PDA

View Full Version : Ap(Alternative Press) Reviews That are wrong

mysensesfailed3
09/04/06, 03:54 PM
I personally think that Atreyu-Deathgrip On Yesterday(It got a 4) should have gotten a one. what do you guys think are other bad reviews from the mag?
a speedo model
09/04/06, 04:01 PM
reviews are all based on the reviewer's opinion. so bitching about them is pointless.
FOBPrettyNPunk
09/04/06, 04:41 PM
They gave A City Divided By The Light a 5/5 :unsure:
Zeran
09/04/06, 05:26 PM
They gave A City Divided By The Light a 5/5 :unsure:

why
Alt_fate83
09/13/06, 07:47 PM
"A Deathgrip on yesterday" deserves what it got
Branevember31
09/17/06, 11:57 AM
The Early November- The Room's Too Cold got a 2
Hellogoodbye got a 5

they suck at reviewing everything.
youcomebeforeyo
09/19/06, 12:45 AM
I can't be bothered digging out my AP mags to see what I disagree with but if they gave Catch for us the Foxes by mewithoutYou anything less than 5 that was wrong.

ACBTLD I didn't really agree on either, 3-3.5 imo.
The Revisionist
09/23/06, 12:08 AM
How can a signature be ignorant?
a speedo model
09/23/06, 08:39 AM
How can a signature be ignorant?
haha
konstantine94
09/23/06, 04:42 PM
they gave cartel's chroma a 2. i thought that was reallly stupid. and i think houston calls got a bad review too. they seem to give all the crappier pop punk albums good reviews.
takingbackrufio
09/25/06, 12:20 AM
New Foung Glory got a 4/5. I thought that was pretty close.

Also, one of the reviewers for Rolling Stone ripped into the Killers' new album.