PDA

View Full Version : Motion City Soundtrack - My Dinosaur Life


Thomas Nassiff
01/26/10, 01:46 AM
Motion City Soundtrack - My Dinosaur Life
Record Label: Columbia Records
Release Date: January 19, 2010

Brett Favre just won't retire. Well, he has retired, twice, but he hasn't gone away yet. Brett is 40 now and he's playing for his third NFL team. After a terrible year with the New York Jets in the 2008-2009 season, he more than just bounced back this year with the Minnesota Vikings. He had the best season of his 19-year career at the age of 40 years old, which in professional football might as well be dead.

Don't call it a comeback, call it a return to form.

While Motion City Soundtrack haven't been around quite as long as Brett Favre, the band surface with a return-to-form album with My Dinosaur Life. The follow-up to often criticized Even If It Kills Me is Motion City Soundtrack's best album to date. Motion City are the latest band to fall into that trend, where a group gains immense success and popularity, then release an album that seems just a little different from the others before regaining momentum with full steam (think New Found Glory with Coming Home). After experimenting with more poppy territory on their last offering and seemingly losing that brainy indie rock sound that sets them apart from other bands in the genre, Motion City Soundtrack find their game again and it is evident from the first song.

Also evident from opener "Worker Bee" is the honesty that Justin Pierre has poured out of his pen this time around. Finally writing about his personal struggles in the form of his prose, Pierre kicks off the album stating that "It's been a good year / A good new beginning / I'm through with the old school / So let's commence the winning / I've been a good little worker bee / I deserve a gold star." The entire song is juiced with a never-slowing guitar and is one of the hardest rockers on My Dinosaur Life. Following suit of the first song, "A Lifeless Ordinary (Need a Little Help)" shows MCS's rocking side, complimented by a slightly more pop-infused performance by Pierre. This leads listeners into first single "Her Words Destroyed My Planet", which I'm glad to announce is a shining example of a single actually displaying a good window into what the album sounds like. After the first verse is when I was convinced that Motion City were their old selves again. With Commit This to Memory being my favorite album by the group, "Her Words" was excellent to hear as MCS brings back the car-stereo ready sound found on that album, specifically during the short instrumental part after the first verse. This may be the most honest track on the most honest album that Pierre has written: "If we only stayed together / I might not have fallen apart / But the words you said destroyed my planet / I stall before I start / Anything at all."

The band doesn't take a break with "Disappear" and "Delirium", the former being another fast paced ride through the clever wordplay that fans have become to associate Pierre with, and the latter displaying what seems to be a look into the mind of a psych ward patient. "Stand Too Close", which might be the catchiest song on My Dinosaur Life, will most likely see great success as a single and on the radio, as it is short and sugary enough to entertain the masses that don't really appreciate whole albums. This brings us to "Pulp Fiction", without a doubt my favorite song on the record. It's a feel-good number with lyrical allusions to the film after which it is named. The instrumentals on the song make it just as catchy as "Stand Too Close", but it isn't in the right form to take on the role of a single. "@!#?@!" is perfectly named as Pierre abuses the microphone with more than a few curse words. This song and its successor, "Hysteria", show the variety that Motion City have put into My Dinosaur Life, including hard rockers and head-bangers, catchy made-for-radio numbers, and tracks that seem to serve best as vessels for the words that spilled out of Pierre's beautiful mind.

Nearing the end of the album, "Skin and Bones" is another time-travel trip to Commit This to Memory, its highlight being a chorus that goes down smooth. Closer "The Weakends" starts slow, then punches you in the mouth with dueling guitar work and, again, a lyrical effort where the listener could not ask for more. Pierre's work on this album reminds me of Max Bemis in that he has said exactly what he wanted to say without any regrets or hesitations. Only a handful of albums have left me so thankful for the work of a lyricist, even though coincidentally MDL is one of two albums this month to leave me with that feeling (The Upsides). Like I said, this is Motion City Soundtrack's best work, the perfect storm of Commit This to Memory and the best parts of Even If It Kills Me.

indie rock, Commit This to Memory, counting the number of tiles in the ceiling, head for the hills the kitchen's on fire, you should know what Motion City Soundtrack sound like.

"Her Words Destroyed My Planet", "Disappear", "Pulp Fiction", "The Weakends"

1. Worker Bee
2. A Lifeless Ordinary (Need a Little Help)
3. Her Words Destroyed My Planet
4. Disappear
5. Delirium
6. History Lesson
7. Stand Too Close
8. Pulp Fiction
9. @!#?@!
10. Hysteria
11. Skin and Bones
12. The Weakends
Produced By: Mark Hoppus (he's getting gooooood), Run Time: 40 minutes
myspace.com/motioncitysoundtrack (http://www.myspace.com/motioncitysoundtrack)

Argentine
02/06/10, 10:50 PM
This is a well written review. Also the opener was hilarious haha

Thomas Nassiff
02/08/10, 02:46 PM
This is a well written review. Also the opener was hilarious haha
well thanks there, pal.

songisland
02/09/10, 02:21 PM
never got into this one which is disappointing

E. Clectic
02/11/10, 08:09 PM
I have never seen one album get so many different reviews.
I think this makes five on this site?

That being said, nice review. Enjoyable review.

HometownHero
02/11/10, 08:11 PM
Are all your reviews this biased and absurd?

IndieKid!
02/11/10, 08:14 PM
The rating seems quite high, i personally do not think this is there best work ( to each there own ) but i think 90%> is a bit steep for any motion city soundtrack album to date.

theredline
02/11/10, 08:15 PM
love motion city and favre...great analogy, great review...

MrBojangles6244
02/11/10, 08:24 PM
This was a great review. I thoroughly enjoy this band and this album.

MrBojangles6244
02/11/10, 08:24 PM
Though I did really like Even If It Kills Me, though I might be the only one.

Yellowcard2006
02/11/10, 08:39 PM
Great review. I love every thing MCS does. EIIKM has some of my favorite songs, and for a while I considered it my favorite album by them.

IndieKid!
02/11/10, 08:42 PM
Though I did really like Even If It Kills Me, though I might be the only one.

You are not alone.

Echo Park
02/11/10, 10:14 PM
i cant believe a review/er of a band that gives it a score of 91 that isn't Brand New

roberthuston
02/12/10, 12:54 AM
In reference to band's entire discography, this is amateur at best. I love the energy and drive kids have to write reviews, I love that, but to say suggest it sounds like "motion city soundtrack" in severely un-researched.

brothaman
02/12/10, 04:20 AM
awesome album, better than SEVERAL pop-punk albums that came out this month.

SomedayTheFire
02/12/10, 05:24 AM
Waaaaaaaay too high

zachff
02/12/10, 07:21 AM
Waaaaaaaay too high
Exactly. This guy loves the long winded cliched reviews

Indoor Living
02/12/10, 08:05 AM
i cant believe a review/er of a band that gives it a score of 91 that isn't Brand New
You're retarded.

Echo Park
02/12/10, 08:09 AM
You're retarded.
You're retarded.

Indoor Living
02/12/10, 08:15 AM
You're retarded.
Alright.

Echo Park
02/12/10, 08:16 AM
Alright.
Alright.

blinkme
02/12/10, 08:49 AM
Even If It Kills Me and Coming Home are some of my favourite albums. Glad to see that My Dinosaur Life has been so well received though. I adore this album.

Thomas Nassiff
02/12/10, 09:24 AM
Are all your reviews this biased and absurd?
yeah, don't read them anymore. or read them and figure out yourself. this album and the TWY album hit me hard.

Thomas Nassiff
02/12/10, 09:26 AM
The rating seems quite high, i personally do not think this is there best work ( to each there own ) but i think 90%> is a bit steep for any motion city soundtrack album to date.
i think it's their best work. the best motion city album doesn't deserve a 90? lyrics are solid, music is solid, overall extremely enjoyable album and i don't think their talent can be debated.

Thomas Nassiff
02/12/10, 09:26 AM
Waaaaaaaay too high
so you review it and mark it lower.

Thomas Nassiff
02/12/10, 09:27 AM
Exactly. This guy loves the long winded cliched reviews
this guy loves the douchebag comments. if you read my other reviews, the MCS and TWY reviews are exceptions to the norm.

Thomas Nassiff
02/12/10, 09:28 AM
In reference to band's entire discography, this is amateur at best. I love the energy and drive kids have to write reviews, I love that, but to say suggest it sounds like "motion city soundtrack" in severely un-researched.
this doesn't sound like commit this to memory and i am the movie even in the slightest to you? that's absurd. i've listened to motion city for however long now and i know all their albums, it's researched just fine thank you.

terror_91
02/12/10, 09:31 AM
Decent review but you shouldn't really go through song by song (especially missing a song out haha) because it doesn't quite work. Otherwise good stuff.

Thomas Nassiff
02/12/10, 09:34 AM
Decent review but you shouldn't really go through song by song (especially missing a song out haha) because it doesn't quite work. Otherwise good stuff.
it's my style. i try not to but some albums i find it necessary. i left out the song that i left out for a reason.

HometownHero
02/12/10, 09:43 AM
yeah, don't read them anymore. or read them and figure out yourself. this album and the TWY album hit me hard.
So give the reviewer tilt a ten and actually give normal scores through out instead of gushing like a fan boy

terror_91
02/12/10, 11:57 AM
it's my style. i try not to but some albums i find it necessary. i left out the song that i left out for a reason.
Yeah, that's fair enough. Why did you leave it out? Surely you must have something to say about it? Even if you don't, then say so. People will want to know if a song is so mediocre that nothing can be said about it :-p

Thomas Nassiff
02/12/10, 02:12 PM
So give the reviewer tilt a ten and actually give normal scores through out instead of gushing like a fan boy
thats what i do. this review isn't gushed. it's what i think of the album. read my wonder years review, that's gushed.

DanielJames
02/12/10, 04:06 PM
"Finally writing about his personal struggles in the form of his prose..."

Have you actually listened to past Motion City albums? All of their albums lyrically are about Pierre's personal struggles. I enjoy the album, but this review sounds terribly biased.

IndieKid!
02/12/10, 05:58 PM
i think it's their best work. the best motion city album doesn't deserve a 90? lyrics are solid, music is solid, overall extremely enjoyable album and i don't think their talent can be debated.

Lyrics are solid? Not sure quite what you mean by that, but i am pretty sure all of there albums have "solid" lyrics. 90% is to high for this objectively unless you think there is no room for improvement? This happens a lot when a new album comes out initially, it is a lot better than other releases in the same genre as of late though. I find it hard to connect to a lot of the songs on this album ( opinion ) but as i said, to each there own. :] ( anything can be debated, also this is not a product of 'talent' it is a product of hard work )

Thomas Nassiff
02/12/10, 08:52 PM
Lyrics are solid? Not sure quite what you mean by that, but i am pretty sure all of there albums have "solid" lyrics. 90% is to high for this objectively unless you think there is no room for improvement? This happens a lot when a new album comes out initially, it is a lot better than other releases in the same genre as of late though. I find it hard to connect to a lot of the songs on this album ( opinion ) but as i said, to each there own. :] ( anything can be debated, also this is not a product of 'talent' it is a product of hard work )
i would argue that motion city has at least some talent to go along with that work ethic. anyway if you think there's no room for improvement from a 90% score then what do you think 92-100% scores are for? and i write all album reviews when they come out unless i'm asked to do them by someone in retrospect.

Thomas Nassiff
02/13/10, 09:44 AM
"Finally writing about his personal struggles in the form of his prose..."

Have you actually listened to past Motion City albums? All of their albums lyrically are about Pierre's personal struggles. I enjoy the album, but this review sounds terribly biased.
this is by far his most honest and open lyrical effort. and yeah it's biased. if i hated it i would turn everything into negative things. it's my review. i'm not the god damn associated press.

IndieKid!
02/13/10, 04:07 PM
i would argue that motion city has at least some talent to go along with that work ethic. anyway if you think there's no room for improvement from a 90% score then what do you think 92-100% scores are for? and i write all album reviews when they come out unless i'm asked to do them by someone in retrospect.
92% - 100% ( approaching then hitting perfect ) would be even more of a scoring crime lol to each there own.

DanielJames
02/14/10, 07:40 AM
this is by far his most honest and open lyrical effort. and yeah it's biased. if i hated it i would turn everything into negative things. it's my review. i'm not the god damn associated press.
I could make the argument that every Motion City album is honest and open on a lyric basis. And yeah it's your review, but I believe the best reviews are those where the reviewer can express his/her opinion on an album without being overly baised. Being biased is inevitable, but sounding like a fanboy doesn't make a review very credible, generally speaking.

Do Not Block
04/12/10, 02:02 PM
I totally agree. This album is brilliant and I'm sure I'm going to be listening to it for quite a while

Thomas Nassiff
04/12/10, 09:18 PM
I totally agree. This album is brilliant and I'm sure I'm going to be listening to it for quite a while
Did you just read through half of my reviews or something? Hahaha