PDA

View Full Version : Comeback MLB Player of the Year

StandMyBrothers
07/30/06, 04:47 PM
This is very tough, but I'm going to give it to Rocco Baldelli. That dude's been lights out since his return to the Majors. Magglio Ordonez is a very close second though. Yours?
bigmike
07/30/06, 04:48 PM
...Nomar Garciaparra?
...Jim Thome?
fcknazisympathy
07/30/06, 04:50 PM
This is very tough, but I'm going to give it to Jim Thome. That dude's been lights out since his return to the Majors. Nomar Garciaparra is a very close second though. Yours?

I concur
StandMyBrothers
07/30/06, 04:56 PM
...Nomar Garciaparra?
...Jim Thome?
me=just got back from vacation an hour ago, got a slight sympton of braindead
xbrokendownx
07/30/06, 05:04 PM
nomar
bigmike
07/30/06, 05:17 PM
me=just got back from vacation an hour ago, got a slight sympton of braindead
ahh. it's alright.
mikeford
07/30/06, 05:19 PM
nomar is hurt again.

lol
justinevans
07/30/06, 05:38 PM
jim thome
Yankees' #1 Fan
07/30/06, 06:04 PM
thome
KB3RG
07/30/06, 07:31 PM
Thome : I would have said Nomar but he hasnt really done much since the all star break and it doesnt help him hes on the DL again
Broken Parachute
07/30/06, 08:27 PM
Jim Thome
bigal00004
07/30/06, 08:38 PM
I think Thome. but Nomar is certainly close.
The Matt Kaufman
07/31/06, 05:29 AM
Beltran?
TheDeekay
07/31/06, 08:12 AM
Jim Thome or Magglio Ordonez
For pitching, Tom Glavine and Mike Mussina's season have really suprised me. I never would have guess they'd be doing this well.
The Matt Kaufman
07/31/06, 08:17 AM
Jim Thome or Magglio Ordonez
For pitching, Tom Glavine and Mike Mussina's season have really suprised me. I never would have guess they'd be doing this well.

Glavine has cooled off a bit though..he hasnt won in his last 8 stars (I think?)
bigmike
07/31/06, 10:35 AM
Beltran?
No. sucking for an entire year and then fulfilling your potential doesn't mean you've come back from anything.
Broken Parachute
07/31/06, 10:42 AM
Glavine has cooled off a bit though..he hasnt won in his last 8 stars (I think?) He hasn't lost in his last 6 or 7 starts or something. They've either been no decisions or wins.

No. sucking for an entire year and then fulfilling your potential doesn't mean you've come back from anything.
Yeah, if he was injured last year..definitely.
The Matt Kaufman
07/31/06, 12:40 PM
He hasn't lost in his last 6 or 7 starts or something. They've either been no decisions or wins.


Yeah, if he was injured last year..definitely.

yeah thats why I thought he would be a good candidate..esp if the Mets win the pennant etc