View Full Version : Best Fincher Film?
Nick Hull
10/27/09, 07:16 PM
My favorite director of the modern era. Just wondering what other people favored.
x1onexwo1fx
10/27/09, 09:34 PM
good poll. not as hard as i thought it would be, though. panic room is average, benjamin button was a bit overhyped, and i haven't seen the game and zodiac. fight club wins it by a tiny bit for me, even though se7en is infinitely better than the saw series and almost as good as silence of the lambs. gotta go with what i always considered to be the cult classic.
SkateFirm21
10/27/09, 10:54 PM
any movie with brad pitt is good.
DeadCityScars
10/27/09, 11:34 PM
He has a great resume, not doubt about that...
I enjoyed all those movies but I had to pick Fight Club. I was quoting that movie for about a year.
in a small way I still live by that movie. I wanted to be Edward Norton's character.
any movie with brad pitt is good.
he's been in some crap too. and not just when he started... more recent
edit: also, i picked zodiac because i think it shows his talent/style the best as well as being an interesting story with great actors.
fourletterword
10/28/09, 08:43 AM
fight club
Nerdy91
10/28/09, 09:18 AM
Fight Club is the best
newfoundmichael
10/28/09, 12:44 PM
This won't even be close.
x13looDx
10/28/09, 01:45 PM
fight club, though i loved benjamin button and se7en, zodiac was boring.. haven't seen the panic room or the game
fight club, though i loved benjamin button and se7en, zodiac was boring.. haven't seen the panic room or the game
how was zodiac boring? it was incredible.
it was a true story with great actors and a very interesting story.
LastDeclaration
10/28/09, 02:40 PM
Fight Club. But Se7en was close. Brad Pitt is fucking great.
Debut_Fin
10/28/09, 06:12 PM
how was zodiac boring? it was incredible.
it was a true story with great actors and a very interesting story.
i also thought zodiac was boring
granted i watched it on an airplane and i was fucking exhausted
it's been on my list to see it again for a while now. i just don't really have any strong desire to
jbaseball44
10/28/09, 06:25 PM
Zodiac's the best movie, though Fight Club is clearly going to win
kbi the crowing
10/28/09, 06:32 PM
I can't really have a great opinion on this cuz I've only seen half of em, they're all great, but Fight Club was done the best out of all the one's I have seen.
Nick Hull
10/28/09, 07:01 PM
good poll. not as hard as i thought it would be, though. panic room is average, benjamin button was a bit overhyped, and i haven't seen the game and zodiac. fight club wins it by a tiny bit for me, even though se7en is infinitely better than the saw series and almost as good as silence of the lambs. gotta go with what i always considered to be the cult classic.
Highly recommend watching the Game. By far the most shocking ending I've ever seen.
Se7en is far and away the best here. Fight Club was just the most popular
Se7en is far and away the best here. Fight Club was just the most popular
i agree fight club is the most popular, but i would put se7en just behind zodiac still. both incredible movies though.
xjulianx89
10/29/09, 04:51 PM
Zodiac, and it's not even close.
Kevin Lazaroff
10/29/09, 07:40 PM
is that even a question... Panic Room!!! <-- -_- haha, no but its obviously Fight Club!
jwicklun
10/30/09, 12:07 AM
just saw zodiac, great movie. but I went with seven.
wuduprod
10/30/09, 09:49 AM
Ben Button ftw.
blue_bedlight
10/31/09, 01:39 PM
any movie with brad pitt is good.
Like I've always said, I have yet to see a bad Brad Pitt movie.
blue_bedlight
10/31/09, 01:40 PM
Fight Club. I absolutely loved it. Se7en is definitely tied with it though. I'm pretty sure I've watched both just as many times.
threepunchjim
10/31/09, 07:10 PM
good poll. not as hard as i thought it would be, though. panic room is average, benjamin button was a bit overhyped, and i haven't seen the game and zodiac. fight club wins it by a tiny bit for me, even though se7en is infinitely better than the saw series and almost as good as silence of the lambs. gotta go with what i always considered to be the cult classic.
Go watch The Game. It's really quite an incredible movie.
threepunchjim
10/31/09, 07:15 PM
Highly recommend watching the Game. By far the most shocking ending I've ever seen.
word.
abandonship
10/31/09, 11:31 PM
from what i've seen fight club > se7en >>>>>>> benjamin button
Alexx Miller
11/01/09, 12:50 PM
I love them all, but I would say Se7en and Fight Club are his best.
I went with Se7en.
KevBlu42
11/03/09, 10:50 PM
I would rank them like this:
Zodiac
Se7en
Fight Club
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
The Game
Panic Room
domotime2
11/03/09, 10:56 PM
all of these are great films.
zodiac, not so much.
notoaststereo
11/05/09, 08:47 PM
def a hard poll. i think zodiac is his best/most well made film:
Zodiac
Seven
Fight Club
The Game
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Panic Room
Alien 3
Ari Christos
11/07/09, 02:37 PM
Seven and Zodiac are better than Fight Club I think, but all three are great. I voted Seven.
CollectiveConfusion
11/08/09, 11:25 AM
se7en barreellly edges out fight club
FUCKDIRTYWIPES
11/08/09, 08:32 PM
se7en
cant decide between se7en, zodiac, and benjamin button...
ahh damn. benjamin button it is. of course fight club is gonna win :rolleyes:
i_was_a_lid
11/09/09, 08:45 AM
What about Alien 3? I still say Fight Club
Benjamin Button was such garbage
Oy, definitely not the Panic Room. That movie was awful. (I blame Kristen Stewart)
I can't vote fairly since the only others I've seen on that list are Benjamin Button and Fight Club... but Fight Club changed my life and is one of the best movies I'm convinced I will ever see, so I went with that.
Zodiac. Cool topic and very chilling. Fight Club is pretty good. Se7en is good. Panic Room blows the big one, and Benjamin Button does not compete with the others.
Oy, definitely not the Panic Room. That movie was awful. (I blame Kristen Stewart)
I can't vote fairly since the only others I've seen on that list are Benjamin Button and Fight Club... but Fight Club changed my life and is one of the best movies I'm convinced I will ever see, so I went with that.
how could Fight Club change your life?
how could Fight Club change your life?
Met my boyfriend through a mutual love for that movie :-)
Met my boyfriend through a mutual love for that movie :-)
oh okay, i thought the you meant like some crazy philosophical moment or something.
xjulianx89
11/13/09, 08:04 AM
I can't believe Zodiac is in last. Fight Club has to be his most overrated work - and one of the most overrated films, period.
Radiology
11/13/09, 08:16 PM
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a masterpiece in my eyes, it's absolutely beautiful and transcends the story that is being told.
Though Fincher can do no wrong in my eyes, he is for sure the best "up-in-coming" director. maybe the next Spielberg (he sure has that visual "magic" of Spielberg)
but after Benjamin Button I'd say Fight Club, then Se7en, then Zodiac.
I can't believe Zodiac is in last. Fight Club has to be his most overrated work - and one of the most overrated films, period.
agreed so much.
kdefrisc
11/13/09, 08:57 PM
Yeah I've seen all of these, but I think Fight Club is still my favorite. Followed very closely by Seven and The Game. Had my prom in that big gold room in the last scene of The Game
miketheauthor
11/17/09, 09:14 AM
Never seen fight club. talk some shit haha. I do want to see it though.
Never seen fight club. talk some shit haha. I do want to see it though.
it's worth watching, but not as good as everyone makes it out to be.
i mean, it's great, it really is... but fincher's best movie? no way.
MilesToGo
11/17/09, 11:12 AM
It was tough between Fight Club, Se7en, and The Game. I voted more on a personal basis, because I couldn't choose.
Never seen Zodiac, but after reading what people have said, I want to!
Can't believe votes for The Game are so low though. That movie really is fantastic.
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.