direction or the red tree

[nolan182]

SOooooooooo hard to decide, but I might have to say The Red Tree

[muttley]

Direction.

[yourprivateeye]

red tree by farrrrrr. direction has like 4 songs i enjoy on it.

moneen > tsl, in every possible way.

[nolan182]

red tree by farrrrrr. direction has like 4 songs i enjoy on it.

moneen > tsl, in every possible way.
yeah well for me they're almost tied, but I like moneen more. TSL will probably win this poll only because half the people voting have probably never even listened to moneen. haha oh well.

[fourletterword]

direction

[nolan182]

Haha this thread makes The Red Tree look horrible even though it's one of the greatest records of all time.

My album of the year for 06. Direction was my album of 07 i think haha.

[TSLROCKS]

Direction but I do love The Red Tree

[HometownHero]

Direction with no question. And I love The Red Tree

[dpetty21]

Can't really get into Red Tree too much. So for me it's Direction by far.

[kazuma_ootaro28]

moneen destroys The Starting Line, although Direction has what I think might be TSL's best song.

[Absolut_Punk]

Maybe I'm weird, but I just cannot get into Moneen, but Direction is a great album nonetheless.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Direction

[WhoSaidThat?]

Direction. I can't wait for someone to bitch about "Stupid AP kids".

[lesto17]

I absolutely love both bands and albums, but I have to go with "The Red Tree" on this one.

[blinkme]

The Red Tree > Direction

TSL > .moneen.

[jeremypeele]

I saw moneen on warped tour one year, it was painful.

[LastDeclaration]

Direction is the better album, and yes, I've listened to The Red Tree a lot. I think it's pretty overrated, honestly. A lot of the songs drag.

[patrickhowell]

The Red Tree is a great album, more cohesive than Direction

But I like Direction better overall... And I like The Starting Line better overall too.

[introduction]

i think red tree is the better album, but i love tsl.

[jordalsh]

"I Built a Raft and got carried away"

[radxbandit]

Picked Direction, but damn Red Tree is still a great record. Congrats on making a tough poll!

[DCFCutie]

Direction no doubt.

The Starting Line's best album.

[sarahmaes]

please, The Red Tree ! Direction was good, but it doesn't hit as hard.

[gergs]

The Red Tree

Honestly people are voting for Direction? It had a few good songs at best.

[x1onexwo1fx]

The Red Tree

Honestly people are voting for Direction? It had a few good songs at best.

says the guy who only heard it about five times.

...that would be me, of course.

but i never listened to moneen, so can't really vote.

[patrickhowell]

The Red Tree

Honestly people are voting for Direction? It had a few good songs at best.

Which ones ?

[SuNDaYSTaR]

yeah well for me they're almost tied, but I like moneen more. TSL will probably win this poll only because half the people voting have probably never even listened to moneen. haha oh well.This.

[Heroin Robot]

MONEEN > TSL

fuckin easy

[Ryzenfall]

Direction hands down.

[Clark]

I don't understand the amount of love for The Starting Line on AP.net. I like them, but they were nothing special.

Moneen's masterpiece The Red Tree easily gets my vote.

[Kurt Retenauer]

I love both, but went with The Red Tree knowing it'd need help.

[LessThan3]

TSL. No contest. Duh.

[Indoor Living]

moneen destroys The Starting Line, although Direction has what I think might be TSL's best song.
Which is?

My vote's for Direction but I do love them both.

[kazuma_ootaro28]

Which is?
"Island", which is probably the only song of theirs I found to be enjoyable. Though really, I'm not a fan of The Starting Line.

[Indoor Living]

"Island", which is probably the only song of theirs I found to be enjoyable. Though really, I'm not a fan of The Starting Line.
Island is one of their better songs, but I am a huge fan. Is it the pop-punk in general that turns you away, or why don't you like them?

[Formatfun]

The Starting Line, love them too much to vote against.

[JGood4]

direction