this better be hard.

[x1onexwo1fx]

that's what she said.

[domotime2]

1) Dookie
2) Sticks and Stones
3) Stay What You Are
4) All Killer
5) Tell All Your Friends
6) Take this To Your Grave
7) Say it Like
8) Leaving Through
9) Room's Too Cold.

that's the order

[x1onexwo1fx]

1) Dookie
2) Sticks and Stones
3) Stay What You Are
4) All Killer
5) Tell All Your Friends
6) Take this To Your Grave
7) Say it Like
8) Leaving Through
9) Room's Too Cold.

that's the order

you left out ocean avenue.

[<*)))><]

Damn I came in here to post that is what she said.

[SLoT]

I went with Sticks and Stones. It's the one I still listen to the most.

[fadedmemories]

Take This To Your Grave
Tell All Your Friends
The Room's Too Cold
Stay What You Are
Sticks and Stones
Leaving Through The Window
Dookie
Say It Like You Mean It
Ocean Avenue
All Killer, No Filler

[squared82]

Take This To Your Grave
Sticks and Stones
Ocean Avenue
Say It Like You Mean It
All Killer, No Filler
Dookie
Tell All Your Friends
Leaving Through the Window
Stay What You Are
The Room's Too Cold

[steveC]

i went say it like you mean it, but it was basically a 4-way tie between that, stay what you are, leaving through the window, and take this to your grave

[Brokenhill]

I've only heard 3 of those all the way through, and although I dislike pop-punk overall, I occasionally want to listen to 'Tell All Your Friends'.

[Kozzy333]

Difficult decision but here's my top 3 of these.

1) Take This To Your Grave
2) Sticks and Stones
3) Say It Like You Mean It

[seraph1214]

(1) Dookie
(2) Stay What You Are
(3) Say It Like You Mean It
(4) Ocean Avenue
(5) All Killer No Filler
(6) The Room's Too Cold
(7) Sticks and Stones
(8) Leaving Through the Window
(9) Take This to Your Grave
(10) Tell All Your Friends

[Corgkowznor]

I voted Ocean Avenue one, just my personal favorite...but definitely some tough choices.

[fightinirish217]

Dookie really opened my ears to music, I chose that. I remember listening to the cassette in my dad's car. Good times.

[E. Clectic]

Tell All Your Friends, because no other album has ever given me the same feeling...

...and that feeling was good.

[x1onexwo1fx]

anyone else feel like tttyg is getting a little bit too much love on this poll?

[x1onexwo1fx]

crap, the ataris. i knew i was forgetting something.

[Meeze]

TEN <3 Ace <3 TRTC <3

[lauren1234]

Sticks and Stones. It's the first album on the list that I ever listened to and got me, heavily, into music.

[eriatarka24]

anyone else feel like tttyg is getting a little bit too much love on this poll?
no :)

[x1onexwo1fx]

no :)

well then i just hope it doesn't end up leading by too much.

[FueledByRock]

Tie between TTTYG and Dookie for me. TAYF and Sticks and Stones are soon after.

[drpepper09]

Dookie really opened my ears to music, I chose that. I remember listening to the cassette in my dad's car. Good times.

same here, i remember being a little kid and my dad had Dookie on repeat.

Dookie for nostalgia and the fact that it changed music


Other top choices are:
Take This To Your Grave
Tell All Your Friends
All Killer No Filler

[mike'smannequin]

dookie

[Machu505]

Take This to Your Grave.

[MyWorldEntire]

It's hard to pick because I don't like any of them.

[E. Clectic]

It's hard to pick because I don't like any of them.

Have you no soul?

I bet you don't like making (sweet sweet) love, breathing air, or crabby patties either.

[x1onexwo1fx]

It's hard to pick because I don't like any of them.

i didn't think there'd be anyone on this site who didn't like at least one of these albums. your list of favorite bands is pretty impressive. nothing very fun, though =( live a little!

[Yellowcard2006]

Yellowcard


i didn't think there'd be anyone on this site who didn't like at least one of these albums. your list of favorite bands is pretty impressive. nothing very fun, though =( live a little!
He has Green Day listed but doesn't like Dookie...

wat

[GamEin]

I picked The Room's Too Cold, one of my favorite albums ever. It needs more love.

Tell All Your Friends and Sticks and Stones as honorable mentions.

[E. Clectic]

Yellowcard



He has Green Day listed but doesn't like Dookie...

wat

That's like liking Jesus but hating the New Testament!! You're favorite author being Salinger and hating "The Catcher in the Rye!"
Liking Nicktoons but hating "Hey Arnold!"

[MyWorldEntire]

i didn't think there'd be anyone on this site who didn't like at least one of these albums. your list of favorite bands is pretty impressive. nothing very fun, though =( live a little!

How are these bands not fun: AC/DC, Animal Collective, Arcade Fire, The Avalanches, The Beach Boys, Beastie Boys, Beck, Broken Social Scene, Bruce Springsteen, Daft Punk, Death Cab For Cutie, The Decemberists, Green Day, Guns N' Roses, Jay-Z, Kanye West, The Killers, The Kinks, Lcd Soundsystem, Led Zeppelin, Modest Mouse, N.W.A, Neon Indian, Okkervil River, Outkast, Phoenix, Queen, Queens Of The Stone Age, Ra Ra Riot, The Strokes, Sufjan Stevens,Talking Heads, (old) Weezer, The Who, Wilco, Wolf Parade, Yeah Yeah Yeahs

And I didn't see Dookie was one of the options, will vote for that.

[Yellowcard2006]

How are these bands not fun: AC/DC, Animal Collective, Arcade Fire, The Avalanches, The Beach Boys, Beastie Boys, Beck, Broken Social Scene, Bruce Springsteen, Daft Punk, Death Cab For Cutie, The Decemberists, Green Day, Guns N' Roses, Jay-Z, Kanye West, The Killers, The Kinks, Lcd Soundsystem, Led Zeppelin, Modest Mouse, N.W.A, Neon Indian, Okkervil River, Outkast, Phoenix, Queen, Queens Of The Stone Age, Ra Ra Riot, The Strokes, Sufjan Stevens,Talking Heads, (old) Weezer, The Who, Wilco, Wolf Parade, Yeah Yeah Yeahs

And I didn't see Dookie was one of the options, will vote for that.
See? Crisis averted.

[x1onexwo1fx]

How are these bands not fun: AC/DC, Animal Collective, Arcade Fire, The Avalanches, The Beach Boys, Beastie Boys, Beck, Broken Social Scene, Bruce Springsteen, Daft Punk, Death Cab For Cutie, The Decemberists, Green Day, Guns N' Roses, Jay-Z, Kanye West, The Killers, The Kinks, Lcd Soundsystem, Led Zeppelin, Modest Mouse, N.W.A, Neon Indian, Okkervil River, Outkast, Phoenix, Queen, Queens Of The Stone Age, Ra Ra Riot, The Strokes, Sufjan Stevens,Talking Heads, (old) Weezer, The Who, Wilco, Wolf Parade, Yeah Yeah Yeahs

And I didn't see Dookie was one of the options, will vote for that.

good, yes. interesting, yes. fun? not as much. although some of those i haven't listened to, so meh. and it really does depend on what you consider fun...

aha! i knew it was impossible for someone on this site to not like at least one of these albums.

[MyWorldEntire]

good, yes. interesting, yes. fun? not as much. although some of those i haven't listened to, so meh. and it really does depend on what you consider fun...

aha! i knew it was impossible for someone on this site to not like at least one of these albums.

Your definition of fun is basically pop-punk from what I can tell. Music can be fun without being immature.

[x1onexwo1fx]

Your definition of fun is basically pop-punk from what I can tell. Music can be fun without being immature.

i enjoy thrice as much as any other fanboy on here. i wouldn't say they're fun to listen to, though. ...actually, thrice might not be the best example here, because i have fun listening to the illusion of safety. meh. anyway, i guess for me, enjoyment doesn't necessarily equal fun.

[sleepyseanzzz]

fat lip and my friends over you got me into music on this list (also all the small things, superman by goldfinger, and all my best friends are metalheads) but i gotta give it to all killer no filler just because it was the first. although say it like you mean it is in my top 5 and i love tell all your friends, take this to your grave, stay what you are, and dookie. new found glory's self titled is my favorite by them though

edit: great poll by the way, really had me thinking hard

[x1onexwo1fx]

new found glory's self titled is my favorite by them though

same here. i went with sticks and stones instead because it won in 2/3 of the "which nfg album is the best" polls on here. sort of the same thing happened with through being cool and one for the kids, though i can't say for sure if i like tbc more than swya.

...yes, i did look up polls for every band before making this.

[HoldThatSound]

ocean avenue. then say it like you mean it.

[bladerdude360]

well then i just hope it doesn't end up leading by too much.
Why would it be bad for TTTYG to lead by a lot? Isn't the reason you make a poll to find out what people's opinions are? If most people prefer that album doesn't that just answer your question?

/yeah I voted TTTYG.

[x1onexwo1fx]

Why would it be bad for TTTYG to lead by a lot? Isn't the reason you make a poll to find out what people's opinions are? If most people prefer that album doesn't that just answer your question?

/yeah I voted TTTYG.

if tttyg, or any other album led by a lot, it would mean the poll wasn't as hard as i thought it would be, and i'd be sad.

[Paulb-182]

Tell All Your Friends. Hands down.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Some of my favorite albums, but Sticks and Stones probably takes it.

[MattDennis]

The only albums I actually still listen to on this list are Tell All Your Friends (my vote) and The Room's Too Cold. However if you had asked me 7 or 8 years ago it would have been between Sticks and Stones and Say it Like You Mean It.

[Spark In Space]

Went with All Killer. It has the most nostalgia for me. Sticks and Stones was in a close second.

[Poochemist]

Dookie was an easy choice.

[Hagysaurus Rex]

Leaving Through The Window all day and any day.

Granted the other albums might be musically "better" and "more important", they just don't mean nearly as much to me as that SoCo CD does.

[Croggs]

I will give every Fall Out Boy album a chance because they consistently enjoyable. I will give every TBS album a chance because of TAYF (and Where You Want to Be....mainly because of TAYF) even if the last two have ended in pretty huge disappointment. TAYF is probably my favorite album of all time, but I'm pretty sure most of the albums are in my top 20. You succeeded in making a pretty difficult poll.

[zachff]

1. TTTYG
2. Ocean Ave
3. Leaving Through the Window
4. Say It Like You Mean it
5. Sticks and Stones
6. The Room's Too Cold
7. Tell All Your Friends
8. Dookie
9. Stay What You Are
10. All Killer No Filler

[Chesser19]

Went with Dookie on this one.

[saveferris]

I honestly have no fucking clue. My top 3 are TTTYG, TAYF, and Sticks and Stones

[Ari Christos]

(1) Dookie
(2) Stay What You Are
(3) Say It Like You Mean It
(4) Ocean Avenue
(5) All Killer No Filler
(6) The Room's Too Cold
(7) Sticks and Stones
(8) Leaving Through the Window
(9) Take This to Your Grave
(10) Tell All Your Friends

Interesting last two. I voted for Tell All Your Friends, that one was the game changer for me. My list would probably be like

1. Tell All Your Friends
2. Stay What You Are
3. Take This To Your Grave
4. Dookie
5. Leaving Through The Window
6. The Room's Too Cold
7. Say It Like You Mean It
8. Ocean Avenue
9. All Killer No Filler
10. Sticks and Stones

[seraph1214]

Interesting last two. I voted for Tell All Your Friends, that one was the game changer for me. My list would probably be like

1. Tell All Your Friends
2. Stay What You Are
3. Take This To Your Grave
4. Dookie
5. Leaving Through The Window
6. The Room's Too Cold
7. Say It Like You Mean It
8. Ocean Avenue
9. All Killer No Filler
10. Sticks and Stones

Most of these records hold some of sort of significance to me, but with Tell All Your Friends and Take This to Your Grave, they just dated horribly. I loved them when they first came out (still do), but as I get older I listen to them less and less.

[BozzBlonde]

Take This To Your Grave. No contest for me.

[WhoSaidThat?]

Sticks and Stones.

[The Summer Ends]

Really close between TTTYG and TAYF, but went with TTTYG.

[Toothache]

its really hard to choose between dookie and sticks and stones.

[radxbandit]

Here's my ranking:
Stay What You Are
Leaving Through the Window
Sticks and Stones
Ocean Avenue
Say It Like You Mean It
Dookie
All Killer No Filler

And I never gave a shit about these:
Take This To Your Grave
Rooms Too Cold
Tell All Your Friends

SWYA, LTTW, and SS are the only ones that much playing time, now.

[owiseone35]

I actually tried a few months ago listening to Say It Like You Mean It and I couldn't do it, it just didn't hit me like it used to when I was in 7th grade. I went Stay What You Are just barely over Tell All Your Friends.

[radxbandit]

crap, the ataris. i knew i was forgetting something.

was going to hit you up about that, they're a must.

[Holly HoX!]

Stay What You Are

[Holly HoX!]

Here's my ranking:
Stay What You Are
Leaving Through the Window
Sticks and Stones
Ocean Avenue
Say It Like You Mean It
Dookie
All Killer No Filler

And I never gave a shit about these:
Take This To Your Grave
Rooms Too Cold
Tell All Your Friends

SWYA, LTTW, and SS are the only ones that much playing time, now.

As someone who also voted Stay What You Are, I highly recommend that you give Tell All Your Friends another listen.

[Holly HoX!]

Goes to show how far Taking Back Sunday have fallen. Man, they used to be great.

[radxbandit]

As someone who also voted Stay What You Are, I highly recommend that you give Tell All Your Friends another listen.

i've just never been a big fan of FOB, TBS, or early november, though i've given listened to all of their releases throughout their careers. at one point i was mildly into where you want to be and from under the cork tree, but nothing from these bands has ever really resonated with me.

[under.control]

hmmidy...

Sticks and Stones
Leaving Through The Window
Dookie
Say it Like You Mean It
Tell All Your Friends
Take This To Your Grave
Ocean Avenue
All Killer No Filler
Stay What You Are
The Room's Too Cold

it was hard.

[Star Slight]

Stay What You Are

I'm a little shocked that TBS is practically running away with this one.

[Joeypeapot777]

Stay What You Are is the best album. But Dookie really got me into music. And take this to your grave and tell all your friends are really really close as well.

[Vanedarlingg]

Ocean avenue!

[xapplexpiex]

This was a tough one, but I had to choose TBS.

WTF was Sum 41 doing in this though? Say It Like You Mean It should be beating them!

[RustyxDrums]

Tell All Your Friends hands down followed closely by Take This To Your Grave.

[MADSTA]

It was between Leaving and TTTYG for me. I voted for Leaving but I'm still not entirely sure.

[hitormiss92]

Went with ocean avenue but wow that was hard

[SJPrice99]

dookie
tell all your friends
take this to your grave
say it like you mean it
ocean avenue
sticks and stones
stay what you are
all killer no filler
leaving thru the window
rooms too cold

[Theseventhson]

Tell All Your Friends is the only record on this list I enjoy.

[La La Lie]

It was between Leaving and TTTYG for me. I voted for Leaving but I'm still not entirely sure.

I agree completely. TTTYG was actually such a great album, but Something Corporate was absolutely beautiful. Yeah, I'm voting for Leaving Through the Window.

[lesto17]

Stay What You Are

[antimatter]

...wow.

Are you guys serious with some of these?

Tayf
Swya
Tttyg
---
Trtc
Lttw
Silymi
Oa
---
S&s
Dookie
Aknf

Last three don't even belong and first three are clear top.

[SanePsychotic]

Dookie, easily.

[antimatter]

Oh and through being cool is way better than stay what you are. The biggest std fans will agree.

[klawansie7]

Dookie really opened my ears to music, I chose that. I remember listening to the cassette in my dad's car. Good times.
dookie got me into music also!! a friend played 'basket case' for me and i was like, this is the weirdest but best music i've ever heard in my life give me some mooooore.

[x1onexwo1fx]

Oh and through being cool is way better than stay what you are. The biggest std fans will agree.

i always thought their albums were neither better nor worse than one another, just different. i think stay what you are is the most historically significant, though.

[ATL182fan]

Sticks and Stones. But I love Stay What You Are too.

[smogs]

This was really hard, but went with TSL cause I still listen to Say It Like You Mean It a lot

[sibby]

Dookie
Leaving through the window
Ocean avenue
all killer no filler
havent listened to the others completely, though NFG and TBS are always pretty good.

[SmeezyBeezy]

Ocean Avenue
Tell All Your Friends
Leaving Through the Window
Stay What You Are
Take This to Your Grave
All Killer No Filler
Say it Like You Mean it
The Room's to Cold
Dookie

That was, really difficult. Seriously.

[not.sad.anymore]

It was actually very easy

1. Leaving Through the Window
2. Ocean Avenue
3. Tell All Your Friends
4. Stay What You Are
5. The Room's too Cold
6. Take This to Your Grave
7. Say it Like You Mean it
8. I can't stand the other 3 albums, so there's no way I could possible rank them

[Vandelay]

Tell All Your Friends
Take This To Your Grave
Dookie
Stay What You Are
The Room's Too Cold
Sticks and Stones
Say It Like You Mean It
Ocean Avenue
Leaving Through The Window
All Killer, No Filler

[Andy Young]

Stay What You Are

[JGood4]

1. Sticks and Stones
2. Take this to your grave
3 .Say it like you mean it
4. Ocean avenue

[Olle.89]

this one was hard...but my vote goes for "Tell All Your Friends"

[CarouselBoy]

maybe this is sad, but all killer no filler was one of the records that drew me into the genre. It was catchy and I was like these dudes are having fun doing whatever they want singing about fun stuff.

[Echo Park]

this is stupid.
Tell All Your Friends, Ocean Avenue, All Killer No Filler

[x1onexwo1fx]

this is stupid.

i'm sorry! :-(

[HelloxAlone]

It was hard to decide between Take This To Your Grave and Dookie, but I had to go with Green Day.

[EvilZeppelin]

you left out ocean avenue.

I would too.

[ManicanParty49]

1) Tell All Your Friends
2) Take This To Your Grave
3) Stay What You Are
4) Say It Like You Mean It
5) Sticks and Stones
6) Leaving Through The Window
7) The Room's Too Cold
8) Dookie
9) All Killer, No Filler

That's how I'd rank it...though I've been in a huge TBS mood lately.

[x1onexwo1fx]

I would too.

:-(

[introduction]

had to be between old tbs and old fob. old tbs wins but only because new fob is a lot better than new tbs.

[bowl of oranges]

I went with FOB.

[Spewk]

Not hard at all. TAYF, Dookie, and Leaving Through the Window are the only ones that should even be considered.

[JoeForPresident]

i'm really happy with the outcome of this poll

[Daigle lol]

This was harder than the last CD poll like this I took.. I couldn't decide between Stay What You Are, Take This To Your Grave or Tell All Your Friends.. all three CD's are ones I can still listen to on a regular basis. I'd have to go with Stay What You Are though.

[aboyandhiscurse]

Why Is The Starting Line Not Winning?!

[wall e]

Too hard!

[muchoawesomeo]

saves the day, easy as pie.

[davehennessy]

Ocean Avenue, hands down. Easily one of the best pop punk records ever made

[jordalsh]

The Room's Too Cold, although TMTMATP is my favorite album of all time.

[pleasedontpanic]

Taking Back Sunday and Saves the Day tie, though I voted for STD as the underdog. However, if NFG's self-titled was on here that would've won.

[gabrielthespic]

dookie is old testament

[Mattylikesfilms]

Stay what you are.

[Mattylikesfilms]

1. Stay What You Are (Saves The Day)
2. Tell All Your Friends (Taking Back Sunday)
3. The Room's Too Cold (The Early November)
4. Sticks and Stones (New Found Glory)
5. Ocean Avenue (Yellowcard)

[Mattylikesfilms]

Taking Back Sunday and Saves the Day tie, though I voted for STD as the underdog. However, if NFG's self-titled was on here that would've won.

NFG's self titled is so underrated..

[pleasedontpanic]

NFG's self titled is so underrated..
I'm so with you man.

[SunnyInPhilly]

Say It Like You Mean It followed closely by Sticks & Stones

[Lunchbox1837]

Stay What You Are...the others just don't compare.

[imelliott]

went with Stay What You Are

[Sandbullet]

Green Day set the standard for all of the other bands on this list

[tkamB]

1. Tell All Your Friends
2. The Room's Too Cold
3. Say It Like You Mean It
4. Stay What You Are
5. All Killer No Filler

[TangledUp]

Great list - but it actually wasn't that hard. Take This To Your Grave for me.

[LikeSwingSets]

i was so stuck between sticks and stones, dookie and aknf.

i went for sticks and stones, although i hate that dude's voice.

[im_FINK]

Not hard at all. Tell All Your Friends ftw.

[TSLROCKS]

Tttyg

[Feenucks]

Tell All Your Friends followed (closely) by Take This To Your Grave.

[SeanEBoy2686]

this is much harder than i expected...


the only album I don't like is Sum 41's

[SuNDaYSTaR]

Tell All Your Friends wins it by a landslide for me.

[JayBee420]

you left out ocean avenue.
I dont know why ocean ave was even on this...

One for the Kids was a million times better than that record.

[x1onexwo1fx]

I dont know why ocean ave was even on this...

One for the Kids was a million times better than that record.

i forgot i even made this thread.

[JayBee420]

i forgot i even made this thread.
im drunken trolling. dont judge.