PDA

View Full Version : Peanut Butter: Creamy vs. Chunky

NateFoundGlory
03/04/10, 12:32 PM
As I'm about to make myself some lunch before work, I realize we're all out of chunky peanut butter and I'm stuck with creamy. Which led me to ask the AP community: chunky or creamy peanut butter?

Note: I know there's a poll for this already, but it was back in 06.
muchoawesomeo
03/04/10, 01:05 PM
super chunk
kdefrisc
03/04/10, 01:07 PM
favorite

http://www.themommytimes.com/graphics/LauraScuddersNutty.jpg
Neo Cassady
03/04/10, 01:17 PM
Nutella.
Machu505
03/04/10, 01:39 PM
Creamy or nothing.
SuNDaYSTaR
03/04/10, 03:50 PM
I used to like chunky, but now it makes me puke a little.
MADSTA
03/04/10, 04:50 PM
Chunky is distracting.
muttley
03/04/10, 05:05 PM
I don't eat it often, but when I do, it needs to be very chunky.
Brand-new-123
03/04/10, 05:49 PM
I like both. It really depends on what I'm spreading it on.
cristinaa
03/04/10, 10:10 PM
My whole life I thought chunky was gross, because my family always bought creamy....buy I have come to realize that I like chunky sooo much better.
billyboatkid
03/05/10, 12:00 AM
Creamy, I've never liked chunky.
<*)))><
03/05/10, 08:07 AM
I like my peanut butter to be all peanuts.
E. Clectic
03/05/10, 08:15 AM
super chunk

Yes please.
Tristan Needler
03/05/10, 08:38 AM
Creamy, for sure.
x1onexwo1fx
03/05/10, 09:30 AM
i enjoy both. my mom bought both once, so i'd finish the creamy jar and then open the chunky jar, and once i finished the chunky jar, i'd open another creamy jar.
carnotaurhunter
03/05/10, 09:50 AM
I go both ways.

Also, I usually like creamy, but I'll go chunky if given the opportunity.
And Hours Pass
03/05/10, 03:19 PM
i enjoy both. my mom bought both once, so i'd finish the creamy jar and then open the chunky jar, and once i finished the chunky jar, i'd open another creamy jar.
You're a peanut butter eating machine.
flks511
03/05/10, 03:28 PM
favorite

http://www.themommytimes.com/graphics/LauraScuddersNutty.jpg
Same here.
Smeee
03/06/10, 12:16 PM
Chunky, by so much.
Alex DiVincenzo
03/08/10, 09:03 PM
I prefer chunky
Stavie Steelo
03/08/10, 09:10 PM
Chunky is the best it's not even debatable, having the actual thing in there whats not to like.
JGood4
03/09/10, 04:15 AM
Creamy
BozzBlonde
03/09/10, 12:35 PM
Creamy. Chunky just ruins everything.
fightinirish217
03/09/10, 02:10 PM
Creamy or nothing.

Absolutely correct. Creamy or nothing.
muzicislife31
03/10/10, 05:08 PM
Chunky! Unless it's with Oreos.
klawansie7
03/11/10, 03:55 PM
Creamy, I've never liked chunky.

<3 your avatar.

Chunky! Unless it's with Oreos.

oh good call on the oreos! chucky would be weird with them...
Brokenhill
03/11/10, 06:12 PM
I used to like chunky, but now it makes me puke a little.

Chunky is distracting.

Both of these, especially since they were in a row, made me lol.
Echo Park
03/13/10, 09:27 AM
I like both. It really depends on what I'm spreading it on.
is this some sort of sexual innuendo???
Echo Park
03/13/10, 09:28 AM
has to be chunky. Creamy is weird. It's like chunky without the chunk
Brand-new-123
03/13/10, 09:32 AM
is this some sort of sexual innuendo???
Best poster right here.
Jonnyborg
03/14/10, 06:08 AM
chunky. really, I almost can't believe so many people said creamy. chunky is clearly where the action is.
kbi the crowing
03/14/10, 11:42 AM
Chunky isn't bad, but my teeth are really sensitive, so if I bite down on a chunk in the wrong place it's like biting a pebble.

Creamy all the way.
Brokenhill
03/14/10, 11:36 PM
Actually, the amount of chunky votes surprises me. I never see any one have it in their pantries.
inthemidst
03/15/10, 07:53 AM
Both. I love crunchy, but creamy is easier to spread on toast/bagels.
zachff
03/15/10, 08:24 AM
I went with both. As a kid I only liked creamy but as I've grown up I like crunchy more
chrislauren
03/15/10, 08:30 AM
Nutella.
Nutella is absolutely Godly tasting. But smooth peanut butter is my favorite. I don't think i've ever had chunky anyway.
herecomesthesun
03/15/10, 12:53 PM
has to be chunky. Creamy is weird. It's like chunky without the chunk
..making it..creamy..no chunk. :-|
Echo Park
03/15/10, 12:55 PM
..making it..creamy..no chunk. :-|
it was a joke:-(
Mandee, darling
03/15/10, 12:57 PM
I don't eat peanut butter much, but when I do, it's gotta be creamy.
herecomesthesun
03/15/10, 12:59 PM
it was a joke:-(
i figured haha
drawndead
03/15/10, 01:44 PM
Chunky
songydarko
03/16/10, 10:51 AM
Nutella.
YEP.
derekmoyer4
03/16/10, 11:58 AM
creamy.

i ask this: would you want your butter to have chunks in it?

note: i know it is not the same, but still.
MyNameIsRoss
03/16/10, 12:48 PM
Skippy...and creamy
Gregory Robson
03/17/10, 07:15 AM
Creamy. Hands down.
HometownHero
03/17/10, 11:56 AM
I said creamy because if I do have to eat that nastiness I'd rather not have to chew
nomad1755
03/17/10, 12:41 PM
when i was a young lad, my mum used to make chunky peanut butter sandwiches, with regular butter on top, no joke, i look back now and wanna puke