=w=

[vincent182]

I thought Red was so bad, that Raditude wins it for me.

[BozzBlonde]

Raditude lost it for me after having Lil Wayne as a guest. With or without him, I still thought the album was weak.

[gnp8472]

how is Red winning this?! red is a miserable, poor excuse for an album, and RADITUDE is a return to form. it's brilliant

[Kurt Retenauer]

I don't know if I'd say "brilliant" or "return to form," but Raditude has a lot more to offer than Red in my eyes. Most of Red sounded like unreleased tracks or b-sides, and I wasn't particularly liking the rotating microphone. Majority of the songs sounded awkward and lacked flow from one to the next. Not to say that Raditude doesn't suffer from that same problem, just not as badly. A lot of the songs on Raditude are awkward in how they flow from one to the next in terms of a cohesive album, but I feel like looking at each song individually, Raditude has a couple better songs that Red's missing.

[threepunchjim]

"Angel and the One." That alone makes Red the clear winner.

[Posthardcore]

neither

[Formatfun]

I like Raditude, but The Red Album sounds better as a whole to me.

[ryanhorizons]

they both kinda suck

[TheWeakest]

As of now, i believe red is better. The weakest part of red is how river's didn't contribute vocals on a few tracks. it's his job.

[notfallingapart]

They are both pretty bad, but Raditude has '(If You're Wondering If I Want You To) I Want You To' so I'll just have to go with Raditude.

[PopPunkKid]

Red was just such a non-Weezer album imo. It had absolutely no flow whatsoever. Sure, it had some decent tracks (namely the first 3 songs), but overall I was totally unsatisfied with Red.

Raditude, on the other hand, is great. The only songs I'm not a fan of on Raditude are "Love is The Answer" and "In The Mall", which can easily be replaced with the great B-Sides "The Prettiest Girl..." and "Run Over By a Truck".

[Rogers]

Red Album is alright.
Raditude is fucking terrible.

[HometownHero]

Both are fucking trash

[Indoor Living]

Pinkerton.

[drawndead]

i havent heard ratitude yet but red was terrible so i guess anything is better?

[a morning view]

The Blue Album

[VIVALAMATT]

God, am I one of the few that gave The Red Album a good review?

Haven't heard Raditude so I'll hold my opinion until then.

Hey, FYI, the Red Album is not the worst Weezer album. There are plenty of good songs on there.

[vincent182]

God, am I one of the few that gave The Red Album a good review?

Haven't heard Raditude so I'll hold my opinion until then.

Hey, FYI, the Red Album is not the worst Weezer album. There are plenty of good songs on there.


The first three songs on Red are good, then it all collapses...

Pinkerton > Blue >> Maladroit > Green >>> Make Believe > Ratitude > Red

[PopPunkKid]

For me:


Pinkerton = Blue > Raditude > Make Believe > Maladroit > The Green Album > The Red Album