06:52 PM
old news.
lets hope for a breakup trend to start in shitty pop punk starting with cartel.
ambiotic
05/19/06, 07:08 PM
old news.
lets hope for a breakup trend to start in shitty pop punk starting with cartel.
I second that
IamTheINDUSTRY
05/19/06, 07:17 PM
yeah tate. their no cartel...and they definitely didnt possess half the talent of sherwood........haha
Nolessthanblink
05/19/06, 07:52 PM
yeah tate. their no cartel...and they definitely didnt possess half the talent of sherwood........haha
And you're definately no spelling whiz... dumbass. Cartel's awesome...
Cartel> Tool OR APC...
Hell...
BASICALLY ANY BAND>Tool or APC
Signals Corrupted
05/19/06, 07:53 PM
And you're definately no spelling whiz... dumbass. Cartel's awesome...
Cartel> Tool OR APC...
Hell...
BASICALLY ANY BAND>Tool or APC
hahahahahahahaahha
i declare this man the perfect example of "stupidity"
Nolessthanblink
05/19/06, 08:02 PM
hahahahahahahaahha
i declare this man the perfect example of "stupidity"
You call me stupid, and yet you still can't use proper grammar or spelling... *shakes head*
Loch_Doun
05/19/06, 08:09 PM
Does this mean James Iha will be joining the Smashing Pumpkins?
hmmmmmmmmm...
GoTHErelentless
05/19/06, 08:11 PM
damn. suckage.
zizou1790
05/19/06, 08:12 PM
Tool should do the same.
hahahaha amen.
dontgrabtindy
05/19/06, 08:12 PM
oh well
...nice.
...it really wasn't.
cavein86
05/19/06, 09:26 PM
very awesome band...damnit
The Revisionist
05/19/06, 09:39 PM
You call me stupid, and yet you still can't use proper grammar or spelling... *shakes head*He didn't misspell anything.
ishotthepilot
05/19/06, 09:44 PM
shouldve broken up after the first album. it was pristine.
weworemasks
05/19/06, 09:58 PM
But he's not in The Clash....
good observation?
And you're definately no spelling whiz... dumbass. Cartel's awesome...
Cartel> Tool OR APC...
Hell...
BASICALLY ANY BAND>Tool or APC
hahahaha holy fucking shit. wow, oh my god.
seriously?
wow.
ryanisarealboy
05/19/06, 10:06 PM
fuck them they sucked anyways ha
IamTheINDUSTRY
05/19/06, 11:02 PM
And you're definately no spelling whiz... dumbass. Cartel's awesome...
Cartel> Tool OR APC...
Hell...
BASICALLY ANY BAND>Tool or APC
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhahahaha. spelling wiz how so?
FinchBulldog2
05/19/06, 11:50 PM
And you're definately no spelling whiz... dumbass. Cartel's awesome...
Cartel> Tool OR APC...
Hell...
BASICALLY ANY BAND>Tool or APC
Everybody stop laughing at the retarded kid.
FinchBulldog2
05/19/06, 11:52 PM
fuck them they sucked anyways ha
5 posts is too much. Just stop, son.
Manbotisdead
05/20/06, 05:53 AM
A Perfect Circle broke up (http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1531791/20060515/perfect_circle.jhtml?headlines=true ). *Crickets*
I for one am kind of upset. Maynard has great voice, and probably influenced a few of the bands that are frequented on here.
Especially the recent outcropping of screaming singing combo bands.
Manbotisdead
05/20/06, 08:06 AM
shouldve broken up after the first album. it was pristine.
I really liked 13th step too, they just shouldn't have done emotive.
sensesfail18782
05/20/06, 08:53 AM
My fave part is how all the tool-heads talk shit on Cartel and these other bands just out of the blue, and then they get pissed off because people defend their taste in music.
It all works both ways. Some people don't like Tool or APC, simple as that. That is THEIR opinion. Same goes for people who don't like Cartel and Fall Out Boy. Once again, their opinion.
Although I do think it's kinda pointless to go into a thread about a band breaking up and talking shit about them and saying how you never listened to them or whatever. How is that adding to the conversation?
And yes I realize I'm not making things any better, but this doesn't need to turn into a flame war about Cartel or any other band when it's a thread about APC breaking up.
Broken4EverMore
05/20/06, 08:59 AM
My fave part is how all the tool-heads talk shit on Cartel and these other bands just out of the blue, and then they get pissed off because people defend their taste in music.
It all works both ways. Some people don't like Tool or APC, simple as that. That is THEIR opinion. Same goes for people who don't like Cartel and Fall Out Boy. Once again, their opinion.
Although I do think it's kinda pointless to go into a thread about a band breaking up and talking shit about them and saying how you never listened to them or whatever. How is that adding to the conversation?
And yes I realize I'm not making things any better, but this doesn't need to turn into a flame war about Cartel or any other band when it's a thread about APC breaking up.
Well put... I was going to post something along the same lines. :)
as long as tool keeps going strong, it's all good. apc was good, but no tool.
lazer85
05/20/06, 11:36 AM
thats annoying, always enjoyed APC, probs a bit more than tool, love them both but find APC just bit more easy and nice :P
doesnt say its a definate thing, so lets hope in a couple of years we can have another album :D
I agree, Tool is great, but it's nice to hear Maynard stray from that Tool sound even if it isn't that far of a stray. Also APC is one of the only famous bands I can think of that actually picked some of it's best songs as singles. That's not to say the other songs weren't great as well.
lazer85
05/20/06, 11:52 AM
Although I do think it's kinda pointless to go into a thread about a band breaking up and talking shit about them and saying how you never listened to them or whatever. How is that adding to the conversation?
I agree. I come here cause its the best for news on Rx bandits, steel train, TSOAF, DEP, Head automatica, coheed, 3, it also has some big bands like APC/Tool, Muse,Foo Fighters, NIN, and Radiohead, some indie-scene bands like Of Montreal, Dresdon Dolls, Sufjan Stevens, a few other bands and for some of the RIAA news. Also it's cool to see what some bands I used to listen to (NOFX, Thrice, Saves the Day etc.) are doing.
I can be ridiculously critical of ALOT of bands discussed here, but I'm not going to reply to a panic at the disco or early november post to say they suck, regardless of whether i dislike them or not. That's just kind of adding something negative for no reason.
travisev
05/20/06, 11:55 AM
And yes I realize I'm not making things any better, but this doesn't need to turn into a flame war about Cartel or any other band when it's a thread about APC breaking up.
there should be atleast one post in every thread just briefly mentioning how shitty cartel is.
sensesfail18782
05/20/06, 01:48 PM
I agree. I come here cause its the best for news on Rx bandits, steel train, TSOAF, DEP, Head automatica, coheed, 3, it also has some big bands like APC/Tool, Muse,Foo Fighters, NIN, and Radiohead, some indie-scene bands like Of Montreal, Dresdon Dolls, Sufjan Stevens, a few other bands and for some of the RIAA news. Also it's cool to see what some bands I used to listen to (NOFX, Thrice, Saves the Day etc.) are doing.
I can be ridiculously critical of ALOT of bands discussed here, but I'm not going to reply to a panic at the disco or early november post to say they suck, regardless of whether i dislike them or not. That's just kind of adding something negative for no reason.
I understand. There's a lot of bands covered here that I don't really care much for either...but it almost seems loser-ish to actually go into a thread just to say that a band sucks. I dunno maybe it's just me. Wow a Butch Walker line, will I be verbally raped for that one in this thread? ;)
And I get what you mean about seeing what the old bands are up to as well. I used to be obsessed with Offspring and AFI until I burnt myself out on them, so it's cool to see what they're up to on here without actually having to take the effort to go to their different websites to find out.
.KillMoneen.
05/20/06, 02:50 PM
How is it even possible to say either of these bands are bad. Seriously anyone with any music sense would atleast respect these bands. Tool are some of the bes musicians out there. No one can beat the drumming, no one.
fakeplasticlove
05/20/06, 04:10 PM
This is kinda sad news. But of course, I do get to see two APC members (Josh Freese and Jeordie White) soon for the fourth and fifth time when I see NIN this summer. Yay!
Broken4EverMore
05/20/06, 06:35 PM
there should be atleast one post in every thread just briefly mentioning how shitty cartel is.
Or there should be one post in every thread mentioning that Will has a better voice than almost any other vocalist mentioned on this site....
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.