Daisy or New Again? [Archive]

Spewk

01/18/10, 08:31 AM

To be honest, I haven't listened to very much on either, but this seemed like a good poll.

Brand-new-123

01/18/10, 09:24 AM

Not a fan of either, but at least Daisy had a couple enjoyable songs.

domotime2

01/18/10, 10:15 AM

i fall asleep to daisy and i turn off new again.

xsinkshipsx

01/18/10, 10:29 AM

new again and daisy were on my top of 09......daisy: number 8 new again: number 3

mike'smannequin

01/18/10, 10:31 AM

neither

vincent182

01/18/10, 11:58 AM

Daisy by far!

InvisibleImage

01/18/10, 12:50 PM

not a good poll at all.

tonyC4L

01/18/10, 03:10 PM

It's a good poll if you like seeing landslide victories

mjr20

01/18/10, 03:18 PM

Daisy. new again is a piece of shit.

jordalsh

01/18/10, 03:41 PM

don't get me wrong, I like New Again, but Daisy is just a better album IMO. Overall however, I like Taking Back Sunday better than Brand New

alight/electric

01/18/10, 04:11 PM

You really should include a neither option.

Theseventhson

01/18/10, 04:22 PM

Daisy, no contest.

introduction

01/18/10, 05:21 PM

one of the albums sucks.

swt_catastrophe

01/19/10, 12:53 AM

Brand New, all the way

sleepyseanzzz

01/19/10, 05:38 AM

They both suck

friskycurtain

01/19/10, 12:36 PM

They both are horrible, but at least New Again had 3 listenable tracks.

SeanEBoy2686

01/19/10, 04:07 PM

It's a good poll if you like seeing landslide victories

I would've said "thorough beatdowns" but it's still the same point

danman

01/19/10, 04:10 PM

They both are horrible, but at least New Again had 3 listenable tracks.

come on...vices, sink, gasoline, bought a bride are all listenable....

both are the worst albums by each band though.

friskycurtain

01/19/10, 04:11 PM

come on...vices, sink, gasoline, bought a bride are all listenable....

both are the worst albums by each band though.

Vices is quite possibly the worst song I have heard in years.

danman

01/19/10, 04:12 PM

Vices is quite possibly the worst song I have heard in years.

hahah well that still leaves 3 other listenable songs then! But I do see your point too....I miss old Brand New

just.Starla.

01/19/10, 04:44 PM

Daisy.

Echo Park

01/20/10, 08:33 AM

Its a good poll, because they were both really bad. TBS one the battle with the first LP, Brand New won it with the 2nd and 3rd. But for their forth, i think both these albums are really bad. But TBS song Everything Must Go isn't horrible. so they get my vote for sucking the least

Yellowcard2006

01/20/10, 11:15 AM

New Again. Been listening to it since release day.

GREAT ALBUM

Smeee

01/20/10, 12:26 PM

Definitely Daisy, but I do enjoy most of New Again. It's not as bad as it's made out to be. Everything Must Go is one of my favourite songs of 2009.

Charles777

01/20/10, 01:00 PM

Love New Again. Summer, Man and Swing are some of Taking Back Sunday's best songs.

abandonship

01/20/10, 01:17 PM

daisy

roju

01/20/10, 11:05 PM

why even ask?

MADSTA

01/21/10, 07:07 AM

Daisy was the worst thing I heard in '09.

seraph1214

01/21/10, 12:41 PM

I haven't listened to either.

HometownHero

01/21/10, 10:41 PM

New Again. Been listening to it since release day.

GREAT ALBUM
M-(

phil19

01/21/10, 11:24 PM

brand new is winning. im shocked

Yellowcard2006

01/22/10, 07:45 AM

M-(
:shrug: Just played it two days ago. Some of best songwriting of their careers on that disc.

anamericangod

01/23/10, 04:38 PM

New Again.

jbaseball44

01/23/10, 05:14 PM

Not New Again

xapplexpiex

01/23/10, 08:24 PM

Daisy by a little bit. IMO New Again is bad, but not terrible.

mrnegativezero

01/23/10, 11:42 PM

Hm. The amount of people saying New Again is good is strange. I thought AP hated that album entirely.

midkay

01/24/10, 01:01 AM

wow, even more daisy hate than i expected. new again isn't as bad as everyone makes it out to be, but daisy is a really excellent record.

_><_

01/24/10, 01:22 AM

Daisy.

bentleyj98

01/24/10, 08:34 AM

I love New Again and picked that. I honestly don't like Brand New. They are way too over hyped on this site. I'm not sure if it's even everyone having the same opinion or everyone going with what "AP" thinks.

micsforsinging

01/24/10, 08:36 AM

people still listen to taking back sunday?

Schreiforme417

01/24/10, 10:34 AM

taking back sunday are over. period. listening to them is like watching an 80 yr old guy try and get a stiffy

tonighttonight0

01/24/10, 12:49 PM

Neither.

blinkme

01/24/10, 02:58 PM

New Again is just plain nasty.

justletgo

01/24/10, 05:42 PM

daisy by a ridiculous amount.

Spewk

01/24/10, 05:44 PM

Neither.
This is what I thought.

Feenucks

01/24/10, 10:06 PM

Daisy.

Alex1410

01/25/10, 03:25 PM

I know i'm in the minority but i don't think New Again is anywhere near as bad as most people think. Daisy on the other hand bores me a bit.

lakemichigan

01/26/10, 07:56 AM

I guess people who voted for New Again are far from ap.net usual users haha

datsdatdude

01/26/10, 03:14 PM

Daisy might be my favorite Brand New CD, and I'm a huge BN fan. I think the change to more Accardi songwriting allows Lacey more screaming, and, oh, what a scream he has.

New Again was decent, but trying to recapture TBS' magic is a lost cause. That ship has sailed.

SuNDaYSTaR

01/27/10, 10:00 AM

It's a good poll if you like seeing landslide victoriesThis.

Formatfun

01/27/10, 07:29 PM

I don't think I've read a really good argument on why New Again was bad. I enjoy it.

zachff

01/28/10, 10:15 AM

This wont be close

greenteaallday

01/28/10, 12:49 PM

HelloxAlone

01/29/10, 07:07 AM

I was one of the people who liked Daisy.

Echo Park

01/29/10, 05:35 PM

both sucked. Both had one decent...err...listenable song, You Stole (i listened to maybe twice and only cringed alittle) for Brand New and Everything Must Go (this is actually decent) for TBS. thus TBS got my vote

oh, I already commented earlier^^^

Echo Park

01/29/10, 05:37 PM

Hm. The amount of people saying New Again is good is strange. I thought AP hated that album entirely.
they do hate it, but it's being compared to an almost equally bad album, therefore the bar is lowered

I am Mick

01/29/10, 08:44 PM

New Again is fucking terrible, and I chose that over Daisy. Blows my mind people can like that album.

grimis16

01/30/10, 12:47 PM

i love brand new...except for daisy. So id pick neither, both suck

Echo Park

01/30/10, 12:51 PM

i prefer taking a shit with no music playing

SunnyInPhilly

01/30/10, 06:28 PM

New Again by a long shot.

phaserstostun

01/30/10, 07:57 PM

Loved both, don't understand a lot of people on this website... I realize people can have opinions but people act like they're being tortured when they hear these two albums.

I went with Daisy... I've played both about the same amount and Daisy had to grow on me but I think it will stick with me longer, even though it's only number three on my Brand New list and New Again is number two on my TBS list.

roughroads

01/31/10, 11:08 AM

New Again is terrible. Daisy wasn't amazing but by comparison it's no contest.

carnotaurhunter

01/31/10, 06:12 PM

NUDE Again

VIVALAMATT

02/01/10, 01:18 AM

Both disappointing. Went with New Again because at least the first 4 songs on that album are good....