PDA

View Full Version : Monty Are I - Wall of People


Tony Pascarella
07/17/06, 11:53 PM
Monty Are I – Wall of People
Release Date: August 1, 2006
Record Label: Stolen Transmission/Island Records

[Overall Score: 7.8/10]

Getting right down to it, the biggest problem with the Stolen Transmission debut from Monty Are I is the lack of new songs. That new-car smell applies to CDs too, and those who enjoyed the band’s 8-song debut, The Red Shift, might not find Wall of People as appealing as first-time listeners. Six of the eleven songs are taken from The Red Shift and spruced up a bit before being slapped onto the new CD. While the band have changed their name from Monty's Fan Club to Monty to the current moniker, Monty Are I, their drive and determination remains intact, perhaps even refined as time has allowed them to mature a bit. They are consistently noted for an electric live show, but some complain they are not always up to par on CD. Wall of People combats that stereotype to some success, although a few holes in their recorded performance remain.

Some of the songs (see “Anchor and Hope”) play the angry ex-lover card just a bit too prominently, although “Dublin Waltz” keys heavily on the muted ska sound that gives Monty Are I the edge over your ordinary passive-aggressive rock band. Frankly, that makes all the difference. Never do the horns overwhelm the listener, but they do just enough (although some may argue they should be brought into the mix more often) to accent the rough and tumble rock ‘n roll sound that Monty Are I strive for. “O Brother” starts out promising a harsh sound, but Steve Aiello dials it back a notch vocally. This musical contradiction of sorts comes off as a little forced, although when the band lets loose instrumentally, they flourish. “O Brother” features a self-indulgent choral group backing the outro of the song; it is an interesting touch, and it actually turns out well. Closing the album, “Only the Weak” is an ass-kicking track that seems to try to channel AFI before returning to a distinct Monty Are I sound; it stands as one of the CD’s strongest tracks, and is quickly becoming one of my favorites of the year.

With Wall of People, Monty Are I barrel through 11 tracks with reckless abandon, scathing belligerence, and enough cheap thrills to put a smile on nearly anyone’s face. For his part, Steve Aiello sounds like a stepchild of Name Taken’s Chad Atkinson and New Found Glory’s Jordan Pundik with perhaps a little Darryl Palumbo thrown in for good measure, and that quirky yet refreshing voice of his gives Wall of People a marked advantage in quality. If you want to enjoy a solid debut album from a band that should be making waves sooner rather than later, add Wall of People to your CD collection; these are some damn good rock ‘n roll tunes.

Buy Monty Are I's Wall of People on iTunes (http://click.linksynergy.com/fs-bin/stat?id=PjIvm57kicI&offerid=78941&type=3&subid=0&tmpid=1826&RD_PARM1=http%253A%252F%252Fphobos. apple.com%252FWebObjects%252FMZStor e.woa%252Fwa%252FviewAlbum%253Fi%25 3D168639079%2526id%253D168639075%25 26s%253D143441%2526partnerId%253D30 )

01. Between the Sheets
02. Castle Bound
03. Dublin Waltz*
04. Anchor and Hope*
05. O Brother
06. Island City
07. Metropolis
08. In This Legacy
09. Just In Time*
10. Tie Off Your Veins*
11. Only the Weak*
* denotes new song99 Cents Worth includes several of my favorite songs that if you're looking to sample the album, you should check out on iTunes."Only the Weak," "Dublin Waltz," and "Tie Off Your Veins"Myspace (http://www.myspace.com/montyarei) | Purevolume (http://www.purevolume.com/montyarei) | Official Site (http://www.montyarei.com)

Steve Henderson
07/18/06, 08:16 AM
these are some damn good rock ‘n roll tunes.That is big, orange sticker ready, my friend.

Tony Pascarella
07/18/06, 08:23 AM
hm i just saw them w/ RXB

their trombone player danced with the horn in his hand for 25 mins of the set
for 4 mins he played keyboards
and for 1 minute he played trombone

i was kind of disappointed

and he would pick up the trombone to dance with it in songs where he didnt even play it

it was kind of like a stage prop :(Really? They tore it up live when I saw them (they were recording live footage that night, so I dunno). I have a friend who had seen them previously and said they were very good live as well. Maybe you caught a bad day? He was low on air?

Tony Pascarella
07/18/06, 08:25 AM
That is big, orange sticker ready, my friend.If they choose to use it, I won't complain. This release will get overlooked, and I think a lot of our readers would enjoy it.

X__inhope
07/18/06, 08:32 AM
I have to agree with the fact that it is a major bummer that this is pretty much a rerelease of their last record.

Last year, I reviewed hundreds of demos for Takeover Records Sign My Band Contest, and this was the band that I picked to go into the top 10. I'm glad to see they are going places, but would have loved if they at least had half new and half old.

electricpatrick
07/18/06, 08:35 AM
pretty good review tony

i havent listened to any of the new songs yet, cause like you pointed out, there are only 5 of em and i have the red shift. i like being surprised a little bit when i get the physical cd in my hand. anyway, i have been looking forward to this album

anyone know if they still have that limited enhanced ep they were selling on the beginning of the tour, or if that is sold out?

Tony Pascarella
07/18/06, 08:40 AM
I have to agree with the fact that it is a major bummer that this is pretty much a rerelease of their last record.

Last year, I reviewed hundreds of demos for Takeover Records Sign My Band Contest, and this was the band that I picked to go into the top 10. I'm glad to see they are going places, but would have loved if they at least had half new and half old.That's pretty cool. How does one get a job like that?

Anyone who enjoyed The Red Shift will probably dig this because there's so many songs from it, but the new songs are really where it's at. "Between the Sheets" (old) was good, but songs like "Only the Weak" are so much better.

Scott Weber
07/18/06, 08:44 AM
$1.99 bargain bin in 2 years.

LMB
07/18/06, 08:45 AM
Monty('s Fan Club/Are I)'s releases have been nothing more than fun rock, and that's how I like it.

Tony Pascarella
07/18/06, 08:46 AM
$1.99 bargain bin in 2 years.Most CDs released in the past two years deserve that. Besides, Weber, you hate everything. ;)

shane hennessey
07/18/06, 08:54 AM
ive been following MAI for about 3 years now and I look forward to getting this cd. such good guys

screwbizzle
07/18/06, 08:58 AM
sweet review, tony.
i also agree that their live show is great!

gonz
07/18/06, 09:03 AM
Good review for a good CD

Tony Pascarella
07/18/06, 09:05 AM
By the way, does anyone like the addition of the new box, 99 Cents Worth? I figured I'd highlight a few of my favorite tracks from each CD in my reviews.

Steve Henderson
07/18/06, 09:19 AM
By the way, does anyone like the addition of the new box, 99 Cents Worth? I figured I'd highlight a few of my favorite tracks from each CD in my reviews.
Well, here shouldn't it be $2.97 worth? :) But yeah it is a good idea. I tend to like to talk about the record as a whole only, but I can see people appreciating this.

Tony Pascarella
07/18/06, 09:30 AM
Well, here shouldn't it be $2.97 worth? :) But yeah it is a good idea. I tend to like to talk about the record as a whole only, but I can see people appreciating this.Well, I was referring to iTunes' $.99 per song with that. I can't go tell people just to download the songs (illegally) because that kind of compromises a lot of what we do; so that way it recommends a legal alternative for people to sample the album if they don't have many songs on Myspace.

shane hennessey
07/18/06, 09:31 AM
By the way, does anyone like the addition of the new box, 99 Cents Worth? I figured I'd highlight a few of my favorite tracks from each CD in my reviews.
i like it. id personally never buy individual songs but its helpful for sure

Tony Pascarella
07/18/06, 09:34 AM
i like it. id personally never buy individual songs but its helpful for sureWell, if the songs are on Myspace, it will also hopefully give people an idea which ones are the better ones and which are just filler.

YourMusicSucks
07/18/06, 09:39 AM
By the way, does anyone like the addition of the new box, 99 Cents Worth? I figured I'd highlight a few of my favorite tracks from each CD in my reviews.
That's a great idea, especially since a lot of albums reviewed do have a fair amount of filler. It's good to be able to check out the strongest tracks.

Great review.

Take Heart
07/18/06, 09:48 AM
Well, I was referring to iTunes' $.99 per song with that. I can't go tell people just to download the songs (illegally) because that kind of compromises a lot of what we do; so that way it recommends a legal alternative for people to sample the album if they don't have many songs on Myspace.

I like it, it's a clever way to opine what you feel the standout tracks of the album are. If I were telling someone to listen to this band, those are the exact 3 songs I'd recommend too. Great review.

Scott Weber
07/18/06, 11:03 AM
Most CDs released in the past two years deserve that. Besides, Weber, you hate everything. ;)
I hate bad music. Haha.

Katie Schmitz
07/18/06, 11:28 AM
I was disappointed with the no new songs thing. What the hell? I have the EP, I wanted some (more) new stuff!

RarePromo
07/18/06, 12:37 PM
hm i just saw them w/ RXB

their trombone player danced with the horn in his hand for 25 mins of the set
for 4 mins he played keyboards
and for 1 minute he played trombone

i was kind of disappointed

and he would pick up the trombone to dance with it in songs where he didnt even play it

it was kind of like a stage prop :(


I thought the exact same thing when I saw them in Minneapolis last week. I thought it a rock prop. But they still put on a pretty good show. Although, of course, not as good as the Bandits.

xmicandmoshpitx
07/18/06, 02:48 PM
good review
i like this band a lot and im really stoked that my band might play when them in september

southline
07/18/06, 03:26 PM
hm i just saw them w/ RXB

their trombone player danced with the horn in his hand for 25 mins of the set
for 4 mins he played keyboards
and for 1 minute he played trombone

i was kind of disappointed

and he would pick up the trombone to dance with it in songs where he didnt even play it

it was kind of like a stage prop :(

yea i saw them in Buffalo with that tour. same thing happened. the trombone player was almost unnecessary. he should just stick to more keyboards.

chazburgr
07/18/06, 04:51 PM
Being in the homestate of monty's, of course ive been listening to them for awhile now. I would have to say that, although I enjoyed the energy of their "action rock" debut of The Red Shift, I miss Andrew and Ryan's horns taking stage and their true east coast ska influence showing. They werent completely a ska band, listen to Hearts Bleeding, and they had mixed ska with action rock/alt rock and made it work and we all enjoyed it.

I still liked The Red Shift, but I thought they were better with horns playing a bigger role. It made them a little more unique. Maybe they got tired of the ska scene.

If anyone says they were awesome live, it's because they're music is high on energy and they go wild on stage, a lot of moving and, as part of the audience, a lot of jumping for you.rawr.

HandsDown28
07/19/06, 08:16 AM
So excited for this album! The new songs are phenomenal.

Don't forget this is their label debut, and with it comes distribution they didn't previously have. Meaning those songs from The Red Shift are going to be new to some people. And it's happened a lot in the past - good pre-signage songs redone for their first label album- like All-American Rejects', Something Corporate's, etc.

Also...Anchor & Hope isn't about an angry ex-lover. It's about Rhode Island and making something of yourself ("Anchor & Hope" is the state's motto) - "Just anchor and hope/Have faith in your home" It rocks live.

Word!

X__inhope
07/20/06, 12:42 PM
That's pretty cool. How does one get a job like that?

Anyone who enjoyed The Red Shift will probably dig this because there's so many songs from it, but the new songs are really where it's at. "Between the Sheets" (old) was good, but songs like "Only the Weak" are so much better.
I worked for takeover for a year or so, and when I went and worked at one of the Jersey dates, I came home with a backpack full of cds, as well as two boxs overflowing with cds. haha

The majority of them were not so good, but Monty showed some promise. I guess putting the old tracks is sort of a good idea on Stolen Transmissions part, since they are fan favorites and people who may not have gotten a chance to hear the cd would probably like them. But for there (fairly large) fanbase, I think this cd is pretty much a rerelease and they would have been better suited putting out an ep with the few new songs.

Broken Parachute
07/21/06, 06:32 PM
I will probably purchase this album. Nice review.

killer182
07/24/06, 02:14 PM
This sounds like garbage juice, running down a fat womans hips.

Rhodygrl
07/28/06, 10:44 AM
I wish I had fresh ears on this CD because I would be even more blown away! I think the CD is still amazing I love the new songs, and appreciate the old! I see it more as this is where we came from, but look at where we are heading.I already own the red shit but none the less I will be in line to snaggle this quality as well! In response to those who think Andrew should not be dancing with his trombone and just playing it...I enjoy his dancing its way better than watching a stiff keyboard player. Also, I think people tend to obsess over placing this band into a category. I think they should Just be THEM and keep on making killer music. They have grown alot as musicians and reserve the right to adjust the horns and style as they need to. I personally enjoy the variety of sounds. :)

Cashingout
05/16/07, 09:25 AM
I saw these guys opening for the rx bandits and "Between the sheets", just made me go buy the cd, these guys are getting much better.

bummm
07/13/08, 10:55 PM
<3

Illuminate
09/07/09, 05:45 PM
Just came across this review, well written. It does have a "lack" of new songs, but still quality is quality. Hence I wish you gave higher than a 78 percent.. This deserves mid 80's IMO.