PDA

View Full Version : All Along the Watchtower

murrich
02/22/10, 01:35 PM
Who does All Along the Watchtower better?
Holly HoX!
02/22/10, 09:46 PM
I'm the biggest Bob Dylan-head. That dude is my idol.
himynameiszack
02/23/10, 06:19 PM
Had to go with Jimi.
Daigle lol
02/24/10, 08:14 AM
Based on the poll title, I answered Bob Dylan.. and then I saw that you wanted to know who did the song better. Have to say Jimi Hendrix
the seventeenth
02/24/10, 11:17 AM
... who are they? (kidding)
but in all honesty bob dylan.
Ari Christos
02/24/10, 08:24 PM
Based on the poll title, I answered Bob Dylan.. and then I saw that you wanted to know who did the song better. Have to say Jimi Hendrix

Same here.
TangledUp
02/25/10, 04:44 AM
Bob is my favorite musician of all time .. but Jimi Hendrix's version is soo much better.
Alex DiVincenzo
02/25/10, 07:42 AM
Hendrix
bastard_of_ness
02/25/10, 07:43 AM
Even Dylan would vote for Hendrix. Come on!
TangledUp
02/25/10, 08:14 AM
I'm the biggest Bob Dylan-head. That dude is my idol.
:thumbup:
Say Nothing
02/25/10, 10:44 AM
Had to go Dylan
Neo Cassady
02/25/10, 02:49 PM
Dylan changed how he played it live so it matched Hendrix's version. That's all that needs to be said.
broaddplease
02/25/10, 05:22 PM
Hendrix, of course.
SuNDaYSTaR
02/25/10, 08:31 PM
Love Dylan with all my heart, but Hendrix's version is out of this world.
aerofan11
02/26/10, 09:13 AM
Dammit!
I voted for this poll on the front page, so I thought the poll asked which artist I preferred.

I much prefer Jimi's version. One of the best covers ever. Dylan's version is still brilliant though.
jbaseball44
02/26/10, 09:19 AM
Being that Dylan wrote it, I would say him
Tim Lincecum
02/26/10, 05:18 PM
hendrix definitely
drudo182
02/28/10, 10:13 AM
Bob Dylan.
jbaseball44
02/28/10, 10:21 AM
Bob Dylan.
Way to go, Drew.
drudo182
02/28/10, 10:26 AM
Way to go, Drew.

There is very little I would not pick Dylan on.
jbaseball44
02/28/10, 10:30 AM
There is very little I would not pick Dylan on.
Agreed.
HometownHero
03/02/10, 02:59 PM
Dylan obviously
Theseventhson
03/03/10, 11:29 AM
I like the Hendrix version of this song better, but I prefer Dylan overall.
not.sad.anymore
03/03/10, 01:02 PM
tough choice. Dylan overall, but I gotta go with Hendrix for Watchtower.
And Hours Pass
03/05/10, 06:19 AM
Even Dylan would vote for Hendrix. Come on!

Dylan changed how he played it live so it matched Hendrix's version. That's all that needs to be said.

These two answers just about do it for me. Gotta be Hendrix. And even if it was "who do you prefer" artist-wise (as some thought it was), for me that would also go to Hendrix.
bastard_of_ness
03/05/10, 07:17 AM
Dylan is/was/will always be a much better songwriter than a performer.
jbaseball44
03/05/10, 09:04 AM
Dylan is/was/will always be a much better songwriter than a performer.
You were around to see him in the 60's and 70's
bastard_of_ness
03/05/10, 10:29 AM
You were around to see him in the 60's and 70's

Fair. I'll switch to is and forever will be... no "was" :)

I have seen performances, but never live, as I'm 28.
muchoawesomeo
03/06/10, 06:16 PM
jimi
map8705
03/08/10, 06:22 AM
Hendrix did all along the watch tower better, even Dylan says that. But I voted for Dylan because I thought it was who do you think is overall better, which is obviously Dylan. I like Hendrix, but he only came out with about 4 albums if I can remember correctly while Dylan has come out with over 30 and written some of the best songs of all time.
Tristan Needler
03/08/10, 06:32 AM
Kind of hard, but I think I like Dylan's better.
Stavie Steelo
03/09/10, 12:53 AM
Jimi
BozzBlonde
03/09/10, 12:28 PM
Jimi Hendrix for sure.