Cake or Pie?

[Peacemaker]

Pie is weird.

[Deadbolt23]

Pie is warm.

[Parabola1124]

Pie is superior.

[Oddpac87]

Was this inspired by Rooster Teeth? If so, well done, sir.

EDIT: Cake, by the way, by a long shot.

[Peacemaker]

Was this inspired by Rooster Teeth? If so, well done, sir.

EDIT: Cake, by the way, by a long shot.

Half-way inspired. Also, GameSpot had a big ordeal about Cake vs. Pie a few years back.

[Nick Hull]

Cake. The only Pie I like is Pudding flavored.

[Oddpac87]

Close enough for me to post these then:

http://images.roosterteeth.com/images/groupad61ab143223efbc24c7d2583be692 5148f022900a4df.jpg
http://images.roosterteeth.com/assets/media/9_4559e7533717d.jpg
http://images.roosterteeth.com/assets/media/9_45b8d24d56362.jpg

[kdefrisc]

death

[Peacemaker]

Close enough for me to post these then:

http://images.roosterteeth.com/images/groupad61ab143223efbc24c7d2583be692 5148f022900a4df.jpg
http://images.roosterteeth.com/assets/media/9_4559e7533717d.jpg
http://images.roosterteeth.com/assets/media/9_45b8d24d56362.jpg

LOL that's fucking great.
"The Most Divisive Issue of Our Times."

[x1onexwo1fx]

death

came in here to say that.

[LamarVannoy]

Pie

[MADSTA]

Now I want some cake.

[seraph1214]

Sad that cake is winning this poll. Come on people!

[phil19]

give me meat pie anyday.
this would have been more of a tough choice is the other option was cupcakes

[pennie]

Cake inside a pie is where it's at

[BozzBlonde]

Pie.
I could never get into cake. Unless it was a cookie cake.

[elz125]

pie, easily. i'm not a fan of icing.

[SuNDaYSTaR]

Cake anytime. I don't like pie except for lemon.

[DanTGD]

pAOLOGGftTY

[mjr20]

cake is a lie..

[spansen]

cake.
i'm surprised that this is even moderately close.

[MilesToGo]

cake for sure. Especially if it is in cupcake form. Mmm.

[Croggs]

Ice cream cake is supreme.

[roche]

Pie is soo much better than cake.

[undecidedshrub]

Cake.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Depends on the kind, but I guess in general I prefer cake.

[Peacemaker]

Depends on the kind, but I guess in general I prefer cake.

Your favorite cake vs. Your favorite pie

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Your favorite cake vs. Your favorite pie
Ice cream cake (that counts, right? it's shaped like a cake even though it has no real cake ingredients) vs. Chocolate cream pie is no easy decision, but cake takes the... cake.

[Peacemaker]

Ice cream cake (that counts, right? it's shaped like a cake even though it has no real cake ingredients) vs. Chocolate cream pie is no easy decision, but cake takes the... cake.
Good choice, meine bruder.

Too bad it ends up looking like this at the end of the night.http://img262.imageshack.us/img262/5387/photoog.jpg

[Kozzy333]

Cake, pie is a close second however.

[Brand-new-123]

My favorite desert is pumpkin pie so pie gets my vote.

[gypsydavey]

this is messed up pie is so much better, can you eat cake with cheese i dont think so!

[uninspired_]

cheesecake...?

[Sasha Fierce]

this is messed up pie is so much better, can you eat cake with cheese i dont think so!


ummm..........yeah, you can. It's called CHEESECAKE lol

[Sasha Fierce]

Cake is superior because it usually has frosting :)

If it's chocolate cake with chocolate frosting...then it's pretty much superior to all other foods

[tonighttonight0]

Cake

[runningohfive]

This is difficult, I like them both.

[grimis16]

bad pies outweigh good pies. Thats why i pick cake

[Poochemist]

Depends on the kind. I don't like crusty-topped pies like the traditional apple or cherry. But I love coconut cream pie, and I enjoy key lime pie.

Where does cheesecake fit in? It's more like a pie, but cake is in the name.

[Peacemaker]

Pie is pulling ahead!!

[EastCoastKid]

Hardest poll of my life.

[andthetruthwill]

Pies always feel like they are going to fall apart, as least cakes generally stick together.

[Deadbolt01]

Depends what kind of cake and what kind of pie, but overall, I say pie.

[Tristan Needler]

Shitty cake is better than shitty pie, but awesome pie is better than awesome cake, on average.

[Oddpac87]

http://sale.images.woot.com/Cake_or_Pi_phgDetail.png

Now what?

[kbi the crowing]

a mediocre pie tastes way better than a mediocre cake

pie

[MattADALIE]

Oh, come on! The pie is your heart.

[And Hours Pass]

Cake inside a pie is where it's at

This idea intrigues me to no end. Does it actually exist?

Pie is superior.

Yes, yes it is.

Ice cream cake is supreme.

Ok, are we counting ice cream cake as cake? Because it's really ice cream... like would we be counting something like meat pie or shephard's pie in the pie category? I feel like we should clear up what's in and out of scope in this.

Shitty cake is better than shitty pie, but awesome pie is better than awesome cake, on average.

This is such a true statement that I've never really thought about...

Oh, come on! The pie is your heart.

Not sure what this means, but I like it.

[spunkmastaflex]

Pie in a heartbeat, especially blueberry

[Poe-tryGirl]

Pie, I love pie.

[MattADALIE]

This idea intrigues me to no end. Does it actually exist?



Yes, yes it is.



Ok, are we counting ice cream cake as cake? Because it's really ice cream... like would we be counting something like meat pie or shephard's pie in the pie category? I feel like we should clear up what's in and out of scope in this.



This is such a true statement that I've never really thought about...



Not sure what this means, but I like it.

Thanks... hahahaha. If you ever saw that episode of The Simpsons where Ron Howard, Alec Baldwin, and Kim Basinger come into the picture, you'll know where I got it. At the end, Homer pitched a movie script to Ron Howard that was only twelve pages long and it involved robots from outer space (from what I can remember) and a friggin' talking pie. Ron Howard actually liked the idea and tried telling the executive, "The pie is your heart." It has stuck with me for the past ten years or so.

EDIT: I totally messed up the quote (mine's not even included), but, I'm sure you'll get my response.

[And Hours Pass]

Thanks... hahahaha. If you ever saw that episode of The Simpsons where Ron Howard, Alec Baldwin, and Kim Basinger come into the picture, you'll know where I got it. At the end, Homer pitched a movie script to Ron Howard that was only twelve pages long and it involved robots from outer space (from what I can remember) and a friggin' talking pie. Ron Howard actually liked the idea and tried telling the executive, "The pie is your heart." It has stuck with me for the past ten years or so.

EDIT: I totally messed up the quote (mine's not even included), but, I'm sure you'll get my response.
Ha, that's awesome. I need to see that episode. The funny thing about the Simpsons is when you hear things like "Ron Howard, Alec Baldwin, and Kim Basinger come into the picture," you know it was actually those actors and that's awesome.

[WhoSaidThat?]

This is more entertaining than any other "Brand New vs. _________ poll"

Oh yeah, uh, pie.

[etheritcher]

when was the last time you had a birthday pie? does a pie ever tell you happy birthday or graduation or congrats on the baby? no!

[ElephantGun]

Depends what kind of cake and pie

[Theseventhson]

Pie ftw!

[warstory]

Pieeee. Cake is kind of boring

[Peacemaker]

Ice cream is a cake! So is cheesecake!

[phil19]

i went to get a jesters pie for lunch the other day only to find out the jesters store near my work had closed. i was devo'd

[Feenucks]

Is cheesecake considered a "pie" or a "cake"?

I can't vote without knowing... =/