But you, you were my favorite.

[liveloud4life]

Which of these less-talked-about Coheed songs is your favorite?

Just listening through their catalogue these are always some of my favorites, but from my experience generally aren't the consensus favorites.

[jonwangcb]

Backend of Forever and Willing Well II are two of their greatest and most underappreciated songs ever. Willing Well II would be my favorite ever if it weren't for the first 2 verses. The rest of that song is brilliant.

[liveloud4life]

Backend of Forever and Willing Well II are two of their greatest and most underappreciated songs ever. Willing Well II would be my favorite ever if it weren't for the first 2 verses. The rest of that song is brilliant.

I'm not sure what about those verses makes them worse than other Coheed lyrics. Enlighten me.

[phil19]

3 evils is my fav coheed song

[xapplexpiex]

Three Evils. I think my favorite Coheed song is IKSOSE:3. Such an epic 8+ minute song.

[Mandee, darling]

willing well 1... it's so complex and i love it.

[liveloud4life]

willing well 1... it's so complex and i love it.

Dude, me too. It's just like one epic riff after another.

[Goat01]

Three Evils is one of my favorite Coheed songs period.

[badazzbuddy117]

3 evils. "pull the trigger and the nightmare stops"

[MattDennis]

Willing Well I easily. Probably my favorite movement out of all the Coheed suites.

[SeanEBoy2686]

three evils is my favorite coheed song... so it's easily my choice out of these too.

[You Got Owned]

willing well 1, such a fantastic song

[Mandee, darling]

Dude, me too. It's just like one epic riff after another.

exactly. how could you not enjoy a song that has extreme twists and turns.. and the way it's sung is spectacular.

[jonwangcb]

I'm not sure what about those verses makes them worse than other Coheed lyrics. Enlighten me.

Its not the lyrics, its the melody. Its too poppy...and not Coheed poppy...its just bad poppy, in my opinion. Also sounds a lot like Strung Short, so basically, he used a melody that he had basically written a decade before.

[tonyC4L]

Camper Velourium!

"Is this weird? Do I scare her?" gives me chills every time.

[liveloud4life]

Its not the lyrics, its the melody. Its too poppy...and not Coheed poppy...its just bad poppy, in my opinion. Also sounds a lot like Strung Short, so basically, he used a melody that he had basically written a decade before.

I don't hear that at all. I think that has amazing melody. As for Strung Short, I haven't heard it so I can't speak for that.

[hurryupbrett]

Over and out, Connecticut

[xtheaudition]

3 evilz!

[Toothache]

backend of forever

[SuNDaYSTaR]

Almost went with Three Evils, song is really good, but From Fear won it for me.

[barkingincision]

Fuel is rad

Three Evils does not belong

[liveloud4life]

Fuel is rad

Three Evils does not belong

I was kinda thinking that after I looked at the whole list. I didn't realize it was that many people's favorite.

[Scrandon]

Welcome Home

[Rustash]

I'm just glad On The Brink isn't winning :-p

[kbi the crowing]

Oh god, I don't know if I'll be able to pick between Willing Well I and Backend of Forever.
Three Evils is also very good, but those two are in my tops.
Hopefully I can choose one later haha

[liveloud4life]

Welcome Home

Way to miss the point as much as humanly possible.

[Scrandon]

Way to miss the point as much as humanly possible.

Lol i got it -just was being difficult

[frenchatticus]

First time I ever heard Coheed was Three Evils on the Warped 04 Comp. Gotta go with that one, so sick.

[FUCKDIRTYWIPES]

three evils

[kbi the crowing]

Deciding on Backend of Forever, although Willing Well I is still super close.

[brencore]

I originally downloaded In Keeping Secrets... before anything else and I loved it, but it was missing two tracks, Cuts Marked In The March Of Men and Three Evils. When I finally got around to buying it and I heard those two tracks, I was blown away, they fitted so well.

[liveloud4life]

Lol i got it -just was being difficult

Oh you. Damn kids. Jk

[SteveD]

On The Brink. Love that song so much.

[liveloud4life]

On The Brink. Love that song so much.

Me too. I was starting to wonder if anyone else thought so. It's so tasty and bluesy and it's a pretty emotional end to the story.

[SteveD]

Me too. I was starting to wonder if anyone else thought so. It's so tasty and bluesy and it's a pretty emotional end to the story.

Completely agree. NWFT gets too much hate IMO. It's a solid album. I love it. YOTBR on the other hand......ugh.

[liveloud4life]

Completely agree. NWFT gets too much hate IMO. It's a solid album. I love it. YOTBR on the other hand......ugh.

See, I don't understand the hate on any of the albums. If you put aside what you wanted them to do and the desire for them to stay the same there's a different genius to all of them. I think that's entirely too many people's problem with alot of bands. He is Legend, anyone?

[jonwangcb]

I don't hear that at all. I think that has amazing melody. As for Strung Short, I haven't heard it so I can't speak for that.

here you go! you should check out the shabutie stuff...some of its pretty good. according to nate kelly (coheed's original drummer), this song is about claudio's insecurity over his small penis...i'm glad he adopted the story line.
9Lbir8n3KMU

[liveloud4life]

here you go! you should check out the shabutie stuff...some of its pretty good. according to nate kelly (coheed's original drummer), this song is about claudio's insecurity over his small penis...i'm glad he adopted the story line.

Lmao that recording is awful. My garage band stuff sounds ten times better than that. Pretty good song though.

[sasalukac]

Three Evils. I think my favorite Coheed song is IKSOSE:3. Such an epic 8+ minute song.

this

[wall e]

Three Evils, the song that got me into them in the first place.

[CollyLullaby]

three evils is so awesome ^_^ in keeping secrets is the best album I think

[sevinw0rds]

See, I don't understand the hate on any of the albums. If you put aside what you wanted them to do and the desire for them to stay the same there's a different genius to all of them. I think that's entirely too many people's problem with alot of bands. He is Legend, anyone?

Totally agree about the unwarranted backlash they got for Suck Out The Poison. I Am Hollywood is one of the most fun records to listen to, but they got serious on SOTP and people just hated them for it. I love that they had a sense of humor about it and displayed that in the video for "Dungeon Witch."

On topic, "Three Evils." I was a bit surprised to see it on the list after the reaction the song got when Claudio played the first chords last night, but I guess someone in the thread addressed that already. The last minute and a half is sooooo amazing.

[liveloud4life]

Totally agree about the unwarranted backlash they got for Suck Out The Poison. I Am Hollywood is one of the most fun records to listen to, but they got serious on SOTP and people just hated them for it. I love that they had a sense of humor about it and displayed that in the video for "Dungeon Witch."

On topic, "Three Evils." I was a bit surprised to see it on the list after the reaction the song got when Claudio played the first chords last night, but I guess someone in the thread addressed that already. The last minute and a half is sooooo amazing.

Yeah, bad call. It used to be my favorite and I didn't realize it was so widely popular. I'm goin to see them on sat. SO stoked.

[aboyandhiscurse]

three evils is godly. i got to see it live a couple times too.

[theNatetron]

3 evils is what got me into coheed