View Full Version : Cartel Is My Wonderwall
Frank Giaramita
05/30/06, 12:23 PM
Check out a live video on YouTube.com (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H50D04mCMCI) of Cartel (www.cartelrocks.cm)'s acoustic cover of "Wonderwall" from their all-acoustic show in Orlando, FL.
Ryan Imhof
05/30/06, 12:33 PM
Too bad it's delayed but still, wow he definitly has one of the best live voices.
Take Heart
05/30/06, 12:36 PM
I will never forgive myself for missing this show
kissible&quiet
05/30/06, 12:36 PM
they almost played it the other night after several people requested it, but changed their minds.
GreenJellyBean
05/30/06, 12:39 PM
oh my god. amazing. just..wow.
Am I the only one who thinks it was cringe worthy?
I want to watch this so bad... fucking work.
12:46AM
05/30/06, 01:08 PM
Am I the only one who thinks it was cringe worthy?nope.
Jourdan
05/30/06, 01:18 PM
they almost played it the other night after several people requested it, but changed their minds.
they played it for the first time live a week from today in huntington, wv.
it was damn good, too.
joeshmoe909
05/30/06, 01:21 PM
Amazing.
china white
05/30/06, 01:23 PM
Ryan Adams does this so much better, prettttty much
jtrocka182
05/30/06, 01:29 PM
Will Pugh has probably one of the best live voices ever.
iihungrieii
05/30/06, 01:34 PM
Will Pugh has probably one of the best live voices ever.
i definitely agree, i remember seeing htem for the first time awhile back, and the performance was amazing
Frank Giaramita
05/30/06, 01:35 PM
Ryan Adams does this so much better, prettttty much
How can you even attempt to compare Ryan Adams to Cartel? The two versions of the song are completely opposite of one another.
PaintTheTarget
05/30/06, 01:44 PM
This is a great cover of the song--sure its not too different than the original, but his voice is amazing, when he holds those high notes its gives me chills. Can't wait to see them on Warped.
And you really can't compare the Ryan Adams version to this, as the tone is far different. Cartel's version is a little more upbeat while Adams' is a very somber, slow cover. Both are amazing--I'll leave it at that.
china white
05/30/06, 01:45 PM
How can you even attempt to compare Ryan Adams to Cartel? The two versions of the song are completely opposite of one another.
Well they both cover the song, I guess that's the only comparison, I didn't mean to start a fuss about anything though, I was just adding my opinion
suburbn_thrills
05/30/06, 02:17 PM
This cover's really grown on me. They did a good job.
I want to see Cartel acoustic.
Meh I think covering Oasis is blasphemy... lol... but Ryan Adams did a great job. I don't like Cartel too much, but go ahead and shoot me. Props to them though and I wish them success.
Johnny Confirm
05/30/06, 03:04 PM
..
whipcream4teen
05/30/06, 03:14 PM
When they played it, I got chills. Much better live than on CD.
irthesteve
05/30/06, 03:38 PM
i want to see the rest of the acoustic set...
losethegirl
05/30/06, 03:51 PM
I loved it. The Gallaghers would piss on a lot of things, doesn't mean they're not good.
Curt Phillips
05/30/06, 04:00 PM
Seriously!:blink: You tube has everything! I love it!
piaffeprncess98
05/30/06, 05:26 PM
Hell yes, I'm going to watch it right now.
AShannon04
05/30/06, 07:38 PM
even though Cartel is one of my favorite bands, I'm not a huge fan of this cover. Maybe that's just because the original is one of the best group/drunk sing-along songs ever in my opinion.
EDIT: alright, I kinda take that back. I just watched the video and it's a lot better than the recorded version. Not as good as Oasis, but pretty damn good
sensesfail18782
05/31/06, 06:02 AM
This is okay.
It definitely gets better near the end when he starts singing with passion...
Up until he starts hitting hte high notes, it was very bland to me. This song is just one of my favorite songs of all time and it seemed like Will wasn't being passionate about it at all...but the last half of the song more than makes up for it.
I still get chills hearing the original though. Takes me back to 8th grade all over again...hard to believe it's already been 10+ years...friggin' insane...
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.