What's Your favorite record by the one & only: Motion City Soundtrack

[xtheaudition]

let
the
voting
begin
!!!!!

(you only get 1 vote, so choose wisely!)

[SpyKi]

I'm pretty sure I'm in the minority but I'm going for Even If It Kills Me. I still haven't given IATM many listens though so that could become my favourite in time.

[reckoner]

IATM but this is very tough. CTTM and MDL were very solid.

[Neo Cassady]

CTTM > IATM > EIKM. Haven't listened to MDL. And since we're doing MCS acronyms, LG FUAD > everything else.

[vincent182]

Can't get into Dinosaur....

[phil19]

i am the movie. though i havnt heard my dinosaur life

[fightinirish217]

All of them...

Okay, voted for EIIKM and I know I'll be in the minority here. CTTM and IATM are great records too obviously. Still trying to get into My Dinosaur Life.

[SLoT]

It was Commit... until I got ahold of My Dinosaur Life. As they grow older, so do I. Therefore it's time to move on from Commit no matter how good it was to me when it came out, and understand how good My Dinosaur Life is for where I'm at in life now.

[herestoyoufla]

Definitely commit this to memory...

[InvisibleImage]

this band isnt that good.

[cristinaa]

I like Even If It Kills Me best.

[HoldThatSound]

commit this to memeory > i am the movie > my dino life > even if it kills me

I love them all except even if it kills me is... meh lol

[SpyKi]

I like Even If It Kills Me best.
Okay, voted for EIIKM and I know I'll be in the minority here. CTTM and IATM are great records too obviously. Still trying to get into My Dinosaur Life.
Brofist.

[seraph1214]

IATM > MDL > EIIKM > CTTM x

[xtheaudition]

this band isnt that good.

and you could do better?

[11:11]

Hmm...probably CTTM > IATM > EIIKM > MDL, but I enjoy all of them. MDL could move up in the line because I haven't listened to it very much.

[xtheaudition]

Hmm...probably CTTM > IATM > EIIKM > MDL, but I enjoy all of them. MDL could move up in the line because I haven't listened to it very much.
my dinosaur life is loads better than even if it kills me imo.

[SpyKi]

my dinosaur life is loads better than even if it kills me imo.
even if it kills me is loads better than my dinosaur life imo.

[xtheaudition]

YDodJuuSrr4

classic. :-)

[himynameiszack]

Commit This to Memory.

[klawansie7]

YDodJuuSrr4

classic. :-)
i never got into this song until a few months ago, and now it's tied for my favorite MCS song (with time turned fragile). everything about it is just completely perfect, I can't believe it took me so long to realize that.

also, CTTM>IAMT>MDL>EIKM, but i still really like EIKM. just not their best work, i don't think.

[lucky#88]

love 'em all but

CTTM>IATM=MDL>EIIKM

[phaserstostun]

It was Commit... until I got ahold of My Dinosaur Life. As they grow older, so do I. Therefore it's time to move on from Commit no matter how good it was to me when it came out, and understand how good My Dinosaur Life is for where I'm at in life now.

This may come out creepy but... we are the same person.

[vivatoto56]

I never got into this band but I see the appeal.

I however really liked Dinosaur Life, in particular History Lesson, which is one of my favorite songs of all time.

[nathaniel]

They are all freaking, freaking amazing.

[MADSTA]

commit this to memeory > i am the movie > my dino life > even if it kills me

I love them all except even if it kills me is... meh lol
Opinion twinz.

[roughroads]

I'm pretty sure I'm in the minority but I'm going for Even If It Kills Me. I still haven't given IATM many listens though so that could become my favourite in time.

Don't worry you're not completely alone there.
Though I thoroughly enjoyed every MCS album but I gotta say Even If It Kills Me takes the cake.
It's just beautiful, start to finish.

[Indoor Living]

Commit. No song will ever hit me as hard as "Together We'll Ring In The New Year" did the first time I heard it. It's my all-time favorite song. All three of their other albums are extremely close behind though. They're 4 for 4 with four homers in my book.

[xtheaudition]

i never got into this song until a few months ago, and now it's tied for my favorite MCS song (with time turned fragile). everything about it is just completely perfect, I can't believe it took me so long to realize that.

also, CTTM>IAMT>MDL>EIKM, but i still really like EIKM. just not their best work, i don't think.

really? my fav accident is what got me into them! and i like the same album order as you! almost... i like i am the movie then commit.

[SLoT]

This may come out creepy but... we are the same person.
Haha! I've been trying to figure out how to say what I said since I heard the new album. I just didn't think anyone would understand... thank you, er..wait.. me.

[Maiaophilia]

CTTM - easily.

[klawansie7]

really? my fav accident is what got me into them! and i like the same album order as you! almost... i like i am the movie then commit.
ohh i didn't get into them until commit had already came out, make out kids is what got me into them, since it was on the warped tour 2005 compilation album. i didn't actually get into IATM until the last year or so.

[heathkliff]

I am the Movie>My Dinosaur Life>Commit this to Memory>Even if it Kills Me

I'm seeing them this weekend for the first time since CTTM came out, and damnit, if they don't play a good deal of that first album, I'm gonna be majorly bummed.

[xtheaudition]

ohh i didn't get into them until commit had already came out, make out kids is what got me into them, since it was on the warped tour 2005 compilation album. i didn't actually get into IATM until the last year or so.
ahh gotcha! i am the movie is the first one i bought! =D

[xtheaudition]

even if it kills me is getting raped!

[SpyKi]

even if it kills me is getting raped!

:-(

[BozzBlonde]

Since I've listened to My Dinosaur Life, I've been able to enjoy the older albums now.

[danman]

love 'em all but

CTTM>IATM=MDL>EIIKM

exactly what i came in here to say

[danman]

I never got into this band but I see the appeal.

I however really liked Dinosaur Life, in particular History Lesson, which is one of my favorite songs of all time.

History Lesson?! Oh noooooo. That's my least favorite song by them of all time I think hahah.

[Mattylikesfilms]

Can't get into Dinosaur....

I love that album! I was a huge fan of the debut (IATM) and thought commit this to memory was just ok, but then Even If It kills me came out and I hated that album. My Dinosaur Life has brought me back as a fan.

[notoaststereo]

commit this to memeory, i am the movie, my dinosaur life, even if it kills me.

[tonighttonight0]

IAtM

[xtheaudition]

keep voting! =D

[lucky#88]

exactly what i came in here to say
well you sir have impeccable taste.

[imtherealdave]

I wanted to vote for them all, but I went with CTTM

[runningohfive]

I Am The Movie is awesome, but I loved their other albums as well.

[SuNDaYSTaR]

Commit This To Memory FTW.

[Rustash]

Commit This To Memory. I have so many memories tied in with that album, and the nostalgia of listening to it brings me back everytime.

CTTM>IATM>EIIKM=MDL

I enjoyed Even If It Kills Me a hell of alot, it was my favorite for awhile and i never really understood the hate for it. And i really like My Dinosaur Life, but i feel like they've definitely done better, not as many songs struck me as particularly memorable but still an amazing album all in all.

[uglystar03]

I never got into this band but I see the appeal.

I however really liked Dinosaur Life, in particular History Lesson, which is one of my favorite songs of all time.

Really? History Lesson is probably my least favorite MCS song ever.

This poll is pretty tough. EIIKM contains my favorite MCS songs (It Had To Be You, Last Night, The Conversation), but I feel like the album isn't consistent. I love CTTM but it's grown old. MDL is still too new to tell if it is my favorite.

So I guess it would go a little something like this:
CTTM>EIIKM>MDL>IATM

[vivatoto56]

Really? History Lesson is probably my least favorite MCS song ever.

This poll is pretty tough. EIIKM contains my favorite MCS songs (It Had To Be You, Last Night, The Conversation), but I feel like the album isn't consistent. I love CTTM but it's grown old. MDL is still too new to tell if it is my favorite.

So I guess it would go a little something like this:
CTTM>EIIKM>MDL>IATM

That seems to be what every MCS fan is saying.

Since I'm not a fan of them it would make sense I like it so much.

[Chris92]

The vote totals are spot on, thus far...

[TheClockSounds]

Commit This To Memory, always but my dinosaur life is my second favorite

[pnkhrdwndr]

Voted Commit. But All their albums are just as good but in different ways.
Definitely one of my favorite bands
And History Lesson Is also their worst song by far, I skip it every time

[SeanEBoy2686]

Commit This To Memory... but Even If It Kills Me has my favorite MCS song on it. None of the albums are bad by any stretch of the imagination though.

[takeaction]

My professor was wearing a Motion City Soundtrack last Thursday. He's probably in his 40s.

[muttley]

I Am The Movie > My Dinosaur Life > Even If It Kills Me ≥ Commit This To Memory

[Bruised26]

Eiikm >/= Cttm >> Mdl>>>> Iatm

[xtheaudition]

My professor was wearing a Motion City Soundtrack last Thursday. He's probably in his 40s.
you should ask him what his favorite album is

[TSLROCKS]

I've only been able to get into My Dinosaur Life. I really should go back and listen to the others again

[takeaction]

you should ask him what his favorite album is
lol maybe if I go to office hours or something. Me: "Hey,uh, I saw you wearing a Motion City Soundtrack shirt last week... What's your favorite album?" I can just imagine how awkward that would be asking lol.

[xtheaudition]

lol maybe if I go to office hours or something. Me: "Hey,uh, I saw you wearing a Motion City Soundtrack shirt last week... What's your favorite album?" I can just imagine how awkward that would be asking lol.
definitely!!!

[VIVALAMATT]

Even If It Kills Me is by far their strongest record.

I don't see how anyone could dislike that record, start to finish.

I'd say My Dinosaur Life is a close second. Then Commit.

[stereokiller]

i'm with the majority here although the rest are close seconds.

I don't think I can live as happy as this if I didn't own the MCS discog. Most of their songs were the soundtracks of my life.

[GamEin]

I Am The Movie.

[anamericangod]

CTTM is fucking classic.

[Gregory Robson]

Definitely commit this to memory...
Amen, brother.

[TheSkyline]

Went with IATM, but I love MDL. And obviously CTTM is awesome as well. Cant get into EIIKM though.

[wall e]

Iatm.

[xtheaudition]

iatm<3

[gr33ndayfr3ak]

It was Commit... until I got ahold of My Dinosaur Life. As they grow older, so do I. Therefore it's time to move on from Commit no matter how good it was to me when it came out, and understand how good My Dinosaur Life is for where I'm at in life now.

Exactly.

[xkristenxchaosx]

i haven't listened to all of my dinosaur life yet, but i really like all of their albums.

[yellowhouse]

I Am The Movie. Each of their albums has gotten progressively worse since then, although I do enjoy Commit This To Memory also.

[xtheaudition]

Even If It Kills Me never had a chance..

[danofthedead]

Even if it Kills Me. It's like they're on a bell curve for me. IATM < CTTM < EIKM > MDL. Last Night on EIIKM is absolutely incredible songwriting. It's like an orchestra slowly building into brilliance and then it all comes together so perfectly.

That being said, A-OK on IATM is one of my favorite album enders, and My Favorite Accident is one of the best live songs to be a part of.

[SpyKi]

Even if it Kills Me. It's like they're on a bell curve for me. IATM < CTTM < EIKM > MDL. Last Night on EIIKM is absolutely incredible songwriting. It's like an orchestra slowly building into brilliance and then it all comes together so perfectly.

That being said, A-OK on IATM is one of my favorite album enders, and My Favorite Accident is one of the best live songs to be a part of.
Agree with all.

[introduction]

My Dinosaur Life blows away anything else they've done, in my opinion of course.

[xtheaudition]

dino life is awesome!

[Yellowcard2006]

1 I Am The Movie
2 Even If It Kills Me
3 Commit
4 Dinosaur

[tttygxlove]

It was between CTTM and MDL, but CTTM won for me. I really like everything they put out, tough choice!

[himynameisjohn3]

Commit.

[xtheaudition]

1 I Am The Movie
2 Even If It Kills Me
3 Commit
4 Dinosaur
really?
dinosaur is tight!

[bowl of oranges]

IATM > CTTM > MDL > EEIKM

x

[Indoor Living]

I've come to figure out that Calling All Cops is the only song of theirs I'll skip.

[DCFCutie]

My Dinosaur Life is so bad.
So disappointed in it. I'm surprised it's beating Even If It Kills Me.

Commit This To Memory of course.

[squee42]

It's so incredibly hard for me to choose, I think I have to pick Even If It Kills Me simply because it was the album that got me listening to them.

[xtheaudition]

My Dinosaur Life is so bad.
So disappointed in it. I'm surprised it's beating Even If It Kills Me.

Commit This To Memory of course.
its WAY better than even if it kills me.

[FallOutWeeze]

Even if it kills Me and My Dinosaur Life are the only ones I can listen to all the way through. sorry, but Commit This to Memory and I'am the Movie have a few songs I tend to skip

[SpyKi]

its WAY better than even if it kills me.
disagree.

[Yellowcard2006]

really?
dinosaur is tight!
Yeah but MCS is one of my favorite bands so that album is still a 9/10. But I really love EIIKM and CTTM has "Hold Me Down" on it. So that's where MDL lands for now.

[xtheaudition]

Yeah but MCS is one of my favorite bands so that album is still a 9/10. But I really love EIIKM and CTTM has "Hold Me Down" on it. So that's where MDL lands for now.
that's understandable.

[themagicrat]

I think each record is incredible for its own reasons. That being said, Mark Hoppus really does seem to bring out the best in this band and My Dinosaur Life is a much tighter and cleaner record than Commit This To Memory.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Commit > Dinosaur > Movie > Kills Me

[Formatfun]

COMMIT THIS TO MEMORY

because Everything is Alright and L.G. Fuad are on it... which are two of my favorite songs by them.

[drawndead]

I am The Movie I guess

[xtheaudition]

damn commit this to memory passed 200!

[zachff]

1. Commit this to Memory
2. Even if it Kills Me
3. I am the Movie
4. My Dinosaur Life

[DCFCutie]

its WAY better than even if it kills me.

I really don't see whats so bad about EIIKM

[xtheaudition]

I really don't see whats so bad about EIIKM
just the songs in general are not good imo. some i dig though! but the album as a whole sucks.

[anthonydarko]

Even If It Kills Me is the one record of theirs I can relate to the most so it got my vote.

[xtheaudition]

holy shit alot of people voted for commit this to memory

[M1ndset]

Commit this to Memeory is the most amazing album written about modern life. Ever. Every single note echoes something tragic real and meaningful. And if you have ever relied on self medication Justin is your fucking hero. The vocals will never be duplicated again. And the synth is fucking beautiful. I spin that album religiously and every single time I discover more and more things in my existence that relate to that album. Best album ever.

[avarice14]

Iatm>mdl>cttm>eiikm